Saturday, 14 June 2014
Ev'ry Shannannara, ev'ry woh-o woh woh -- still shines
Not ev'ry Shannara, actually: so that post title is a bit of a lie. But the first three, at any rate. Indexed here:
Terry Brooks, The Sword of Shannara (1977)
Terry Brooks, The Elfstones of Shannara (1982)
Terry Brooks, The Kitschsong of Shannara (1985)
Tuesday, 10 June 2014
Terry Brooks, Shannara 3: Shan Hard With A Vengeance (1985)
Wishsong of Shannara is the third Shannara I've read (this was the first, and this the second) and I think I'm finally getting a sense of what's going on here. I mean: a sense of what the distinctive thing is that Brooks brings to the Tolkien-derivative table. It's this:
In the forests of Shady Vale the leaves had already begun to turn. Brin Ohmsford paused by the flowebeds that bordered the front walkway of her home, losing herself momentarily in the crimson foliage of the old maple that shaded the yard beyond. [1]It's Thomas Kinkade. Which is to say: it's Thomas Kinkade avant la letter, since Brooks is writing in 1985. So what I really mean is -- it's one iteration of a much broader aesthetic of specifically American quasi-rural Kitsch.
A full moon hung above the eastern horizon like a white beacon, and stars began to wink into view. The trail dipped downward into the sheltered hollow where the village proper sat ... the inn was busy this night, its broad double-doors flung open, the lights within falling over tables and a long bar crowded with travellers and village folk, laughing and joking and passing the cool autumn evening with a glass or two of ale. [9]
This is interesting, I think, in the particular context of genre Fantasy. Celeste Olalquiaga traces the beginnings of ‘kitsch’ to the nineteenth century, linking it with (as she puts it) the way ‘industrialization transformed nature into an artificial kingdom of miniature scale’ [Celeste Olalquiaga, Artificial Kingdom: a Treasury of the Kitsch Experience (University of Michigan Press 1988), 7]. For Olalquiaga this aesthetic is ‘at once exhilarated and melancholic’; and although she doesn’t not specifically discuss Fantasy (or indeed SF) she might as well do. The desire to model the cosmos, to ‘reduce’ it to a more comfortable scale, as much as the proneness to a particular logic of visualisation, and the cosy-worship buried narrative of Dark versus Light, Christianized to a greater or lesser degree: these fingerprints are all over Fantasy. Fantasyland, like the materially real but equally fantastical Disneyland, is similar to the real world, but kitschier: smaller, more colourful, more conventionalised, safer and more manageable. For a certain kind of Fantasy novel, this is the whole point of the worldbuilding.
Perhaps I over-reach myself in trying to identify this as a distinctly American sort of kitsch, but the way religion works in these supernatural Good-versus-Evil yarns does seem to me differently encoded to the way Tolkien's old-school Gothic (in the strict sense) Catholicism operated in his art. Wishsong of Shannara is, like Tolkien, Christian in form without including specific religious content in its worldbuilding (its main through-line and climactic pay-off has to do with the pure and redemptive love between a brother and sister). It reminds me of the way Kinkade painted cottages, landscapes and Disney characters rather than (say) churches or chapels, yet always worked the Christian Ichthus fish-symbol and references to 'John 3:16' into his signature. It's tweeness as transcendence: hollow plastic blue-and-pink models of the Madonna with a light bulb inside; images of the face of Christ discovered in a potato crisp; angelic beings as simpering putti rather than terrifying figures out of Rainer Maria Rilke. Part of me wonders if this isn't the genuine religious salient today. Maybe this quality's own (inauthentic) campness is actually what guarantees its authenticity. This is because religion is not just about the Sublime; it is about the interaction between the Sublime and the ridiculous, between God and us. The fact that we are much more ridiculous than we are sublime beds-in a kitsch element at the heart of worship. When Eliot’s bird pointed out that humankind cannot bear very much reality, it meant divine reality; and the marker of that falling short—kitsch—is to be celebrated. You may be too sophisticated to be actually moved by Kinkade's cottage-scenes; that's fair enough. I expect none but the most refined and sophisticated readers to this blog, of course. The real question is: are you snotty enough to mock those who are so moved?
Part of the point of kitsch is that visual texture (pastel-y; illuminated; moonlit; shadowy) isn't primarily about the visual appearance of things so much as it is a way of connoting affect. This is why Brooks, not an actively incompetent writer, can pen a sentence of such prima facie ridiculousness as: 'His dark face was pale' [97]. 'He' is Allanon, our Gandalfalike, and he's described like that because he has just drained himself in some strenuous magical spellweaving or other. The sentence becomes less daft when we clock that 'dark' isn't really there to evoke dark skin, but rather to connote the exotic otherness with which magic in this novel is mildly racialised (see also: 'magic negro'. Our heroine, Brin, is likewise kitsch-orientalised, on account of her skills with the magical wishsong: 'dusky skin and black eyes ... soft delicate features'). And 'pale' here doesn't mean actually pale; it connotes an emotional state of being worn out in a good cause.
Still: not to get over-serious. I enjoyed reading Shannara 3, but not in a way that leads me to believe I'll be reading any more of these books any time soon. Not sure I need to. Shannara 3 is basically the same story as Shannara 2 and indeed as Shannara 1: an ancient evil has arisen that threatens the whole world; Allanon must persuade an initially reluctant scion of the Ohmsford clan to use Interchangeable Magic Item (in this vol: the titular 'wishsong' that Brin sings, which can change the natural world, or make people hallucinate spiders are crawling all over them, depending) to address this evil. The evil this time round is a Ring of Power analogue called 'The Ildatch', a malign book of evil which must be located and then destroyed. Since the main protagonist is called 'Brin' and possesses magic skills in singing I kept picturing this:
But actually she's supposed to look like this:
Cheer up, love! It may never happen.
So: Vol 1 was about the middle of the map. Vol 2 gave us a whole new map of the Westland; and this vol adds a new map of the Eastland. I'm racking my brains trying to work out what Brooks will do for vols 4 and 5.
The
Anyway: once the bad book is gone the whole malignant expanse of the Maelmord marsh simply vanishes away. Not sure how this latter thing happens, actually. But it means that Goodness is restored to the land. And by goodness I mean: Thomas Kinkadeness. 'Autumn had settled down across the land, and everywhere the colors of the season brightened and shone in the sunshine's warmth. It was a clear cool day in the Eastland forests where the Chard Rush tumbled down out of the Wolfsktaag' [489]. Ah. Not a typo, then.
SPIDER-GNOMES!!
Sorry. That just slipped out.
Friday, 6 June 2014
Terry Brooks, Shannara 2: Shan Harder (1982)
The Elfstones of Shannara it is. That cover (‘touch my sto-o-ones! Touch them! Or I’ll have Robin Hood here put an arrow in your eye!') sets the tone. Viz: inadvertent double-entendre and Carry On-ishness pretty much throughout. Here the main antagonist, a kind of demon, on his first appearance:
The Dagda Mor appeared out of the dark, hissing with rage. His Staff of Power steamed hotly. [16]Oo-er! There’s a lot of this, and I’m sure it’s a confession of my own immaturity to say that, however much there is in the novel, it never gets old.
With both hands gripping his Staff of Power, he placed it upright. … a pale reddish color, it began to pulsate … fire shot skyward from the Staff in a thin, brilliant arc that flew into the dawn like some frightened, living thing. [22]So: we get a whole new map, of the 'Westlands', where the elves come from; and also a copy of the original map of the, eh, Midlands I guess.
The plot is set two generations after Sword and the premise is that the
There was a whisper of silk, and Wil found himself face to face with the most stunning girl he had ever seen … she was wearing high leather boots, dressed in pants and tunic of scarlet silk that failed to hide anything of the woman beneath. [161]Wow—pants? Oh: pants. Ah well. Anyway, it all ends well; but there's a twist. Amberle doesn't plant a new Ellcrys tree; instead she [SPOILER] metamorphoses, Daphne-like, into the new Ellcrys tree. This upsets Wil very much, on account of him having fallen in love with the elvenish maiden. Indeed, he's so heartbroken by her magical entimbering that it takes him almost three whole pages to cop off with a different girl. Moving stuff.
Wednesday, 4 June 2014
Terry Brooks, The Sword of Shannara (1977)
When I tweeted that I’d decided to read this novel (on the grounds that I’d never read it) a number of people tweeted back that (a) it is immensely, almost parodically derivative of Lord of the Rings, and (b) but their nine-year-old selves had really liked it. And that is what we find. It is so patently rip-off Tolkieniana, down to the last detail, it is almost endearing. Reading it was a process of reminding myself (contra Adorno) that there is a pleasure in settling-in to an aesthetic experience of marked familiarity; as when the blues chords and bo-diddley chug of yet another pleasant AOR rock track notionally 'new' comes on the radio and you find your foot tapping along. It’s not Tolstoy. You aren't surprised to hear me say so. It is a YA adventure, written before publishers had quite grasped the commercial potential of that mode. And, rather to my surprise, I did enjoy reading it.
Of course, tis a particular and rather limited sense of ‘enjoy’ I’m using here, and to be sure. In terms of the book’s plotting and worldbuilding, I have nothing to add to the estimable Tom Shippey’s judgment of a derivativeness so profound it would plumb the Mariana trench. Shippey [in 2000’s J.R.R. Tolkien: Author of the Century, pp 319–320] considers the novel distinctive
for "the dogged way in which it follows Tolkien point for point" … Shippey locates "analogues" for Tolkien characters such as Sauron (Brona), Gandalf (Allanon), the Hobbits (Shea and Flick), Aragorn (Menion), Boromir (Balinor), Gimli (Hendel), Legolas (Durin and Dayel), Gollum (Orl Fane), the Barrow-wight (Mist Wraith) and the Nazgûl (Skull Bearers), among others. He also finds plot similarities to events in The Lord of the Rings such as the Fellowship of the Ring's formation and adventures, the journeys to Rivendell (Culhaven) and Lothlórien (Storlock), Gandalf's (Allanon) fall in Moria (Paranor) and subsequent reappearance, and the Rohirrim's arrival at the Battle of the Pelennor Fields (Battle of Tirsys), among others. Avoiding direct commentary on the book's quality, Shippey attributes the book's success to the post-Tolkienian advent of the fantasy genre: "What The Sword of Shannara seems to show is that many readers had developed the taste ... for heroic fantasy so strongly that if they could not get the real thing they would take any substitute, no matter how diluted."Yep.
It’s a novel that bears the marks of a writer not yet (shall we say) entirely in charge of his instrument. The main giveaway here is a gushing refusal to permit any noun to go before the reader unadjectived, or any verb unadverbed. This leads to overwriting of this sort:
The trail stretched out unevenly down the northern slope, winding through the huge boulders which studded the rugged terrain in massive clumps, disappearing into the thick forests of the lowlands to reappear in brief glimpses in small clearings. [9]The way to deal with this (in your own writing, I mean; or, you know -- generally) is to italicize all adjectives and adverbs and see what the result looks like. Generally the result is that if you cut out all the italicised bits the prose would be more vivid.
Long front legs tipped with deadly hooked claws clutched the empty air, and the great jaws clashed sharply, grinding together the blackened, pointed teeth. [271]
A dazzling flash of lightning outlined a small form near the crest of a tall hill far, far ahead, struggling madly to gain the rocky summit in the face of the driving rain. [529]So, yes, the prose is a bit wearing in long stretches, although on the upside it’s rarely actively Robert-Jordan bad. Except, you know: sometimes.
It rained the entire time—a slow, chilling drizzle that soaked first the clothing, then penetrated into the skin and bone, and finally reached the very nerve centres. [95]Well, either Shea and friends have unusually spongy body mass, or that is some unusually penetrating rain. But, look: banging this book on its metaphorical pate with a knobstick for manifold failures of expression and general Thoggism, as I might do with another writer, is no fun. It’s like slapping a puppy. One of the pleasures of Brooks’ writing is that he is so in-the-bone unpretentious; there’s no overweening Jordan-ic or Donaldsonian self-importance here. And (not to abdicate the responsibilities of criticism or anything) there’s a level of response which boils down to: ‘either you enjoy reading sentences like Paranor has fallen! A division of Gnome hunters under the command of the Warlock King has seized the Sword of Shannara! [147] or you don’t.’
What else? Well, for the first 450 pages or so there are no women in this story. No female characters at all. Crikey, but that reads oddly in 2014. Finally a woman is introduced, but in tones of such frank astonishment (‘he had rescued a woman!’ [460]) that the reader is left in no doubt (‘a woman! Why would the Northlanders kidnap a woman?’ [461]) that bringing a woman into a story such as this is really, like, bogus, dude (‘he paused at the second button of his nightshirt, suddenly remembering the young woman with him. He pointed meaningfully to the door, but she shook her head negatively and turned away so she couldn’t see him changing’ [466]). Of course it is sexist, but it is the blithe sexism of young boys who don’t want girls in their gang. Girls! Gak. Also she’s called ‘Shirley’ (well: ‘Shirl’) which is a great name for a character in an heroic fantasy. At any rate, Brooks has the decency to hold-off the icky kissy-kissy stuff until near the end.
'I came a long, long way,' he murmured gently. 'I've seen the evil there is in this world and in worlds that mortals only dream exist. There is nothing that can hurt us ... Just believe, Shirl.' ... The weary highlander smiled, gripping her hands tightly. She was the most beautiful woman he had ever seen. [599]Since she appears to be the only woman anyone has ever seen, that's a safe bet. Less amusing is the seeming naif racist orientalism by which the ‘Gnomes’, this world’s orcs, are described. They’re small, yellow-skinned, devious and hunched. I don’t believe Brooks uses the phrase ‘bandy-legged’ with respect to them, but he might as well have done.
What’s that? Oh alright then: Thoggisms it is. Though they’re hardly Thoggisms at all! Baby-Thoggisms.
The trees prevented the members of the company from seeing much of anything, their great girth ranging from three to ten feet in diameter. [176] (… that’s one stout set of company members!)See? Hardly Thoggisms at all. Reading The Sword of Shannara turned out to be a surprisingly pastime-y exercise, in part because it’s been a while since I read a book so unembarrassed about being Wholly Generic Heroic Fantasy Product. There’s no twist here, no attempt to add novelty to Tolkien’s format. Actually that’s not right: Brooks has one idea, which is that his fantasy world is our world a couple of thousand years after an atomic apocalypse; his dwarfs, elves, gnomes etc. are mutated descendants of different branches of humanity. Every now and again he remembers this notion and has his characters chance upon a ruined city of rusting steel girders in the forest, or encounter a feral robot from the olden times. But mostly it is conveniently forgotten.
The Dragon’s Crease was well named. [275]
Expectant eyes traveled upward over the steep rock walls. [289]
The features of the Troll were indescribably bland. [342]
They were like thousands of blazing yellow dots in the blackness of the plain. [408]
An eerie soundless shriek of terror ripped from the convulsed shroud. [701]
One more thing: about half way through our hero falls in with a rogue-ish, charming thief called Panini (I may be misremembering his name) who has a rock troll as his side-kick. In a novel published in 1978 this couple would fair scream ‘Han Solo and Chewie rip-off!’; but The Sword of Shannara was first published in 1977, and written before Lucas’s movie, so I guess that’s just one of those odd coincidences.
Tuesday, 3 June 2014
Sunday, 1 June 2014
Anne Charnock, A Calculated Life (2013)
A shame this title seems to have been largely overlooked from last year’s batch of SF: it’s a coolly written, deceptively straightforward tale that manages to stir the silt from some properly unsettling depths in its pool—really, a very noteworthy book that deserves to be better known. Or maybe it is better known, and the ignorance is mine alone—it was shortlisted for the Philip K Dick prize after all, and rightly so.
We’re in a near-future Manchester, where the proles have been shunted into unappealing banlieues on threadbare universal wages, and the better-off concentrate in the city centre. Some of these better-offs have been ‘augmented’ in subtle ways; and some, like our heroine Jayna, are ‘simulants’—in effect, replicants, with a nicely rendered spock-ish mixed bemusement and curiosity about the way ‘regular’ humans conduct themselves. Jayna leads a carefully regulated and timetabled life, living in a hostel with other synthetics, working for a company where her superhuman processing skills are employed looking for correlations between various sets of data, ideally in order to locate trends that the company can monetize. That’s it, pretty much: and most of the novel is given over to Jayna moving through the cityscape, Jayna’s work-day practices and Jayne’s astringent perspective on normal human life. Intimations of social unease, and a background anxiety about Jayna’s future are hinted at, not beaten on the head. There are rumours of other comparable simulants, working in other companies, going off the rails—(eating, shock-horror, in an Indian restaurant rather than chowing the hostel’s carefully prepared and, we assumed, drugged food! Having sex with normals!)—and being retired.
One thing is novel does exceptionally well is convey a texture of actual life, a carefully pitched low-key verisimilitude. I fear that name-dropping ‘replicants’, as I did in the previous paragraph, gives rather the wrong impression: Charnock’s Manchester is quite unlike Blade Runner’s hyperreal city, and her prose creates a much more rounded sense of actual life than the deliberately flattened paranoidal patterns of Phil Dick’s writing. What she shares with Dick is the ability to write unease. Jayna’s genius-quasi-asperger’s apperceptions lead her to test her own limits, and through that the novel unobtrusively—but all the more resonantly for that—leads the reader into emotional territory of impressive nuance and range. Charnock has fascinating, complex things to say about work, sex, family and hope (and that pretty much covers it, don’t you think?). Indeed, the emphasis on the routines of work struck me as one of the strongest things here. Too much SF and Fantasy is concerned with the life of play—of aristocrats and the superwealthy, say; or of ordinary people taken out of their humdrum lives and sent on exciting adventures, because that makes for a notionally more ‘exciting’ story. Charnock, though, captures the flavour of regular work, and that is (after all) what most people’s lives are mostly like. And that sets it aside, and I think above, its most obviously comparator as a novel: Ishguro’s Never Let Me Go. Ishiguro’s simulant-equivalents just loll about like bored teens, because that’s what they are; and whilst that’s fine, it also means that the novel itself can’t quite escape a faintly adolescent vibe. Charnock’s Jayna undertakes a similar process of ‘growing up’; but because A Calculated Life engages with all the external trappings of the adult day-to-day the novel itself has a broader affective range.
Thursday, 29 May 2014
Ian Watson, Deathhunter (1981)
Deathhunter (1981) is a curious, oddly memorable short novel. The story concerns the titular protagonist, Jim Todhunter. As the book opens he is travelling to Egremont (somewhere in a near-future North America) to take up a new position in a House of Death. We are in a quasi-utopian post-nuclear war world where ‘death’ has been de-pathologised. Our unheathly obsession with death and the religious fictions of ‘afterlife’ had brought the world to the brink of disaster. ‘We were going to destroy this whole fair world of ours and al the people in it because we couldn’t come to terms with death. Death was something that never happened to us, but only to the other fellow. We expelled the dead from our lives. We made them into strangers, who had nothing to do with us’ [12]. This led to a brief nuclear exchange that seems to have destroyed China, and a postbellum re-arrangement of social and thanatological priorities. Now death is an accepted part of the community, each town being built around the House of Death where, after a useful life, people are gentle and openly euthanized. Jim wanders round Egremont, and listens to the poet laureate Norman Harper blithely face his own death: speeches by the mayor in front of an admiring crowd, Harper himself reading his own poems.
It’s a nice touch that these poems are super-banal; and Watson’s feel for the fundamentally underpowered Ikea-lite trappings of his utopia is itself nicely understated—actual utopia, we all know deep down, would be a profoundly beige and humdrum place. But the peaceful ceremony is shattered when a terminally ill and deranged individual called Weinberger rushes the podium and shoots Harper dead with a pistol. Shock! Why did he do it?
Todhunter is given Weinberger as a ‘patient’, with the brief of encouraging him to accept his inevitable and now (after this almost unprecedented capital crime) imminent euthanisation. But Weinberger turns the tables on Todhunter, revealing that he used himself to work in a House of Death, and that he had noticed a ‘pheromone of death’ on the nearly dead that in turn attracted a sort of half-visible red giant moth-like creature. Death itself, this beast, come to steal away the souls. The only way to evade this alarming soul predator is to die suddenly, unexpectedly—hence Weinberger’s assassination of Harper. This obviously improbable circumstance takes root in Todhunter’s imagination until he becomes persuaded, and with Weinberger builds a sort of large mirrored box-cum-Faraday-cage. The two simulate death and emit the pheromone and lo! death flutters in.
Something suddenly flickered … into existence. A red thing—except that it was not really ‘red’—appeared abruptly, perching upon Weinberger’s chest. It was a bat, or giant moth … it flickered: it seemed to dance in and out of existence. It had big glassy eyes—if they were eyes—as red as the rest of its body. And a cruel little beak. It wore sharp hooks on its veil-like wings—if they were wings—like the spurs of a fighting cock [62; ellipses in original]Weinberger grabs this in his fist and holds on: all afternoon, through the night and into the next day, despite it being agony (and despite the creature being invisible outside the cage). When he finally relinquishes the thing his cancer has miraculous vanished from his body.
The remainder of the novel sees Todhunter, under increasing pressure from his fellow House of Death employees to give up this dangerous and unhealthy obsession with an hallucinatory afterlife, joining Weinberger in his pursuit of death. The two of them are forced to flee into the forests, where they chase death down a second time, following it into a weird surreality, past a crystal fog and into a no-space structured as corridors and doors and infinite possible realities by (we assume) their own consciousnesses. There’s a whole flock, or swarm, of the death-moth-bats—what, incidentally, is the collective noun for a mass of death-moth-bats? Is it like ravens? After passing through a succession of odd realms, including one containing the otherwise entirely unexplained naked tentacle-chest woman pictured in the front cover art above, they meet a man-sized insectile ‘angel’, or perhaps devil. According to this creature the death-moth-bats are not preying on dying souls, but are rather sent to guide them to the realm of infinite possible realities. Those who die suddenly either stay on the Earth as ghosts, or else become trapped in the (malign and expanding) crystal fog.
Now the novel has a twist-ending, and to that end I must issue a spoiler warning. I wasn’t very impressed by the twist, actually; officials from the House of Death catch up with Todhunter and Weinberger in the wilderness and, far from taking them into custody, kill them both. Todhunter passes through the crystal fog to emerge in a reality that exactly replicates the circumstances of the opening of the novel. He is at the ceremony marking the euthanizing of Harper, aware that at any moment Weinberger will come running up with his pistol. Then the last chapter effects a shift of POV. Now we are in an institute in Montenegro (of which ‘Egremont’ is a near anagram) in ‘our’ world; Todhunter is a criminal—a defrocked priest who abused and later murdered children—who is being treated for his psychosis in an experimental ‘psychoscope’; the House of Death and its whole world being a sort of matrix-y hallucination within the machine. The characters in the novel are all officers working for the institute; but Weinberger is resisting his treatment. The twist-on-the-twist is when one of his (we are assured, purely notional) death-bat-moth creatures breaks out of the imaginary reality of the psychoscope and flutters off into our world.
Twists are tricky things. This Shutter Island-style reveal (of course, avant le lettre) is liable to leave the reader a little nonplussed: to leave her wondering a little sourly what exactly is the status of the intriguing gnarly and interestingly literal-minded speculation on death that has gone before. Still: there is, I think, a kind of aesthetic redemption implicit in the larger project here. The game here is not one a conjurer’s one of false-reveal followed by false-reveal through to a final flourish with a true reveal. The game is a more intricately embedded one.
Step back a moment. What is the nature of this fictional afterlife? Doors, doors, doors
Cautiously Jim opened the doors a crack, then pulled them wide. Now there was a no bluebell wood outside. In its place was a moated castle set in a clearing in an oak wood. Steep jagged mountains of ice or glass rose beyond the wood, flashing in the sunshine. A dinosaur-like dragon capered … A knight rode out of the castle over the drawbridge ...That it’s not just ‘fairyland’ is made plain in the next few afterlives glimpsed: ‘a white rabbit wearing a frock coat ran past, feverishly consulting a pocket watch’ (that TOS Star Trek episode has a lot to answer for); ‘again: a bilious, lime-green, goggle-eyed toad rowed lazily along a winding river under the feathery drip of willow trees. The toad sported a straw boater with a candy-striped hatband, a loud checkered jacket and a mustard waistcoat.’ You get the point. But the specificity is self-reflexive:
“Fairyland!” exclaimed Weinberger. “All the facets of Fairyland!”
He thrust the doors shut before they could witness the outcome of the dragon-tilt and pulled them wide once more.
A great cavern with an underground river running through it. Bones littered the stone floor. A wicker cage penned a weeping, hand-wringing maiden. A giant, with nail-studded club over one shoulder, grabbed for them. Its fist slammed into the doors as both men through their weight against them. They forced the twin doors shut against increasing pressure, till they clicked home. [132-33]
Here the doors opened on some future city, or some city on another world. The two men stood high on a railed tower, looking down. Gossamer bridges spanned rose-red canyons. Craft flew through the air, flapping metal wings like birds. The sun in the sky was hugely swollen, a dying bonfire red. When they reopened this same door a moment later, bloated glassy spiders the size of houses floated through a violet sky above a tawny desert, their dangling webs snaring angular white birds.This is the crux. The beige-utopia in which people submit smilingly to community-sanctioned euthanasia is a genre creation. Embedded within it is a secondary genre creation, a world in which death is an actual being—not a bleached-white skeleton man in black cloak, but a weird bat-moth thing—that leads ‘consciousness’ into an afterlife (like the Douglas Trumbull 1983 SF movie Brainstorm, which this novel anticipates)* amenable to scientific enquiry. That afterlife is revealed to be: genre itself, the myriad possibilities not of ‘fiction’ as such but specifically of fantastika. This is what provides the, as it were, aesthetic geometry of the novel with its rationale: a genre text that squirrels its imaginings down through layers of genre to reveal this human universal—death—as not the end but on the contrary the very ground of possibility of genre itself, the setting in which the novel in which this topography is revealed is situated. The final twist, with the bat-moth fluttering away into ‘our’ world, is less a Tales-of-the-Unexpected style reversal, and more a reaffirmation or the interpenetration of this complexly self-embedded topography.
“They’re genre doors, that’s what,” cried Weinberger. “Sets of fictions. Imaginings. Free creations. Not hells or purgatories, but inventions.’ [133]
--------
*Actually, looking into it, I discover Trumbull was working on the movie in 1981; Natalie Wood's death delayed the release until 1983. So: no lines of influence, just a slightly uncanny coincidence of fascinations.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)














