Monday, 1 September 2014
Lucy Saxon, Take Back the Skies (2014)
'Damning with faint praise' is a peculiar idiom, isn't it? When I eventually slip down that facile avernus slope and find myself in Hell, I might well consider myself lucky, on balance, if the chief tormenting devil limits himself to a tart 'well your dress-sense isn't that bad, considering you're a straight, middle-aged academic'; or to saying something passive-aggressive about my hair-do. Shouldn't we expect something a bit more, well, damnatory? What is so bad about inflecting our praise? I suppose our mind's-eye is drawn to the 'faint' rather than the 'praise' part. It could be that we're so down-and-trodden, so used to being criticised, that we've forgotten what 'praise' even looks like. Or is it faintness itself to which we are allergic? How deep into our assumptions has it sunk, that fundamentally evangelical belief that the only proper response to anything is vehemence? So then because thou art lukewarm and neither cold nor hot I will spue thee out of my mouth? 'Faintness' is where many of the most beautiful aesthetic effects are found; pastels and watercolours, nuance and subtlety. What is 'faintness' but a treading lightly, rather than going galumphing on? What is it except an mode of anti-extremism?
You can tell what's coming. Because faint praise is all I can muster for this novel. It's a debut, written by its author at the age of sixteen. Which is a genuinely impressive thing: I mean, not only planning a novel and sketching out maps of one's own Fantasyland (which is what I was doing at sixteen) but actually writing and finishing the whole thing; and then getting it picked up by a major publisher and turned into an actual book in real bookshops. And it's not a wholly terrible novel. It stands comparison with many other commercially produced fantasies. It's set here:
This is sort-of 18th-century Europe, except with robots ('mecha') and television and, most of all, flying sailing ships that soar through the skies. Our heroine is Lucy Hunter, daughter of a posh 'Anglya' family, which nation is to all intents and purposes at aerial war with Mericus. The war means that the children of poor people (not rich people, though) are press-ganged at regular intervals, which is causing a quantity of social unrest. But Lucy's more immediate worry is that her father wishes to marry her off to some brattish young man. So she dresses as a boy, calls herself 'Cat' and stows-away aboard the sky-ship Stormdancer. So let the expected adventures escape and flee/rolling along the grooves of genre Fantasy. There's a lot of stuff chucked-in, and much of it can be dna-tested and located in the reading that its author has done. It's no surprise that a teenage author writes a story about how the war-mongering government cannot be trusted: this is a post-Blair fantasy novel, in which 'war' is a big lie designed to make the lives of adolescents horrible. Nor is it a surprise that 'Cat', by sheer force of her specialness, is able to turn the tide against a system that has dominated for decades. Wish-fulfilment fantasy is a fine and doubtless psychologically healthy business. I've been scolded for lacking a proper sense of 'fun' before, and with good cause.
But there's that other sense of 'faint' which connotes 'mediocre'; and of course that's where the real force of 'damning with faint praise' kicks in. Take Back the Skies isn't a very good novel. Stylistically there are too many adjectives and adverbs; too much telling and hardly any showing; expression reverts so frequently to cliché that it becomes a default: Cat feels sick in 'the pit of her stomach'; a cross person has 'a face like thunder'; eyes linger wistfully, or are rolled ('Fox scoffed, rolling his eyes'), teeth are gritted, gasps are stifled. The pacing is all to whack (as I believe the technical term has it). I would have liked more stuff actually on the rather nicely imagined 'skyships' and less faffing around on the ground, and I would have liked that faffing to be less predictable and generic. The love-story is very much wibble-wibble, only partially redeemed by an unexpected tragic ending. Fainter and fainter, I could neither greatly love or greatly hate this novel. But then, I am, as the Devil in the first paragraph pointed out, a balding middle-aged geezer. It might just be that a gushing, gnashing YA-romance steampunk fantasy of 'one special teenage girl' leading a world revolution against governmental corruption isn't really aimed at readers like me. So, you know: pinch of salt and all that.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


No comments:
Post a Comment