Friday, 23 October 2020

What Sinks "Underwater"

 


Although, actually, I rather enjoyed William Eubank's 2020 science fiction action horror movie. But it doesn't really work, and I was curious why. Spoilers follow.

It's essentially Alien underwater. A deepwater drilling platform located (improbably enough) at the bottom of the Mariana Trench is hit by what seems at first an earthquake. Kristen Stewart and other highly attractive underwater drilling technicians, as all commercial drilling technicians of course are, run around the collapsing facility in their underwear, closing bulkheads and pressing control panel buttons and so on. Some of them are killed in the chaos. The survivors clamber into diving suits and make their way across the seabed to a different part of the facility, where the escape pods are located. More of them die, this time hauled away by tentacled monsters—hitherto-unencountered lifeforms, mansized pallid motile globs of feelers and teeth. As the facility further collapses more of the cast are, as per Alien, snaffled by these nameless horrors. There is much wriggling through collapsed, flooding corridors, and plenty of shock moments, diving suit helmets suddenly filling with blood as their wearers howl and so on. 

Finally Stewart, Jessica Henwick and John Gallagher make it to the escape pod room, all the slightly less attractive cast members having been tentacled-away. Stewart manages to send Henwick and Gallagher away in their pods, but her own pod is broken, so she stays behind. And this is where the movie stages its big reveal. The human-sized undersea monsters are merely the progeny of one absolutely gigantic tentacle-and-teeth monster

Far, far beneath in the abysmal sea,
From ancient, dreamless, uninvaded sleep
The Kraken waketh
... and it's Cthulhu! It's your actual gigantic Lovecraftian beast. Stewart gazes into the ph'nglui mglw'nafh r'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagnian horror for a while, and then presses the base's nuclear self-destruct (all mining platforms, as I understand it, are equipped with one such) immolating herself and the elder horror both at once. 

The whole movie is expensively mounted, well-made, nicely designed, earnestly acted. It is no more intrinsically silly than was Alien back in 1979. And yet it doesn't work. I wonder if the reason it doesn't work is because this Lovecraftian flourish mismatches the tenor of the movie as a whole. Underwater is, as Alien was, body-horror. Now, body horror can be very effective at spooking and upsetting us, squicking our sense of somatic integrity and safety. But Lovecraft did not write body horror. His stories do sometimes contain horrible bodies, but that's not the same thing. Lovecraft wrote topographic horror. Think how ‘The Dunwich Horror’ begins with pages and pages of eerie scene-setting off the Aylesbury turnpike in north central Massachusetts; or how ‘The Colour Out Of Space’ opens by situating itself in a particular Arkham locale (‘the old folk have gone away, and foreigners do not like to live there. French-Canadians have tried it, Italians have tried it, and the Poles have come and departed. It is not because of anything that can be seen or heard or handled, but because of something that is imagined. The place is not good for the imagination, and does not bring restful dreams at night.’) Heidegger distinguished between space and place in order to valorise the latter as the dwelling of Being. Lovecraft intuitively turned this around, and his work generates a queasy apprehension of place as the iteration of nightmarish inescapability, place as the already-dwelt-in by nameless ghastliness. There's nothing in the generic corridors and control rooms of Underwater's subsea base that can evoke that, and the scenes of the cast lolloping across the ocean bed entail no connection, or recognition, in the audience. Can't have the unheimlich without the heimlich, after all. 

4 comments:

  1. Initially read that as

    "Lovecraft wrote typographic horror"

    which isn't that far off either.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Comic Sans Out of Space.
      The Serif Over Innsmouth.
      Hound of the Baskervilles no hang on a minute wrong writer.

      Delete
  2. I'm sorry but I have to know -- how does the film identify the monster, within the story, as Lovecraft's Cthulhu? Does it introduce itself to Kristen Stewart, in English? Wear one of those name plate necklaces? Is there a copy of "The Dunwich Horror" in the mining platform/nuclear bomb's Little Free Library?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. He’s still wearing his lanyard from the office.

      Delete