So, yes, I finally got around to reading these novels. Can't remember why I didn't read them when they first came out, Mind you, I can't remember why I thought it would be a good idea to read them now, either. Maybe my memory is starting to go.
The first vol, The Gap Into Conflict: The Real Story (1991), is the shortest of the five. A troll-ugly space pirate (Angus Thermopyle) turns up in a space station bar with an exceptionally beautiful young woman called Morn Hyland. She clearly hates him, but she does what he tells her. The regulars believe Angus has a sort of mind-control implant in Morn that compels her to do whatever he dials into the control; and everyone assumes moreover that he spends most of the time, in the privacy of his ship, dialling in all manner of kinky degrading sex acts. But another space pirate happens to be in the bar: the handsome, dashing Nick Succorso. He sees Morn. Morn sees him. Suddenly Angus has been framed for a crime he didn’t commit (though there are thousands of worse crimes he has committed), and before we even get to the end of chapter 1 Morn and Succorso have run off together
This, though, is not ‘the real story’. We are assured the ‘real story’ is quite other, and the rest of the novel is given over to retelling it in detail. Confusingly, it turns out to be exactly what everybody assumed: Thermopyle had rescued Morn from her parents’ space ship, which she herself sabotaged (she suffers from the ‘gap sickness’ that afflicts 1% of space travellers: passing through hyperspace drives her temporarily insane). Angus had then fitted her with a brain control device, and using this he rapes her every which way for chapter after chapter after chapter—ghastly, monotonous reading, as gruelling as it is boring. The only twist, as it were, is that Succorso turns out not to be the dashing hero figure, but another violent misogynist interested only in hurting and raping our heroine. The whole thing is brutish, and the flimsiness of its central textual thread makes the brutishness somehow worse, like a version of ‘twinkle twinkle little star’ performed by Laibach whilst ripping the heads off kittens.
It may be that Donaldson thinks that the ‘real’ story is the psychological one; that like Nabokov’s Lolita he is delineating a monster only to humanise him, and sketching a victim only to complexify her. But Donaldson is no Nabokov. It's a genuinely queasy book. It posits a beautiful young woman who commits an unspeakable crime (Morn's 'Gap sickness' prompted her to murder her whole family, you see) and is therefore set up as punishment-worthy. Then it rigs this character with an implant that renders her perfectly complaisant, however much she hates what she is doing. It's as if it is going out of its way to say to one sector of its reading public: hey, you, ugly young geek guy who can't get laid. Imagine what you could do with this set-up! It's like an SF version of John Norman's Gor (and, really, can you think of anything SF needs less than one of those?) What's the word? Well everybody's heard about the word, and ugh! is the word. It's hardly possible to iterate that word often enough, or with enough force, here.
The second instalment The Gap into Vision: Forbidden Knowledge (1991) is four times as long, and contains quite a lot of business, although by no means does it contain 650-pages worth of substance. The big event here is that Morn discovers she is pregnant, following Angus’s multiple rapes. She tells Nick the baby is his, and a complicated tangle of plotting takes them to the alien race called the Amnion. This is notionally to use their technology to enable Morn to give birth to an adult, and so nip past all the tedious decades of growing-up otherwise needful to introduce Angus and Morn’s son into the story. There’s the question of whether Nasty Nick will sell a human (Morn, or Morn’s son) to the Amnion, which outcome is repeatedly claimed to be The Worst Thing Imaginable.
Donaldson doesn’t write characters; he writes marionettes (divided into: male, wicked, ugly; male, wicked, handsome; female beautiful victim; female beautiful deadly; other). The flatness of this characterisation means that he has to force his puppet-players into more and more intensely exaggerated reactions, ever more extreme shrieking and suffering and yelling. Emotion is always turned up to ten, or else turned off entirely. It results in a weirdly jerky, stop-start description of subjectivity which prompts D. to more and more hyperbolically extreme adjectival and adverbial description. This very quickly putters into diminishing returns. Here’s Nick Succorso, pirate, rapist etc.; thwarted and trapped, described over the course of a couple of pages of A Dark And Hungry God Arises (1993):
Fear and rage knotted his muscles, twisted his throat. An instinct for survival stretched as thin as thread was all that kept him from hurling himself at her throat … His muscles were so tight with strain that he could hardly breathe. [90-1]There’s no way any crew would follow so cyclotropic a captain, but that’s hardy the point. Donaldson isn’t portraying a group dynamic that comes even close to verisimilitude; he’s straining every pip for INTENSITY and PASSION and EXCITEMENT and flapping the toggle on the back of his androidal characters between ‘suave’ and ‘rage-screamy’ with increasing desperation as those qualities stubbornly refuse to come alive in his writing. His characters aren’t ‘characters’ in the conventional sense: they’re vessels into which one or other extreme emotion can be decanted as needed.
He no longer needed outrage. He was calm now, almost clinical himself. His grin showed how calm he was. [93]
He felt too buoyant to sit down. … nonchalantly, Nick nodded cheerfully. [97]
All at once Nick started laughing. He had to laugh to prevent himself from screaming. … In another minute he was going to kill the command second with his bare fists. … Nick opened his throat to roar. [100]
He didn’t need to scream. Or kill Mikka. Suddenly calm again, as casual as ever, he asked Scorz, “who is it this time?” A sigh of relief or trepidation seemed to spread away from him around the bridge. … Involuntarily Nick recoiled as if he had been hit. His calm was gone in an instant; forgotten. [100]
The hectic hyper-vehemence infects the writing too, and not with any good effect. Immediately after the last-quoted passage Nick understands something, which mental process D. describes according to the following improbable simile: ‘a laser of inspiration shot along the synapses of Nick’s brain; his nerves were ablaze with coherent light’ [100]. Donaldson may think he’s achieving a kind of operatic heightened intensity, or perhaps even something simpler—maybe he’s going for the externalised bright-colour bang!-bang!-bang! of comics.
He doesn’t create either vibe, though. The galaxy-spanning setting of the novel is unable to prevent it feeling intensely and unpleasantly claustrophobic: we seem forever trapped in poky spaceships with a screaming, gurning, punching, raping cast of half a dozen; or else in interminable committee meetings of the UMCP, where the director and effective Galactic tyrant Holt Fasner interminably schemes his terrible schemes. The effect is more like Franz Xaver Messerschmidt.
It's not that the effect lacks creepiness; it's that it skews ludicrous, not tragic-intense. And it gets more pronounced as the series goes on: the books get longer, more claustrophobic, more tedious and prolix, more unpleasant. And the style gets worse. Indeed, by the time we get to the last two books, there's little to do except to register the unique Donaldsonian style. Here, from 1994's Chaos and Order:
[109] Wheeling like a blow, he raged.
[130] Angus’ heart clenched in a grimace which didn’t show on his face.
[146] For reasons she couldn’t name, premonitions of disaster burned in her palms.
[165] Her shoulders hunched into a clench of disgust, which she deflected into a shrug.
[170] His hands were steady as stones as he toggled his intercom.
[174] If other means failed he probably had a dozen strategically placed buggers he could rely on.
[176] Above his open mouth, his eyes blinked like cries.
[177] His aura yowled of furies that didn’t show on his face.
[205] The smears on his lenses refracted his blue gaze into streams of hope and apprehension.
[216] The face that greeted him in his mirror was as wrinkled and used as a sheet of crumpled tissue.
[233] Perspiration turned to ice on his forehead and ran down the sides of his jaw.
[237] Matter is ‘frozen’ energy … Conversely energy may be understood as ‘liquid’ matter.
[240] She discovered that most of her aches were gone, and her ears no longer registered everything against a background of pain. Nevertheless her anger remained.
[251] She had to clench her teeth and grip her gun hard to prevent herself from flinging her stew across the galley.
[252] Under his fat, his features hardened.
[264] His grin was so abhorrent that Angus howled to himself; but he made no sound.
[265] Davies looked like his chest was congested with shouts.
[266] Angus looked straight at Nick, but with his peripheral vision he studied his readouts.
[280] A clutch of loss lifted his shoulders like a shrug.
[281] His eyes slid off as if they’d lost their grip.
[295] Davies seemed to feel tremors run through Angus; neurons misfiring like a suppressed storm. He didn’t care, however.
[313] The air had grown viscid with mortality.
[373] His scars looked like streaks of acid under his eyes, burning deeper and deeper into his cheeks. Heat poured off him as if he were overflowing.
[381] Her heart beat in her ears, the veinous funeral march of her inadequacy.
[395] [She was] shivering as if the cold had become metaphysical.
[441] Sweat oozed like wax from his skin.
[454] [Sib was] throwing the torque of his shoulders and the strength of his arms like projectiles at Nick’s ribs and kidneys.
[488] Koina regarded him with darkness stirring in the depths of her gaze. The restrained tension of her cheeks and forehead hinted at bleak bones beneath the skin.
[510] His eyes were so full of white fear that they appeared to have no irises.
[527] Nick let out a clenched laugh.
[538] Nick leered back at him from under his eyebrows.
[577] His beard moved like a blade whenever he spoke or turned his head.
[658] Through a red, squalling, visual knife of pain, he found the controls on his chestplate.
And here, at the risk of trespassing on your patience, is The Gap Into Ruin: This Day All Gods Die (1996)
[15] In the pockets of her labcoat her fingers twitched as if they were entering data on a purely metaphysical keypad.
[38] A pallor of betrayal seemed to leach the color from her cheeks; even from her eyes.
[38] Indignation and confusion appeared to flush through Chief Mandich in waves, staining his skin with splotches like the marks of an infection.
[39] In one sense Hashi noticed the reactions of his companions. But in another he paid no attention to them at all.
[46] Hashi spread his hands disingenuously.
[46] Now at last Warden permitted himself a reaction, which may have been surprise.
[47] Anodyne Systems, the sole licensed manufacturer of SOD-CMOS. [This acronym is so wonderful it almost caused me to forgive the rest of the series. Ed.]
[51-2] That substance is a coenzyme. Inherently inert … it combines with some of the human body’s natural apoenzymes to form an artificial holoenzyme. [I'm not a trained chemist. Is that what the word "inert" means? Ed.]
[63] Mandich murmured an obscenity between his teeth.
[66] He appeared to shudder like a man being sickened by uncertainty.
[67] The DA director wheezed. He fluttered his hands in front of his face to ward off emotions for which he had no use.
[97] He shook his head. Carried by its own momentum, his head continued rocking from side to side on his weak neck.
[109] Her voice ached like Morn’s arm.
[117] Food and coffee had rubbed the smudge from his gaze.
[147] Dolph’s deep, rumbling tone sharpened trenchantly.
[168] His companions were vivid with tension. Their postures shouted of dangers Min didn’t know how to evaluate.
[180] Angus snorted past his grin.
[255] His eyes emanated a moist heat that Warden had never seen in them before.
[317] Mins jaws clenched and loosened as if she were chewing iron.
[342] Cleatus was full of explosives—metaphorically speaking … his eyes held a lupine glitter, and his beard bristled like wire.
[366] Smoke seeped out of her hair as if the mind under it had been burned to the ground.
[375] Lane hid a grin behind a fringe of unclean hair.
[420] Fasner spoke so fiercely that acoustic shatter fretted the edges of his voice.
[471] His voice sounded as bleak as hard vacuum. [So that's what vacuum sounds like! Excellent. Ed.]
[437] Darkness mottled his face: blood and dirt marked his skin like livid stigmata. His heavy arms beat anguish against his sides. ‘Stop it!’ … Instinctively he aimed his rage like despair at Morn.
[447] Standing rigid, as if he were remembering a crucifixion, he shouted.
[474] She was a good fifteen centimeters taller. But the ominous intensity he radiated, the sense of critical mass he conveyed, made him seem larger. He gave the impression that there was no limit to how far he might expand.
[476] Every eye in the room clung to her urgently.
[480] Blaine wore her sexuality like an accusation.
[485] Sen Abdullah gaped like a man who couldn’t breathe well enough to grasp the opportunity Koina had given him.
[499] In response he brandished his beard at her like a club.
[525] Ceatus closed his mouth. But he left his demand hanging in the air.
[525] The sound of knives filled Hyland’s voice.
[667] Mikka swallowed a knot of tears.
That's enough. I brandish my beard at these books, like a club.






.jpg)



I enjoyed this immensely. If I had a beard--no, if I had a forked beard, I would clash the two beardlets together like a pair of cymbals (or maybe like two elephants, or two palm trees, or two especially hard clouds) in pleasure!
ReplyDeleteIn the 90s I'd basically stopped reading new scifi. Stuff like this is why.
ReplyDeleteHis mind wrote a lengthy comment expressing his amusement, but his fingers typed nothing.
ReplyDeleteThose are some of the worst sentences qua sentences I've ever seen -- and all by a single individual. Remarkable
ReplyDeleteThe only one that wasn't beyond redemption was this one: 'In the pockets of her labcoat her fingers twitched as if they were entering data on a purely metaphysical keypad.'
That's almost sub-Ballardian -- except in Ballard it would be in one in of those paragraphs where he'd pile 6-8 metaphors and similes on top of each other so they worked by sheer accumulative force, and he'd find a better word than 'metaphysical.'
The content sounds grotesque, too. But man, those are some insanely bad sentences.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteSome of those at least carry a meaning forme:
ReplyDelete[39] In one sense Hashi noticed the reactions of his companions. But in another he paid no attention to them at all.
Noticing and paying attention don't have to be the same.
Even this:
‘a laser of inspiration shot along the synapses of Nick’s brain; his nerves were ablaze with coherent light’ [100]
These are few exceptions though and the expressions, maybe even the choice of information, are very inadequate.
I guess this one can be taken off my shelf now. It sounds awful.
ReplyDelete