Saturday, 20 September 2014
Graham Edwards, Talus and the Frozen King (2014)
Some time ago, prompted I think largely by the global success of Ellis Peters’ Brother Cadfael novels, many writers cast about for historical periods into which to embed their investigating detectives. For a while a great many whodunits got themselves written starring Victorian, Tudor, eighteenth-century, Ancient Roman and so on detectives. Then the vogue fizzled out—Peters died in 1995, and the historical whodunit form has largely gone out of fashion (Death Comes to Pemberly style exercises aside). Still, even when this kind of sub-genre was in vogue I don’t think anybody thought of writing a prehistorical detective, conceivably because the elevator pitch sounds, well, stupid. (What's that you say, Mitchell-and-Webb? Ah yes: 'Caveman Detective!’)
Graham Edwards’ Talus and the Frozen King has decided to plug that gap, whether or not you realised it was a gap that needed plugging: ‘Introducing the World’s First Detective’, declares the cover shout-line. Caveman detective, indeed! Now, Edwards is a veteran writer of genre Fantasy, and knows how to put a story together—it’s not Nabokov, but neither does it shirk its storytelling puzzle-box responsibilities. Talus is a sort-of rhapsode, travelling about with his companion, Bran. Once upon a time fire rained from the sky, ruining his left hand; Bran saved his life and now they have a special Caveholmes-and-Wats-ugh! thing going on. In this case, the mystery is a Warrior King frozen to death on a mysterious island called Creyak. The murderer could be any one of the king’s six scheming sons, or perhaps one of the other prominent islanders. Talus investigates. Edwards’ idea here is that detection is a matter of telling oneself stories, and that Talus has a more advanced story-telling lobe in his brain than many of his fellow cavecitizens.
It’s not entirely to Edwards’s discredit that his imagined prehistory feels underpowered compared to a book like Kim Stanley Robinson’s recent Shaman. It’s bound to, of course. This is not a matter of specific historical anachronisms; it is a matter of tone—characters chatting on with one another like Agatha Christie ciphers in bearskins, saying deeply unNeolithic things like ‘is it true what they say, that Love survives death?’ [14] and ‘our work here is done’ [265] or Talus doing a Columbo impression (‘Just as the morning fog was folding itself around Cabarrath’s retreating form, Talus called, “Actually, I have just thought of another question”’ [151]). That’s all fine. Puzzle-whodunits are a game, and it’s boorish to complain about the rules. If you don’t want to play, don’t play. Still: I retain my reservations.
I’m assuming from the style of the title that Edwards is planning a long string of ‘Talus and the …’ murder mysteries set in prehistoric Scotland. Who knows; it could become a Thing. The problem I have with this novel is the problem I had with Brother Cadfael, back in the day. It is, fundamentally, a Foucauldian problem. The structures of detection are part of a larger episteme of mass surveillance and discipline. The lone detective figures, paradoxically, not as a solitary genius, but precisely as the epitome of the larger social forces of industrialisation and embourgeoisification, and the carceral episteme they entail. That’s the name of the game, and it misfits a pre-bourgeois world as glaringly as if Talus rode onto Creyak on a unicycle smoking a cheroot and singing an a capella version of Depeche Mode’s ‘Master and Servant’. The detective—the Holmes, the Poirot, the Rebus—is the externalisation of the principle of imprisonment; he (and usually, it is he, for reasons to do with the close structural connections between patriarchal authority and Capitalist society) intervenes in the free play of libidinal anarchy represented by the murder, and imposes the narrative-deductive grid that is his defining feature. It is entirely uncoincidental, given this discursive logic, that successful whodunit writers end up manufacturing a great quantity of mass-produced items—the seemingly endless production line that churns out Poirot novels, Cadfael novels, Maigret novels, not to mention the myriad ‘Inspector X and the Y’ style novels. ‘Is it surprising,’ Foucault asked rhetorically, in Discipline and Punish 'that prisons resemble factories, schools, barracks, hospitals, which all resemble prisons?’
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

I could add: despite some shaman goings on, and references to the 'afterdream' as a kind of mystic dimension, this is a novel wholly without a Fantasy genre aspect to it. Which is fine -- it is a whodunit. But, you know. Not Fantasy.
ReplyDeleteThe lone detective figures, paradoxically, not as a solitary genius, but precisely as the epitome of the larger social forces of industrialisation and embourgeoisification, and the carceral episteme they entail.
ReplyDeleteI sense you're reaching the "blog like no one's reading" stage. It's a good stage.
Phil: LOL
ReplyDeleteWhat's your opinion on The Name of the Rose? Granted not a series, but a medieval mystery (of sorts) by a novelist who knows his Foucault, if anything, too well. Do you think this sort of historical mystery can really only work in the postmodern, self-conscious, ironic Eco-ian mode?
ReplyDeleteAs regards the carceral episteme, I'm reminded of Auden's comments in Murder in the Vicarage that, although he hated the death penalty in real life, he heartily approved of its tidiness in fiction. And it seems to me that most fictional detectives I know have at least once or twice let the criminal "get away with it."
There's a Wimsey in which Lord Peter sends the murderer away rather than calling the police; Lord P's logic is that, since the killer has let down his underworld allies, he'll end up just as dead that way, but sooner and with less stress and anxiety.
ReplyDeleteAs for TNOTR, there's a certain kind of book which - as our host wrote of M John Harrison's Light - is always about what it's about, or rather about the idea of fiction being about what this fiction purports to be about (if that's any clearer). To put it another way, you can never quite get behind what it's doing, because there's always the sneaking suspicion that it's about what it's doing. TNOTR for me falls into the less interesting category of fiction that's about the idea of fiction being about anything.