My review of this title is up on Strange Horizons today. Snip:
The front cover of my copy comes with a "notice me!" big red sticker announcing "soon to be a major motion picture, starring Emma Watson." The flap-copy doubles down on this boast: "film rights have been acquired by Warner Brothers, who will reunite 'Harry Potter' team of producer David Hayman and star Emma Watson." Not that Watson will be well cast as far as this role is concerned. One thing the novel insists upon, with a weirdly insistent repetition, is how plain-looking Kelsea is: tall and dark, but heavy-set and unpretty. The handsome Fetch assures her that he's not romantically interested in her ("You're far too plain for my taste," [p. 66]); and her fencing master is downright rude ("'You require conditioning, Lady. You'll never be as lithe as a dancer, but you'd move faster if you carried less weight.' Kelsea flushed and quickly turned away. She knew she was heavier than she should be, but there was a big difference between knowing something and hearing it spoken out loud" [p. 266]). This is a venerable Jane Eyre-y strategy, of course: dialing down the pulchritude of your heroine the more believably to mary-sue her. And as a strategy it has certain advantages: for since the hero isn't distracted by a pretty face, and falls in love with the true heart beneath the unalluring exterior, it can work to heighten the true love pang with which the story will eventually pay off. (I'm guessing here: The Queen of the Tearling surrounds Kelsea with gorgeously handsome men, but she has copped-off with none of these by the end of vol 1. That will surely have changed, come vol 3.) Hollywood, I suppose, is like US daytime soap operas—simply disinclined to cast actual human beings in key roles. But the point of the red sticker, and flap copy, has less to do with the rather boyish good looks of Watson herself. It is a signal to potential readers. Want more Harry Potter? Buy this! As far as that goes, Potter is a tricky prototype to follow. I don't just mean in terms of its globe-spanning success, or special charm. I mean that Rowling's series starts out Young Young Adult, and ends up, via death, torture and burgeoning sexualities, considerably more Adult Young Adult. If you want to pitch your book to readers who have already worked through all seven of those books, you may feel obliged to plump for the Deathly Hallows rather than the Philosopher's Stone end of this spectrum.

One day I'm going to write an essay on the value of Mary Sues. We can't all be intellectual giants.
ReplyDeleteI received an advance copy of this book, and, as I recall, even the publicist's letter emphasized that Emma Watson was slated to star in the film. So I was amused when, a few weeks later, my Twitter feed erupted with mentions of and links to Erika Johansen's groundbreaking essay on why fantasy heroines don't need to be pretty.
ReplyDeleteMatt: I hadn't seen that essay -- will seek it out.
ReplyDeleteMatt: me too!
ReplyDeletehttp://www.buzzfeed.com/erikajohansen/all-shapes-and-sizes#4i837x0
ReplyDelete