Nobody is waiting for my opinion on Rossgate (that link is to Foz Meadows' roundup of the slapfight; it is worth reading first, and indeed, perhaps -- since I'm about to disagree with her take on it -- instead). I recognise that as a white male writer I have a less worthwhile perspective on the whole brouhaha than many; and I also recognise that too many pixels have been splurged on the topic already. Since I won't link to this post; and since random traffic to this blog is low, I don't feel I'll thereby be thrusting my obnoxious opinions too bullishly on the world. On the other hand, and since my attitude to it all has undergone pretty much a 180-degree about turn, I'll jot down why.
My first awareness of the whole circumstance was Farah Mendlesohn's resignation note. Now Farah is a friend of mine of many years standing, and one of the single most principled and conscience-driven people I know. I applauded her note, both for the stand she was taking and for the scrupulous way she orchestrated her separation from the Loncon committee (with which she found herself in disagreement) so as not to compromise the many worthwhile practical things she has done by way of setting stuff up for the convention. My sense at that time was: SF has been through a particularly intense Sexismfail turmoil over the last several months, and the efforts to make Cons welcoming safe spaces for women is an ongoing, intensely worthwhile activity. I assumed (making an ass of me, I know, I know) that Ross was doing the gig for a fat fee. Since I'm not plugged into comics culture especially closely I was not really aware of his fan credentials, and it seemed to me that Farah had a point. Then, as we all know, Twitter exploded. Ross withdrew. The whole SF community polarised and started shouting.
I've been following the ensuing kerfuffle, off and on; and the longer it has gone on the more I have found myself thinking: Adam you are an ass. Ross offered his services for free. He is, it seems clear now, a genuine geek with a real love for the genre. He would certainly have raised the media profile of the event and so on -- all these questions have been rehearsed many times of course. But the tipping point as far as I was concerned was Kameron Hurley's post on the whole thing. I urge you to read it. She compares the fight to a disagreement she had with a three-year-old. Said three year old went to punch his mother; Kameron Hurley raised her voice; the three year old was outraged since it is rude to shout and such shouting 'hurt his feelings'. Hurley's position is that yelling is justified to prevent a greater evil.
Until she applied her analogy to the situation, I was honestly unsure whether Hurley was troping the three-year-old as Ross or as Fandom. That's the trouble with double-edged allegories. Clearly, nobody was suggesting Jonathan Ross was going to rock up at the Hugos and literally hit the nominated writers. Hurley's point (I take it) is that words can be like blows. But the problem here is that only thing we have in this sorry case is words: the words people imagined Ross would use (based on the precedence of the words he has used in his day-job as a television presenter) and the words people actually used about and to Ross and his family. All hurtful.
For Hurley, Ross is the petulant 3-year-old, and fandom is the 'OK, maybe I could have been a little more cool-headed in the way I reacted, but look: I had to speak in a way that hurt your feelings to stop you punching your mother.' Which is to say, since the punching is a metaphor: ' .... but I had to speak in a way that hurt your feelings in order to stop you speaking in a way that would hurt feelings.'
The whole force of Hurley's post hinges on the imbalance of power it assumes: relatively powerless massed fandom, super-powerful white male TV celebrity. 'When did the privileged become victims?' she asks.
OK. So: one unintended consequence of reading her post, for me at least, was to wonder how the actual punching conceit might work.
Imagine a world-famous professional boxer who happened to be a massive genre fan -- an alt-reality Muhammed Ali, say. Let's say he was proposed as host, and people objected 'we can't have him as host! He will literally punch all the nominees in the face! That's what he does!' How would you respond? Let's try: no he won't. Punching people is what he does in his day job; he's here not as a boxer but as a fan whose boxing happens to have made him world famous.
Jonathan Ross's day job is: comedian. His style (like it or loathe it) is comically confrontational rather than mild and agreeable, but that's his day job. He agreed to host the Hugos as a fan, not as a television presenter.
His day job involves him interacting not with privileged people (people like me); but with super-privileged people ... folk of staggering wealth and power, movie stars, rock stars at the like. His modus operandi is: not to give these super-privileged people too easy a ride ('when did the privileged become victims?') These people do not agree to appear on his show out of the kindness of their hearts; they do so because they intend to parlay the media exposure into even greater reserves of wealth and power. To make their blockbuster an even bigger hit, or sell even more copies of their album. Ross could, as some TV interviewers do, treat these entitled megarich celebrities with fawning deference, and thereby get as little in the way of them selling their shit to us as possible. He doesn't do that. Here's the thing: him 'not doing that' is him doing his job. You can of course object to it; but it seems to me you can't object to it on the grounds that by doing so he is picking on the disempowered or underprivileged.
Here's one scenario: Ross comes to the Hugos, makes fun of all the cowering fat boys and fat girls, laughs in their faces and then drives away in his open-topped sports car with a cigar jammed in the corner of his smug, laughing mouth. Thank heavens we have averted that dire possibility.
Here's another scenario: Ross agrees to host the Hugos for free, because he's a big genre fan. He is immediately attacked by many other fans on the grounds that he is a sexist misogynist, and not wanted, and he can take his working class speech-impedimented masculinity and his fat geek wife and their fat geek daughter and fuck off, basically (I paraphrase). He reacts testily online, and soon enough withdraws. His wife deletes her twitter feed because she finds the tweets she is receiving so upsetting. All the stuff that has actually happened.
This, to revert to Hurley's analogy, is two sides raising their voices. One side, though, is raising their voice as a proxy for raising their fists. Which, though?
I'm not suggesting that the metaphorical playing field is level, where power and influence are concerned. But I am suggesting that the victims of Ross's discourtesy, the people who have been the butt of Ross's public jokes -- the people instanced as the reason why he is The Devil in this context -- are more stratospherically privileged not only than the average SF fan, but than Ross himself. As Frankie Boyle (is he free to host the awards, I wonder?) once put it: you think these megacelebrity filmstars and rockstars are 'like' you, or want to be your friend? You don't realise that they would throw themselves under a bus if they had to live your life for so much as one afternoon? When did the privileged become victims?
So, yes: I've changed my mind on this issue.
I'm not convinced, Adam. I think focusing on Ross so closely as an individual is to miss the point, in some ways. I think this comment is good: "The problem is not with Ross's professionalism (how far he understands the limits of a particular gig, how far he understands the sensitivities of the community) - although they come into it. The main problem with him as host was and always has been with the permissions that his reputation gives others with less sense." He may well have been capable of turning up and being a professional, respectful, entertaining host. But he still stands for, predominantly, laddish, not-very-clever humour; that association is not appropriate for this convention, at this time; and no work was done to allay concerns about that reputation.
ReplyDelete(And there are ways and ways of puncturing celebrities, I think. It's not as if famous women don't get sexist crap all the time, at a volume far exceeding that received by most mere mortals. I don't think the fact that they are famous and, to that extent, powerful, legitimises being sexist towards them.)
No, I'm not convinced either. When I heard that Ross was the host I knew he was a fan and I assumed he wasn't getting paid (I didn't know Gaiman had asked him but it seemed pretty obvious he must be doing it as a favour). I think he might well have been a good host but that isn't really the issue (and potential publicity or the chance to flog more books certainly aren't the issue). It's a question of values and culture. A significant chunk of fandom aspires to be better than mainstream society when it comes to sexism and tolerance. It usually fails but that is the aspiration. In that context, it doesn't really matter if Ross is a fan or a good bloke, he is still very much part of a different culture with a different set of values.
ReplyDeleteIn an ideal world, the chairs and committee would have had a dicussion about what they wanted their values to be (and hence who they wanted to host) behind closed doors. Alas that didn't happen. Much of your post is devoted to the aftermath and you might well say that fandom wasn't living its values then but it is a seperate issue and I'm not sure why it would make you reconsider your initial decision.
I don't have any privilege-measuring instruments, so I'm not going to get into that debate, but let me respond to one thing. You write, "Jonathan Ross's day job is: comedian. His style (like it or loathe it) is comically confrontational rather than mild and agreeable, but that's his day job. He agreed to host the Hugos as a fan, not as a television presenter."
ReplyDeleteI think Kameron Hurley addresses this appropriately: Why couldn't Ross simply have said that? As she writes,
"So instead of snarking back at people on Twitter and calling them nutjubs and invoking Neil Gaiman’s name as a ward of protection, it would have behooved the privileged person to stand back and say, 'Hey. Wow. I’m so sorry! I didn’t realize so many of you had that impression. Let me assure you that I love and support this community and I take this gig seriously. I respect and love every single one of you and please be assured I’ll be respectful and welcoming, just as I hope you will be respectful and welcoming to me as a host.'"
Again, I set aside the "privileged person" business. Without it, the point stands and is maybe stronger. If Ross had acknowledged that he could understand why people might be made nervous precisely because of what he does in his "day job," and then explained that he wasn't going to be playing that role as Hugo host, then he surely would have won a great many people over. Not everyone, but many people. Instead he got resentful, as did Gaiman. In all of this both of them have given off a how-dare-you-question-me vibe that I find unpleasant.
Oh, I forgot something: the problem with your boxer analogy is that no one would ever fear that a boxer would start hitting people at an awards banquet, because an awards banquet is nothing like a boxing ring. But what Jonathan Ross does for a living is to talk in front of an audience; so if you hear that he's going to be talking in front of a different audience, it's not wholly unreasonable to suspect that he could do what he usually does. That's why I think reassurances are called for in this case, whereas they would not be if a boxer were involved.
ReplyDelete# I recognise that as a white male writer I have a less worthwhile perspective
ReplyDelete# on the whole brouhaha than many;
dude, seriously, you are an adult human being and your perspective is as valuable as anyone else's. You might be right, you might be wrong, but if we start saying your race and gender are a decisive factor in that, then we might as well go back to living in the trees.
Women threw themselves under the king's horse so that other women wouldn't always think that their viewpoint was less valuable than anyone else's. I don't believe, I choose not to believe, that they threw themselves under the king's horse so that one day men would think that way.
The other commentators here are ignoring the fact that the SF community conducts itself on the basis of online abuse up to and including death threats (I know, 'cause I've had them). Self-rightous twitterstorms and bullying are the norm. Attacks on people's character are the norm. The community is in denial about this, but when events like this happen, people outside the community see us for what we're becoming.
Alan Jacobs said:
# I think Kameron Hurley addresses this appropriately: Why couldn't
# Ross simply have said that?
Because when you're under attack by an angry, name-throwing mob on twitter, you don't generally have that of strategic insight. This is the most ridiculous attempt at defence I've read yet (no, I take that back, I have actually seen worse, but it is pretty bad). Asking why someone who was under attack didn't just say the magic thing that would have (supposedly) stopped the attack is bonkers. If you're under attack, you'll tend to just hit back, that's human nature.
everythingisnice says:
# It's a question of values and culture. A significant chunk of fandom aspires
# to be better than mainstream society when it comes to sexism and tolerance.
Get real: this is a community where we've had trolls calling for writers to have acid thrown in their faces for the things they wrote. This is the most intollerant community I've ever experienced (I won't be experiencing it for much longer, as I'm sure you'll be glad to hear). To say things like this is delusional.
# It usually fails but that is the aspiration. In that context, it doesn't really
#matter if Ross is a fan or a good bloke, he is still very much part of a
# different culture with a different set of values.
If Ross is a fan, then how is he not part of SF culture? Who appointed you, or your "significant chunk" to decide who is, or is not, a part of that culture? I do not see that you, or anyone, has the right to decide who is, or is not, part of the culture, or what the culture is. At the very least, before you make such statments, you should hold an election to ensure you really have the backing of fandom.
If mainstream society is now a 'different culture' with a 'different set of values' than SF, does that finally make us officiallly a cult?
Colum
Re-reading this in the cold light of day I realize that I shouldn't have called 'everythingisnice' delusional. They may not be seeing the stuff I'm seeing because they've not had my particular unpleasant experiences in this community, and I apologize to them for that. I was angry at seeing Adam devalue his own opinion in this way. If that is what we've come to, then things a bad beyond words.
ReplyDeleteThe community has deep issues, and the claim that we're "trying to make a better fandom" can't cut it anymore. Whatever it is that the community is trying to do, it's not working. It's destroying the community, and I think almost no-one feels safe in it any more.
Colum
Colum: thanks for that clarification. I agree: I don't think everythingisnice is delusional. As for devaluing my own words -- I may have expressed myself poorly at the head of this post. I'm not trying to imply that I don't have a right to an opinion on Rossgate. or anything else. To be clear I think I very much have a right both to have and express and opinion (which is what I'm doing here), But in this particular situation, the context of which has to do with the experience of female fans and writers, the long- and short-term history of that experience, and the on-going attempts to make 'fandom' less hostile to women's voices and presences -- taking all that into account, I'm not sure that my opinion is liable to have as much weight as the opinion of women who have direct experience. Being aware that one is privileged, as I am, isn't the same thing as believing that one should be silenced.
ReplyDelete