Sunday, 3 December 2023

Robert Jordan and Brandon Sanderson, ‘A Memory of Light’ (2013)

 


Some time ago, I read the whole of Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time. You can, should you be interested, see what I wrote in reaction to those many, many books in this volume (a mere £3.51 in paperback, it seems). Long story short: I was not a fan, and said a number of disobliging things about how derivative, badly-written and increasingly madly plotted, or non-plotted, these eleven fat tomes are. As the series proceeds each 800+-page instalment covers less and less ground in terms of narrative. It seems The Eye of the World (1990) was originally planned as the first portion of a Fantasy trilogy, but as Jordan went on commercial success and his ego extended the work according to a hyperbolic-curve Achilles-and-the-Tortoise logic.

Jordan’s fantasyland is a retread of Middle Earth: the ‘third age’ of a quasi-European landscape divided between bourgeois societies and older pre-modern ones, a great city ‘of the White Tower’ instead of Minas Tirith and a Volcanic ‘Mount Dhoom’. There are humble folk living in small villages menaced by sinister dark riders and trollish orcs, here called ‘trollocs’. There are colour-coded wizard castes, blue, white, brown, grey and so on, including ‘Black Ajahs’ who serve the dark lord. As in Tolkien the world is the staging place for a great war between the forces of evil, led by ‘the Dark One’, and the forces of good. For the sake of variation, Jordan rings superficial changes on his template: for instance, his wizards are exclusively women, the ‘Aes Sedai’ (aes aes baby—said I). Magic in this world is a kind of standing-reserve, an aquifer that can be tapped by various people, deriving ultimately from the One Power that turns the mighty wheel of existence from which the series takes its title—but with this hitch, that although women (or: some women) can use this magic for good, when men do so it inevitably drives them mad and turns them to evil.

In The Eye of the World the novel’s gender-swapped Gandalf, Moiraine, and her Strider-like warrior companion al'Lan Mandragoran come to the distant village of Edmond’s Field. Here the main characters are living their humble lives: young Rand al-Thor, a sheep farmer, and his friend Thom (not Sam) and their friends Merry and Pippin—by which I mean to say Mat and Perrin. But the village is attacked by trollocs and dark riders. Moraine, who believes one of this group to be the prophesied ‘dragon reborn’, the hero who will lead the battle against the Dark Lord, hurries them away to safety, along with a young girl with healing powers called Nynaeve and a couple of others. From here the adventures spool out at immense length, characters travel all over the map (with which each volume is furnished), they separate, they reunite. Some narrative tension is provided in the first volume by a studied uncertainty as to which of the various friends actually is ‘the dragon reborn’, although this is resolved by the end of the book: it's Rand.

The first book, whilst nothing special, is pretty readable. But by volume 4, The Shadow Rising (1992), the momentum of the series begins a pronounced deceleration. As individual volumes grow longer (1993’s The Fires of Heaven is over a thousand pages) less and less actually happens. Instead characters are shuffled about, fixtures, fittings and costumes are described at enormous length, women tug on their braids and adjust their skirts, people drink tea and drink more tea. From time to time, Jordan stages his particular sexual kink, and women are tied up and briskly spanked. But in terms of advancing the story: nothing, again nothing, the inevitably impending final battle between the Dark Lord and the Dragon Reborn is deferred, and endlessly deferred. In the seventh volume A Crown of Swords (1996) a parching drought afflicts the world, which can only be ameliorated with a magic bowl. Nynaeve, Elayne and Mat go looking for this bowl, which they finally find at the end of volume 8, The Path of Daggers (1998); otherwise the story treads water for one and a half thousand pages. In volume 9 Winter’s Heart (1994) the story freezes altogether, as its title might imply: a winter grips the land, and nothing happens. And then, after volume 11, Knife of Dreams (2005), Jordan himself shuffled off his mortal coil, tugged down the braid and joined the choir invisible, and it looked as though the deferral would be eternal.

This is how I summed-up the whole series, in the above-linked Sibilant Fricative book.

Mostly I was reminded of a line from Tibor Fischer's celebrated, or notorious, Daily Telegraph review of Martin Amis's Yellow Dog: “the way publishing works is that you go from not being published no matter how good you are, to being published no matter how bad you are.” I can't think of a clearer illustration of that baleful truth than these novels. The first is pretty good; the last are staggeringly, stupefyingly bad.
But the series was, and continues to be, hugely successful; selling millions of copies annually, adapted into an ongoing Amazon TV show with a budget of hundreds of millions of dollars. Go figure. At any rate, Jordan's publishers commissioned Brandon Sanderson, not a master of laconic concision, to complete the sequence and write the final, twelfth installment. This he did at characteristic length, over three enormous, puddingy books: The Gathering Storm (2009), Towers of Midnight (2010) and A Memory of Light (2013).

So here we are. Should (I asked myself) I read these three books? I'm wrapping-up a History of Fantasy at the moment, and Wheel of Time, for all its profound and prolonged rubbishness, is a notable work in the mode just in terms of its popularity. Then again, I thought, I could perhaps invest that time in something less unpleasant, like sticking pins in my eyes or striking myself on the head with a hammer. In the end I compromised: I skimmed The Gathering Storm, omitted Towers of Midnight altogether and went through A Memory of Light. Surely in this final volume, I told myself, something must happen! And something does: the Dragon Reborn and the Dark Lord finally get to have their big battle, the forces of light winning (spoiler, but ... come on). At the same time Sanderson stays true to Jordan's distinctiveness, and his own muse, and piddles around at enormous, draining, rubbishing length.

This is not a well-written book. The characters all speak with the same voice (if you took away the names and just had the dialogue you wouldn't be able to tell who was speaking at any given moment),  description is bland and unvivid, pacing is sluggish, tension is nonexistent. Sanderson has carried-over one of Jordan's quirks as a stylist: that of a writer who jots down the first thing that occurs to him and thereafter never revises or polishes it. What do we have?
Jarid wiped his brow with his trembling palm, then slammed it on his map. [14]
All the best military leaders headbutt their strategy maps before battle. Didn't you know?
Karam began to tie a coin pouch at his waist: the gold coins inside had melted into a single lump, like pigs’ ears in a jar. [15]
The coins were like ... wait, what?
“Unsurprisingly,” he mumbled around her lips, “this is much more fun.” [184]
As I said to my beautiful wife only the other day: “mmMM mmbbMMMM nnmMMMbbb”.
Perrin glanced at Rand, then noticed the smile on Egwene’s lips. He caught the scent of her satisfaction. [215]
What does satisfaction smell like? I was going to check by obtaining a bottle of Chanel's Eau de Satisfaction, but when I got to the shop they had sold out. It's like that Rolling Stones song.
Mat thought eating a meal these days was like going to a dance where there were only ugly girls [326]
Mat should stop eating in the Sexism Restaurant.
Perrin had grown accustomed to—though not fond of—women who looked not a year or two older than he addressing him. [348]
Perrin should do likewise.
Sweat crept down Mat’s brow like ants. [390]
This is such a gloriously bad simile it's actually quite endearing. It's like a small kid trying to write English prose.
He climbed to the fourth level. He could smell the sea on the breeze. Things always smelled better when one was up high. Perhaps that was because heads smelled better than feet did. [391]
I scratch my head at the logic of that because.
Selucia looked out. Her skin was the color of cream, but any man who thought her soft would soon learn otherwise. Selucia could teach sandpaper a thing or two about being tough. [392]
Selucia appears to have some revolting skin condition. She should get hold of some Chanel's Crème Hydration de Satisfaction.
A middle-aged woman entered with her dark hair in a bun. She was squat, shaped kind of like a bell. [483]
On the downside, no arms or legs; but on the upside think of the resonant chiming noise she is able to make! (Seriously though: that kind of is a real tell. No self-respecting writer would leave that in their final draft).
He almost did not notice that the servants were undressing him. [483]
Happens to me all the time, that.
Uno took a deep breath and continued. “I can’t understand it, Mother. Some goat-headed messenger told us that the Aes Sedai on the hills were in trouble and we needed to go up the flaming backsides of the Trollocs attacking them.” [700]
They're not going to win ‘Rear of the Year’ like that.
Rand faced the emptiness. “So,” he said, “this is where it will really happen. Moridin would have had me believe a simple sword fight would decide this.”

HE IS OF ME. BUT HIS EYES ARE SMALL.

“Yes,” Rand said. “I have noticed.” [769]
I have nothing to add to this exchange.
The dragons probably looked busted up something good. [847]
That's an actual sentence, actually in this book. Can you imagine Tolkien writing that? Or Ursula Le Guin? Sheesh.
Honestly. Women. She did have a nice backside, but Mat had only mentioned it to be friendly. He was a married man. [848]
Doesn't Mary have a lovely bottom! Of course they all have lovely bottoms.
[Gawyn’s] eyes clouded with cold perspiration. [876]
Sweating eyeballs would be out of place in a realist novel, of course; but this is Fantasy, and all sorts of magical things are possible.
She was beautiful, with perfect ears and wonderful eyebrows. [1062]
The two things all men look for in an attractive woman.

So, yes: this is not a good novel. On the upside, Sanderson avoids all the creepy spanky-spanky with which Jordan littered his instalments. Indeed, Sanderson's rare gestures at ‘grown-up’ sexiness or swearing are sweetly unconvincing. As with this real, salty, macho-man cussing: ‘“the Amyrlin,” he said. “She flaming wanted a messenger, and I was bloody chosen. Gave Egwene’s bloody report to your commanders, for all the bloody good it will do. We’ve set up our flaming battle positions and the place is a bloody mess.”’ [298] Oooh! Cover the children's ears! It's LDS propriety and conservatism throughout (‘a woman in trousers picked through documents on a table’ [534]—in trousers, do you say?—) coupled to a technical immaturity and clumsiness. I do not recommend.

Saturday, 18 November 2023

A Tumultuary Time Beneath the Drugget


The Tritonian Ring (published as short stories from 1951 onward, the whole published as a stand-alone novel in 1968) tells of the quest of Prince Vakar to save his sinking continent, Poseidonia, from the wrath of antagonistic gods: a peripatetic series of adventures fighting headless zombies, gorgons, giant crabs and octopus-headed creatures. The violence is gruesome (‘he struck right and left, slicing open torsos and reaching arms, spraying blood … looking across the shambles, Vakar saw the king lying with his head staved in’ [154]), the misogynistic sexual-objectification of women more so:—at the court of Queen Porfia, Vakar ‘felt an urge to leap up and seize’ his hostess, since ‘she had a form that practically demanded rape of any passing male’ [56]. As the story proceeds Vakar is accosted by the erotic importuning of naked amazon queens, naked satyr-women (‘quite human except for the horse-tail and pointed ears’) and even naked puritans—although the latter start-off clothed: ‘she blinked her large dark eyes at him. “I cannot endure these fanatical notions of order, and I burned with passion for you from the moment I saw you—oh, take me! You shall never regret it!’ [151]. He does, and with various others too, although in the end he marries Queen Porfia, having resisted his, as de Camp believes, perfectly natural rapacious urges. Indeed she extracts a promise from him that he will stick with her in the longer term:
‘I speak of other kinds of love, not merely carnal love, which for all its delights both of us know for a sly deceiver. Oh, I know you would give me a tumultuary time beneath the drugget; but how about the long pull?’ [de Camp, The Tritonian Ring 202]
They don’t write ’em like this any more. Thank heavens.

Friday, 10 November 2023

‘A Baum? What are you giving him a Baum for? It might bite him.’ Thoughts on Oz


One might almost think, from my title up there, that I'm not taking this topic seriously. But I am! I recently blogged, at some length and involution, about the 1939 movie version of L Frank Baum's story; and from there I have revisited, or in many cases read for the first time, the original novels.

The Wonderful Wizard of Oz (1900) is what Farah Mendelsohn calls a ‘portal fantasy’, a phrase she coins to distinguish it and its sort (Narnia, Cherryh’s gates of Ivriel, Mr Benn’s changing room, Gene Wolfe’s There Are Doors and the like) from ‘immersive fantasy’ such as Lord of the Rings or Westeros, which posits its own separated imaginative space. In a ‘portal fantasy’ characters from our world pass into the magical fantasyland and back again.

The portal that links our world and Oz is: the air. Which is to say distance. In The Wonderful Wizard of Oz (1900), Dorothy Gale, a young girl living on a farm in Kansas, is carried through the air by a tornado, and deposited in the fantasyland of Oz. The story is too well-known to need summary here: Dorothy experiences a series of adventures in Oz making friends with various people—a talking lion, an ur-robotic tin man and a living straw-filled scarecrow as she processes towards the titular wizard, whom she believes can magic her back home to Kansas. Her antagonist is a wicked witch, whose sister Dorothy has inadvertently killed, and who places various obstacles in her way. The titular wizard turns out not to possess magical powers, and is in fact a con-man from Nebraska masquerading as a mighty sorcerer in order to rule over Oz. Dorothy eventually makes her way home, but in subsequent novels she returns to Oz and settles there permanently.

The sequels The Marvelous Land of Oz (1904) and Ozma of Oz (1907) introduce the ruler who succeeds the Wizard, princess Ozma. I'll come back to her. In Dorothy and the Wizard in Oz (1908) Dorothy, shaken out of her mundane world by an earthquake, passes through an underground adventure—Ozma eventually rescues her by means of a magic emerald belt that teleports her and her companions to Oz. The Road to Oz (1909) follows broadly the same narrative pattern: Dorothy trekking from our world to Oz, this time along a magic road that passes through a dimension of talking animals, rainbow beings, Scoodlers (who fight by pulling off their own heads and throwing them at others) and other things. Passage from here into Oz requires crossing the ‘Deadly Desert’, which journey in this novel is effected by a ‘sand-boat’.

At the end of the next volume, The Emerald City of Oz (1910) the portal is, in effect, shut down. An army of ‘Nomes’ attempts to invade Oz, and though they are repelled a magic spell is cast to prevent any future invasion, making Oz unreachable to everyone except those within the land itself. ‘We must not hesitate to separate ourselves forever from all the rest of the world,’ declares the good witch Glinda. The spell she casts ‘won't affect us at all’ but ‘those who fly through the air over our country will look down and see nothing at all. Those who come to the edge of the desert, or try to cross it, will catch no glimpse of Oz, or know in what direction it lies.’ The novel’s last chapter includes a ‘note’ from Dorothy Gale, ‘written on a broad, white feather from a stork's wing’:
YOU WILL NEVER HEAR ANYTHING MORE ABOUT OZ, BECAUSE WE ARE NOW CUT OFF FOREVER FROM ALL THE REST OF THE WORLD. BUT TOTO AND I WILL ALWAYS LOVE YOU AND ALL THE OTHER CHILDREN WHO LOVE US. DOROTHY GALE. [Baum, Emerald City of Oz, ch 30]
Baum, tired of writing Oz books and wanting to concentrate on other things, planned to make Emerald City the last; but demand and financial exigency soon brought him back to the series. The Patchwork Girl of Oz (1913) opens with a prologue in which Baum explains how he was able to write the story despite Oz’s magical isolation: wireless telegraphy (the novel, Baum says in a prologue, ‘would not have been possible had not some clever man invented the “wireless” and an equally clever child suggested the idea of reaching the mysterious Land of Oz by its means’). The story itself is set entirely within Oz, although what was, in 1913, high tech replicates the original portal: rapid passage through the air, now of radio waves rather than storm-tossed houses and balloons.

Seven further novels followed (seven! so much for quitting the series in 1910): Tik-Tok of Oz (1914), The Scarecrow of Oz (1915), Rinkitink in Oz (1916), The Lost Princess of Oz (1917), The Tin Woodman of Oz (1918), The Magic of Oz (1919) and Glinda of Oz (1920). In some of these the ‘portal’, as it were, reopens: for instance, in Scarecrow of Oz the Scarecrow travels from Oz to help two Californians who have gotten themselves in trouble, and in The Magic of Oz two characters are able to slip past Glinda’s magic embargo by transforming themselves into animals, the implication being that Oz is only forbidden to human beings. But the later novels suffer from an increasing sense of imaginative exhaustion, repeating story-shapes, characters and moments from the earlier books.

In the early novels Oz is reachable from the mid-west USA, but is, presumably, too far away to walk. Passage is facilitated by aerial speed of the tornado that whisks Dorothy from Kansas, and the hot air balloon that carries the ‘wizard’ himself (whose actual name is Oscar Diggs) from Omaha, Nebraska: moved, we can intuit, in an austral direction—hence ‘Oz’—across a wide desert and to this fantastical land. An exchange between the Wizard and Dorothy in chapter 15 of the original novel tells us that Nebraska is further north of Oz than Kansas: “I was born in Omaha—” “Why, that isn’t very far from Kansas!” cried Dorothy. “No, but it’s farther from here”’). It is not usual to identify Oz with Mexico—a country like and unlike the USA, exotic and familiar—although it may be relevant that the Mexican national name derives from the Nahuatl mētztli, ‘moon’. A human carried through the air in a storm, or travelling by balloon, and ending up in a fantastical-satirical version of the moon is one of the oldest premises in fantastika. Lucian’s 2nd century AD novel Ἀληθῆ διηγήματα (‘A True Story’) sweeps up its protagonists in a whirlwind and deposits them on the moon—where a variety of fantastical exaggerations and inventions, peoples and creatures refract satirically back upon Lucian’s own society. Edgar Allan Poe’s satire ‘The Unparalleled Adventure of One Hans Pfaall’ (1835) carries its hero to the moon in a balloon.

In terms of in-story logic, Oz is so named its ruler, the fairy princess Ozma, first introduced in The Marvelous Land of Oz (1904). That novel starts with a boy called ‘Tip’, but we discover that the wicked witch of the North, Mombi, has swapped Ozma’s gender and wiped her memory to stop her claiming her inheritance. Turned back into a girl by Glinda the Good Sorceress, Ozma takes the Throne of Oz. In later Oz books Baum specifies that Ozma is an immortal fairy, who will forever remain a beautiful fourteen-year-old and so will always rule Oz: ‘born of a long line of Fairy Queens, as nearly perfect as any fairy may be’ [The Scarecrow of Oz (1915), ch 21].

But in Dorothy and the Wizard in Oz (1908) we get a different story. Here the ‘Wizard’ reveals his name to be Oscar Zoroaster Phadrig Isaac Norman Henkle Emmannuel Ambroise Diggs, an ungainly set of monikers chosen by his scornful father to spell out Oz-PINHEAD—that is, Oscar ‘stupidhead’—which Diggs, as an adult, shortened. He explains
“Surely no one could blame you for cutting your name short,” said Ozma, sympathetically. “But didn't you cut it almost too short?”

“Perhaps so,” replied the Wizard. “When a young man I ran away from home and joined a circus. I used to call myself a Wizard, and do tricks of ventriloquism … Also I began to make balloon ascensions. On my balloon and on all the other articles I used in the circus I painted the two initials: ‘O. Z.’, to show that those things belonged to me. One day my balloon ran away with me and brought me across the deserts to this beautiful country. When the people saw me come from the sky they naturally thought me some superior creature, and bowed down before me. I told them I was a Wizard, and showed them some easy tricks that amazed them; and when they saw the initials painted on the balloon they called me Oz.” [Dorothy and the Wizard in Oz, ch 15]
He unites the four separate realms, previously ruled-over by four witches (‘the people thought my power was greater than that of the Witches; and perhaps the Witches thought so too, for they never dared oppose me’) and builds the Emerald City ‘just where the four countries cornered together, and when it was completed I announced myself the Ruler of the Land of Oz.’ This may make us think of the four provinces of Ireland, the ‘emerald isle’, with the land of the Munchkins approximating Munster, the Gillikins Connacht, the Winkies Ulster and the Quadlings Leinster. ‘Oscar’ is an Irish name, or at least a Celtic one—it came into currency with James McPherson’s gallimaufry of Celtic myth and individual forgery, The Works of Ossian (1765)—and Diggs’s third name, in Baum’s idiosyncratic spelling of Pádraig, points in the same direction. At the same time the ‘Z-for-Zoroaster’ is clearly not Irish, but oriental: something mystic, transcendent. But if ‘Oz’, as the sounded-out first syllable of ‘Oscar’, or as ‘O.Z.’, is why Oz is called Oz, then Ozmar (‘the mother of Oz’, one presumes) must similarly be a reference to Diggs.

I mean, I'm straying into some abstruse and unlikely interpretation here, I'm well aware. But there's a long critical tradition of that.
In his 1964 classic article in American Quarterly, Henry Littlefield's finds that The Wonderful Wizard of 0z contains a ‘symbolic allegory’ which ‘delineated a Midwesterner's fibrant and ironic portrait of this country as it entered the twentieth century.’ In Littlefield's reading, Baum's Scarecrow was a farmer, the Tin Woodman was a dehumanized industrial worker, and the Cowardly Lion represented ‘William Jennings, Bryan himself.’ According to this view, the story was made from the political materials of the 1890s and authored by a social observer sympathetic to the Populists. Yet, in a more recent analysis, William Leach argues that politics and social criticism are not apparent in L. Frank Baum's work. Rather, Leach contends that Baum did not ‘express much concern for poor farmers or for any mistreated Americans. All evidence points the other way - that he preferred to identify with the “best people,” with the winners in American society, not with the losers.’ While, for Littlefield, Baum's tale reflects a nineteenth-century political culture that valued producerism and agrarianism, for Leach, Baum was a twentieth-century proclaimer of the glories of consumption and industrial capitalism. [Gretchen Ritter, ‘Silver Slippers and a Golden Cap: L. Frank Baum's The Wonderful Wizard of Oz and Historical Memory in American Politics’, Journal of American Studies 31:2 (1997), 172]
This is the least of it. It used to be argued that the Oz books were actually all about, I kid you not, the bimetallism debate in the States, with Henry Littlefield making the case for the book as an allegory for this issue, and Richard J. Jensen proposing that ‘Oz’ was derived from the common abbreviation for ‘ounce’, used for denoting quantities of gold and silver. My humble speculations seem almost common-sense by comparison. 

Folding Mexico (Old and New) and Texaco-Arizonico together, it does make a kind of sense to see Oz as American, in provenance and orientation. The Emerald City stands at the junction of the four states that comprise Oz. There is one place, and one place only, where that is true of the US: the point at which Arizona, Utah, Colorado, and New Mexico connect, known as ‘Four Corners’:



Baum's own map of his fantasyland was originally painted on glass and projected onto a screen (Baum created it for a tour in which he read from his stories and gave a lecture on Oz). When it was copied onto paper to be printed the inversion of up down west east was copied over too, or so the story goes. At any rate, given the Carrollian logic of Baum's fantastical worldbuilding (inversion, parody and so on), we can treat this map as a looking-glass image of the world, such that the 'Nonestic' ocean (the non-east, that is the western or Pacific, ocean: but also of course the non-existent ocean) lies to the west, California becomes the Rose kingdom, and Oz maps more or less onto the Four Corners. 


Of the surrounding ‘shifting sands’ of the ‘great sandy waste’, Baum's last words, on his death bed, were allegedly ‘now we can cross the shfting sands’. Then again, in Ozma of Oz, Oz is surrounded on all sides by ocean, so absolute consistency is not the point here. Then there's this:
In 1905, Baum declared plans for an Oz amusement park. In an interview, he mentioned buying “Pedloe Island” off the coast of California to turn it into an Oz park. However, there is no evidence that he purchased such an island, and no one has ever been able to find any island whose name even resembles Pedloe in that area. Nevertheless, Baum stated to the press that he had discovered a Pedloe Island off the coast of California and that he had purchased it to be ‘the Marvelous Land of Oz’ intending it to be ‘a fairy paradise for children.’ Eleven year old Dorothy Talbot of San Francisco was reported to be ascendant to the throne on March 1, 1906, when the Palace of Oz was expected to be completed. Baum planned to live on the island, with administrative duties handled by the princess and her all-child advisers. Plans included statues of the Scarecrow, Tin Woodman, Jack Pumpkinhead, and H.M. Woggle-Bug, T.E. Baum abandoned his Oz park project after the failure of The Woggle-Bug, which was playing at the Garrick Theatre in 1905.
So far as I can see this was all just marketing, whipping up interest up to and including auditioning young girls to act as princess: publicity for his novels and the Woggle-Bug play and never intended more seriously. That said, writer-me finds this idea quite intriguing: it would be a thing to do, to work out a sort of Lord of the Flies (Lord of the Fl-Oz) tale in which the entire population of a private island off California is prepubescent children and L Frank Baum living a solitary life in a big house in the middle, like the pig's head on a stick. [I did wonder if Baum's naming was supposed to imply that ‘Pedloe’ island was close to the shore, easily reached by somebody in a pedalo, but OED tells me that latter word isn't coined until the 1940s.]

But this brings in another dimension. Lewis Carroll was a manifest influence upon Baum's imagination, and in many ways the Oz books approximate to ‘nonsense’ better than they do to Fantasy of the Narnian or Wolfean portal mode. But a shadow lies across Carroll's reputation (as it does across J M Barrie's Peter Pan). Some critics argue that there is something morbid about the way the pre-pubescent child is fetishized in their works, or worse something paedophilic. No such reputation adheres to Baum I think, although one might think it could: there is, as with Carroll, an intense focus on specific beautiful young girls (Dorothy, Ozma) who are forever fixed in their prepubescence. ‘The justification of secular art is the responsibility it bears for the enrichment of human awareness,’ says Peter Coveney. ‘The cult of the child in certain authors at the end of the nineteenth century is a denial of this responsibility.’ He is talking of Carroll and Barrie, but could easily have folded-in Baum.
Their awareness of childhood is no longer an interest in growth and integration, such as we found in The Prelude, but a means of detachment and retreat from the adult world. One feels their morbid withdrawal towards psychic death. The misery on the face of Carroll and Barrie was there because their response towards life had been subtly but irrevocably negated. Their photographs seem to look out at us from the nostalgic prisons they had created for themselves in the cult of Alice Liddell and Peter Pan. [Coveney, The Image of Childhood: the Individual and Society (1957; 2nd ed 1967), 241]
Baum looks somewhat jollier in his photographs than those other two, and there was a public construction (in which he took part) of him as the avuncular ‘wizard’-esque jolly old man. MGM put it about that the jacket Frank Morgan wears in the 1939 movie version was the very same jacket Baum himself had worn. It seems this wasn't true, but it feeds into the ‘persona’ of Baum-as-author. Shy, retiring Carroll, and strange, disconnected Barrie didn't do anything so hucksterish.

I've never found anything paedophilic in the Alice books, I must say. Here's what I said in another place.
There are several ways of addressing the ‘paedophilia’ angle as far as Carroll was concerned. One way, of course, would be simply to sweep him into the box marked Monster and refuse to engage with his tainted art. I think that would be a pity, not because I’m certain that his heart was perfectly pure when he took his photographs of naked nine-year-old girls, but because the art itself doesn’t seem to me tainted. The paedophile’s fantasy (I assume) is that of the sexually available child; but the striking thing about Alice is how unavailable she is, how expertly she resists attempts to assimilate her to our agenda. That she is her own person is the ground of her splendour. Indeed, her curious inviolability is, I think, absolutely integral to the way she works in these stories. I also tend to think that the best reading of the ‘Freudian’ symbolism of the books—all those vaginal doors, tight entrances, all those phallic swellings and shrinkings, swimming through seas of bodily fluids, the oedipal anxieties of the Queen of Heart’s pseudo-castrating cry ‘Off with his head!’—that the best reading of all that stuff is William Empson’s ‘The Child as Swain’ chapter in Some Versions of Pastoral. Empson engages enthusiastically with all the ‘Freudian’ symbolism in the books, but does so within the conceptual framework of Some Version’s larger agenda: putting the complex into the simple; the ironies of class; the relationship between heroic and pastoral modes. In fact, recently re-reading 'The Child as Swain' was a revelation to me. It brought home to me how far Empson's account is from being a straightforward Freudian decoding of Carroll's books, despite the fact that he, tricksily, insists that it is (‘the books are so frankly about growing up that there is no great discovery in translating them into Freudian terms’, 253). In fact Empson’s stress is on the way the (sexual) world of adulthood becomes nonsensical when it is, in Empson's rather brilliant phrase, 'seen through the clear but blank eyes of sexlessness.' That’s right, I think.
There's certainly a good deal of ‘off with his/her/their heads!’-ness in the Oz books: The villanous Princess Langwidere in Ozma of Oz keeps a collection of thirty heads in a gem-studded golden dressing room, and regularly swaps her own with any of these exchangeable crania. All are very beautiful (‘no two formed alike but all being of exceeding loveliness ... golden hair, brown hair, rich auburn hair and black hair; but none with gray hair. The heads had eyes of blue, of gray, of hazel, of brown and of black; but there were no red eyes among them, and all were bright and handsome’) and the Princess controls her wardrobe with ‘a curious key carved from a single blood-red ruby’: red like Red Riding Hood's cloak, to signify menses and therefore sexual maturity (in the 1985 Disney movie Return to Oz this character is combined with the witch Mombi). Jack Pumpkinhead, a main character in the novels, is a sentient pumpkin on a timber body who lives in a giant pumpkin house where he grows new pumpkins to replace his head every time it ‘spoils’. He buries the rotten heads in a graveyard beyond his garden, and seems unconcerned by the ship-of-Theseus dilemma of this circumstance:
‘I've a new head, and this is the fourth one I've owned since Ozma first made me and brought me to life by sprinkling me with the Magic Powder.’

‘What became of the other heads, Jack?’ [asked Dorothy]

‘They spoiled and I buried them, for they were not even fit for pies. Each time Ozma has carved me a new head just like the old one, and as my body is by far the largest part of me I am still Jack Pumpkinhead, no matter how often I change my upper end. Once we had a dreadful time to find another pumpkin, as they were out of season, and so I was obliged to wear my old head a little longer than was strictly healthy. But after this sad experience I resolved to raise pumpkins myself, so as never to be caught again without one handy; and now I have this fine field that you see before you.’ [Road to Oz, ch 16]
Then there are the aforementioned Scoodlers, who fight by pulling off their own heads and flinging them at their enemies. There are other examples too, although these various freudian-oedipal decapitations are only one aspect of the novels' repeating figures of (playful) dismemberment, bodily disintegration and reintegration. Not that Baum quite has Carroll's savagery. In Patchwork Girl of Oz (1913) Baum originally wrote a chapter in which Ojo the Unlucky and the titular Patchwork Girl encounter a species of vegetable people who grow ‘meat folk’ in their gardens to eat. Baum later thought better and deleted this chapter, though we still have some of Neill's illustrations and their captions for the episode, which show the heads of human children growing out of the ground and being watered by their vegetable gardeners. Carroll, I think, would have kept that scene in.

Still, my notional novel set in Baum's proposed Oz-themepark ‘Pedloe’ island could hardly avoid the fundamentally creepy, unpleasant vibe of the premise: the one adult man, the many pre-pubescent and cusp-of-pubescence girls (Ozma is fourteen forever), sealed away from the normal world. Like old Tiberius at Capri. Baum might indeed bite them, and do worse to them than that. A difference between Carroll's Alice and Baum's Dorothy is that the former seems more self-sufficient: she cries, from time to time, but otherwise passes through the dangers and anxieties of wonderland and looking-glass land with a kind of serene inviolability, untouchable even in a court convened to prosecute and execute her. Dorothy is altogether more anxious, uncertain, scared, especially in the earlier novels (a fact sealed by the fact that Judy Garland's performance has ‘fixed’ how Dorothy in a way no actor's performance of Alice has. Geoff Ryman's Was (1992), discussed in this post, though you have to scroll a way down, imagines Dorothy as victimised and violated, her Oz nothing more than a fantasy projection in her head into which she can escape her dolorous reality, and who ends up a whore, a destitute and eventually in a lunatic asylum. Hard to think of Alice being reimagined the same way. 

Sunday, 1 October 2023

G K Chesterton's “High Rise”




I wonder if Ballard read Chesterton's essay “Skyscraper” (1932; collected in Sidelights on New London and Newer York And Other Essays) and was influenced by it?
There is one lesson to be learnt from skyscrapers, which just now is very vital — or rather very deadly. It illustrates that huge inhuman anomaly of modern men being cut off from the very earth. It is connected with what I have said about the impossibility of scraping the sky and the possibility of scraping the soil. A perfect parallel of our whole argument might be offered, in a story of the men in the lower flats of a skyscraper starting to starve out the men in the higher ones. The men in the higher ones would have every advantage of what are called modern improvements and conveniences; light and ventilation and telephones and hot and cold water — until they were cut off at the main. But they could not devour telephone wires, and might even be averse from eating soap; and unless they could grow a kitchen-garden in a window-box, they would presumably die or surrender. A fine American epic might be written about the battle in the big hotel, with its multitudinous cells for its swarming bees. It might describe the exciting battle for the elevators; the war of the nameless and numberless guests, known only by their numbers. It might describe the gallant sally of 55783, who succeeded in seizing and working the thirty-second lift; the heroic conduct of 62o 17, in bringing up an armful of yams and sweet potatoes by the fire-escape; of the deathless deeds of 65991, whose name, or rather number, will resound for ever in history. It would be great fun.
A properly Chestertonian ‘High Rise’ would be fun, I think: and perhaps rather more fun than the slightly flattened lord-of-the-flies-esque guignolery of Ballard's version.

Saturday, 26 August 2023

Alasdair Gray, ‘Lanark’ (1981)

 

Alasdair Gray’s Lanark (1981) laminates two narrative lines, disposing them into four books (though Gray, perversely, orders the books: 3, 1, 2, 4). One of these is set in ‘our’ world, mid-twentieth-century Glasgow, and follows the childhood and young adulthood of Duncan Thaw: severely asthmatic, a talented if unconventional artist—like Gray himself, though Thaw’s fate is grimmer than was Gray’s: alienated, disaffected, constantly ill, he eventually drowns himself in the sea. The other narrative is the Fantasy component of the story. After his death Thaw wakes in an underworld version of Glasgow called ‘Unthank’, a place without daylight governed by an oppressive, Orwellian logic. This takes its place in a notable tradition: as for example The City of Dreadful Night (1874) by Scottish poet James Thomson (who wrote as ‘B.V.’), or Scottish novelist Margaret Oliphant, who rendered hell as an industrialised, lightless underground polis in A Beleaguered City (1880).

Posthumous Thaw falls in with a group of young people, a clique centred on a character called Sludden, who meet in the ‘Elite Café’. But as Thaw was an outsider in ‘our’ world, so he proves in Unthank; and his earthly eczema becomes hyperbolically rendered in this afterlife as ‘dragonhide’, a sickness by which his skin transforms into thick scales. Before his draconic transformation is complete Lanark itself is swallowed by a titanic mouth in the ground, and Thaw awakes in a Kafkaesque ‘Institute’, a kind of hospital that exploits its patients under the pretence of curing them, from which he resolves to escape. After these two versions of death—drowned in our world, Unthank swallowed by the earth—we learn that the next time Thaw expires he will ‘actually’ die, and the novel ends on this nihilistic, or perhaps nirvanic, note.

Gray worked for many decades on this novel, and its appearance in 1981 was in a sense untimely. It owes much to Mervyn Peake’s pseudo-Gothic fantastika, and anticipates by 20 years or more the surge of interest in ‘Weird’ fiction, but nothing else like it was being published at that time. Still, though it stood alone, it was a hit, and has remained a cult classic. Hard as it is to ‘fit’ into a narrative of genre fantasy in the 1980s, it is harder to decide whether the novel engages politically—published as it was at a politically divisive and highly agitated time—or not. For novelist Jonathan Coe, Lanark is ‘the quintessential political novel … its theme is the individual’s relationship to society, and this theme is inscribed not just in the narrative but in the formal apparatus of the novel itself, which embeds the story of the hero’s coming of age in the framework of an Orwellian dystopian fantasy.’ [Coe, ‘Nae new ideas, nae worries!’, London Review of Books, 30:22 (20 November 2008), 18]

Sara Wasson and Emily Alder see the resurgence of interest in Gothic, and the various neo-Gothic texts of the years 1980-2010, as indices of ‘late capitalism and its discontents’: ‘the 1980s saw an economic transformation in the West’ and neo-Gothic addresses the ways ‘the human subject [had] become increasingly biologized, the ideological hold of liberal humanism over the foundations of identity destabilised … with the Gothic not only unearthing the hidden, be it repressed desire or secret anxiety, but also as itself a thing of desire’ [Sara Wasson and Emily Alder (eds), Gothic Science Fiction 1980-2010 (Liverpool University Press 2011), 8, 14-15]. Gray, a socialist and Scots nationalist, devoted much of his life to political engagement, through pamphlets and articles as well as speeches; and the frontispiece for the novel riffs on that of Hobbes’s Leviathan, as if Lanark itself is a midrash upon the collectivised vision of polity of Hobbes’s vision, as standing against his fundamentally dystopian sense of life as nasty, brutish and short.

And yet—as you can see, Gray has altered Hobbes when rendering the legend of his version. The original, in the Introduction of the Leviathan is: ‘For by art is created that great LEVIATHAN called a COMMONWEALTH, or STATE which is just an artificial man—though bigger and stronger than the natural man, for whose protection and defence it was intended’ (by ‘art’ Hobbes means ‘thoughtful planning, contrivance, design’; the word was used, in the 17th-century, in contradistinction to ‘nature’, and refers to all that happens artificially rather than naturally). Gray changes this to: ‘By Arts is formed that great Mechanical Man called a State, foremost of the Beasts of the Earth for Pride’. Pride, clearly, is not the same thing as ‘protection and defence’, and arts, in the narrower 20th-century, sense of the word, were the business of Gray’s life, drawing, painting, design. Lanark includes a number of what we might call metafictional gestures, including an epilogue in which Gray introduces himself into his own story, but this frontispiece has already tipped the nod. Lanark is an intensely personal novel, looking not forward to the deracination of global capitalism and neoliberalism of the 1990s and 21st century, but back to Gray’s own childhood. The ‘fantasy’ of the book actualises and externalises the existential claustrophobia of a being-in-the-world curtailed physically by asthma and weakness and psychologically by neurodiversity, shyness and difference. It is a book of large scope, and many pages, that reverts repeatedly upon small spaces, imprisonment, being swallowed rather than swallowing. It is, I know, a precarious business bringing purely subjective responses into a work of what ought to be disinterested criticism, but I can perhaps report—as an individual who has suffered lifelong, and continues to suffer, from debilitating asthma—that when I first read Lanark as a teenager I was deeply struck by how accurately Gray represents the experiential aspect of that disease in this novel. Newer drugs make it more manageable now, but that was not Gray’s patience in the 1950s (or mine in the 1970s and early 1980s) and Lanark vividly captures how chronic, pervasive breathlessness shrinks one’s existence, seals one away in clinging cellophane. It is no coincidence that Duncan Thaw dies (the first time) by drowning. There is, believe me, nothing worse. ‘Thaw’ is a another kind of ironic reimagining, like Gray’s personalised arts-and-crafts Hobbesianism (which reverts Hobbesian collectivism upon one individual’s experience, and that individual Gray)—the Norse god Thor is the epitome of superabundant strength and outgoing-ness, where Thaw is physically weak and debilitated. But just as Thor wrestles the great ocean-dragon Jörmungandr—the ‘Midgard’ or World Serpent—that seeks to crush the breath from him and drown him, so Duncan not only wrestles asthma and an Eliotic ‘death by water’, he actually begins to transform into a dragon, and his experience renders Unthank as Midgardian, between the daylight of ‘our’ world and the final destiny of Duncan below in absolute death.

Of course, in a slogan popular in the decade when Gray completed his first draft of Lanark, the personal is political. The novel flirts with this: Sludden, expatiating on the proper role of work and love, says: ‘perhaps I've surprised you by putting work and love in the same category, but both are ways of mastering other people’ [Lanark, 6]. A grim sort of blurring of the personal and the political—though, we could say, perfectly Hobbesian. But elsewhere the ‘political’ is troped as a kind of hideous self-division. In Unthank Lanark meets a woman called Nan, who relates a strange sickness that afflicted him:
“I began to grow mouths, not just in my face but in other places, and when I was alone they argued and shouted and screamed at me. Sludden was very good with them. He could always get them singing in tune, and when we slept together he even made me glad of them. He said he'd never known a girl who could be pierced in so many places. … But they drove even Sludden away in the end (the mouths did), because as I grew worse I needed him more and he didn't like that. He was going into politics and he had a lot to do.” Lanark and Rima cried out together, “Politics?” and Rima said, “He always made fun of people who went into politics.” [Lanark, 371]
Ultimately Lanark represents a withdrawal from the social, from the intersubjective—from politics as such—into a private fantasy. It’s not a very comforting fantasy, but the retreat into the merely personal often is not comforting. Gray’s next book, 1982 Janine (1984), though a kind of masterpiece, further embeds this retreat: its narrator abandoning himself to elaborate erotic reverie and sexual fantasy even as he laments the failure of his fellow Scots to (a phrase Gray adopted from poet Dennis Lee, and made into his own slogan) ‘Work as if you live in the early days of a better nation.’ Gray published many other things, but Lanark and 1982, Janine remain his two major achievements, riffs on ‘fantasy’ in, respectively, a generic and a sexual sense. Lanark is a great novel of Glasgow, and rehearses inter alia that city’s sectarian tensions between Catholicism and Protestantism—in itself a reason for the book’s Fantasy.

Thursday, 24 August 2023

Tad Williams, ‘Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn’ (1988-1993)


 Williams is, to this day, best known for his Tolkienesque trilogy Memory, Sorrow and Thorn, comprising The Dragonbone Chair (1988), Stone of Farewell (1990) and To Green Angel Tower (1993). These very lengthy novels—the third one so ample its half-million words had to be split between two separate, blocky volumes upon paperback publication—detail the rise of a lad called Simon Mooncalf, from his lowly status as a kitchen boy in the castle of dying King Prester John, to saviour of the realm. Williams calls his Middle Earth ‘Osten Ard’, his elves ‘Sithi’, his wizards ‘mages’ and his Old Forest ‘Aldheorte forest’, folding into his story magic swords of power, enigmatic prophesy, wicked sorcerers, quests, enchanted scrolls, intelligent wolves, trolls, and all the paraphernalia of an enchanted pseudo-medieval Europe. What makes his trilogy different to the, by the late 1980s, excessively over-familiar fare of post-Tolkien heroic fantasy is the detail: the novels give us great shovelfuls of specific detail, a textual strategy Tolstoyan in ambition if not in execution. It means that the series is slow to start, the curtain rising on several hundred pages of scene-setting and authorial throat-clearing that a reader may find immersive, or else frustrating-offputting, depending. Eventually a larger story emerges from the welter of detail: Ineluki the Storm King, undead ruler of the Sithi, blights the land with the power of his dark wrath, forcing the scattered remnants of humanity to rally at the ‘Stone of Farewell’. Simon, rising from servitude and adolescence into an important adult role in the ‘League of the Scroll’, is caught up in the final battle of good against evil.

Williams’ prose is prolix but inexact. Of Ineluki, we are told: ‘he has become a smoldering ember of despair and hatred … he exists to see the present state of the world obliterated and its injustices made right, but his only window is anger’ [Stone of Farewell, 123]—writing that, in a general sense, communicates its meaning, even if it leaves us pondering how a smouldering ember can have a window and how such fenestration can be constructed out of so unsolid a material as anger. Late in the trilogy, Simon thinks back on all he has been through.
These old stories are like blood. They run through people, even when they don’t know it or think about it. He considered this idea for a moment. But even if you don’t think about them, when the bad times come, the old stories come out on every side. [To Green Angel Tower, 190]
Important, I feel, to keep your mind focussed at all times on the fact that blood is circulating around your body in a network of veins and arteries. Stop thinking about it, even for a moment, and it’ll start oozing out from every pore. Memory, Sorrow and Looooooong.

Tuesday, 22 August 2023

Randall Garrett and Vicki Ann Heydron, ‘The Gandalara Cycle' (1981-86)

 


The ‘Gandalara Cycle’ novels were co-authored, according to the books' title pages, by Randall Garrett and Vicki Ann Heydron. In fact they were written by Heydron, from a series of notes provided by Garrett, her husband (he having at that time a higher profile amongst SF fandom). The first novel in the series, The Steel of Raithskar (1981), sets-up the premise: first-person narrator Ricardo Emilio Carillo, an elderly and infirm university professor in ‘our’ world, is taking a cruise in the Mediterranean when a giant fireball crashes into the ship, as is typical of these sorts of cruises. Ricardo passes through ‘heat, pain and blinding light’ to awaken in the body of a young and vigorous man called Markasset, in the orientalised cod-Arabian fantasy-land of Gandalaran (a map is provided). Markasset embarks without excessive delay upon a series of adventures, alongside his companions: the beautiful female illusionist Tarani (she ‘speaks in a low and vibrant voice that set my spine tingling’) and a giant intelligent cat named Keeshah with whom Ricardo shares a telepathic bond. Seven novels.

In The Steel of Raithskar Ricardo is suspected of stealing a sacred jewel called the ‘Ra’ira’ and must prove his innocence via the expedient of questing-about, fighting people with swords and generally getting to know his new land, all the time riding his cat-friend like a horse. The Gandalarans are not surprised at Markasset’s consciousness being supplanted by a mind from another world: ‘it happens,’ an old man called Thanasset tells him, if ‘rarely’ (‘maybe once a generation ... I have read the accounts of most, if not all, of the Visitations’). To begin with, Ricardo/Markasset is often distracted by memories from his previous life (‘there was no way to say coronary thrombosis in Gandaresh’ [69]) but as the series goes on he increasingly immerses himself in his fantasy idiom and forgets his former life: adventure, fighting, sex (discretely rendered) and all the satisfactions of youth in a magical realm. There are giant white apes, beautiful princesses, a desert land, mysterious magicians, an ‘All-Mind’ overpower: all very John Carter of Mars in flavour. One thing that Burroughs doesn’t give us that Garrett-Heydron does is a strange (or at least, strange to me: I daresay this only indexes how square and sexually-repressed I am) tooth fetish: ‘I kissed her, tantalizing my tongue on the rounded tips of her large canine teeth. All thought was swept away’ [230]; ‘Her canine teeth were as well-developed as mine. Somehow, they looked even better on her’ [50]; ‘Her large canine tusks looked eager’ [207]. Phwoar, and so on.

There is rather a lot of bourgeois comfortableness in what is, notionally at least, a feudal bronze-age Arabian world:
The room we had first entered was merely a wide hallway with chairs. It led into a large, private sitting room which connected with several other rooms, including a tiled balcony where meals were served. We were in the private sitting room now, and Tarani was adjusting a fold of the gown while Zefra admired herself in a polished-brass mirror. [The Bronze of Eddarta (1983), 130]
They may not have discovered how to smelt iron, but these are people who appreciate the benefits of a private sitting room and comfortable chairs. Priorities in cultural/social evolution.

In the later volumes, Ricardo travels to the land where the giant intelligent cats come from, and also meets the draida, ‘dog-like in the same sense that the sha'um were cat-like’ [The Well of Darkness, 19]. So all your pet-needs are catered for. Eventually Tarani becomes new High Lord of Eddarta, announcing her intention to end its corrupt traditions of slavery, though this doesn't go smoothly to plan. Still, there are consolations:
Her lips were soft, responsive, eager. With a thrill of joy I slipped my hand under the fabric of her tunic and caressed her breast, full and firm. She moved and made a sound—and we took the time, then, to be free of all our clothing. [Well of Darkness (1983), 96]
Hot!
Gandalara is always hot, but the reflective quality of the sand in the desert made it seem suffocatingly, blisteringly hot. [The Search for Ka (1984), 260]
Hot!