Saturday, 26 August 2023

Alasdair Gray, ‘Lanark’ (1981)

 

Alasdair Gray’s Lanark (1981) laminates two narrative lines, disposing them into four books (though Gray, perversely, orders the books: 3, 1, 2, 4). One of these is set in ‘our’ world, mid-twentieth-century Glasgow, and follows the childhood and young adulthood of Duncan Thaw: severely asthmatic, a talented if unconventional artist—like Gray himself, though Thaw’s fate is grimmer than was Gray’s: alienated, disaffected, constantly ill, he eventually drowns himself in the sea. The other narrative is the Fantasy component of the story. After his death Thaw wakes in an underworld version of Glasgow called ‘Unthank’, a place without daylight governed by an oppressive, Orwellian logic. This takes its place in a notable tradition: as for example The City of Dreadful Night (1874) by Scottish poet James Thomson (who wrote as ‘B.V.’), or Scottish novelist Margaret Oliphant, who rendered hell as an industrialised, lightless underground polis in A Beleaguered City (1880).

Posthumous Thaw falls in with a group of young people, a clique centred on a character called Sludden, who meet in the ‘Elite Café’. But as Thaw was an outsider in ‘our’ world, so he proves in Unthank; and his earthly eczema becomes hyperbolically rendered in this afterlife as ‘dragonhide’, a sickness by which his skin transforms into thick scales. Before his draconic transformation is complete Lanark itself is swallowed by a titanic mouth in the ground, and Thaw awakes in a Kafkaesque ‘Institute’, a kind of hospital that exploits its patients under the pretence of curing them, from which he resolves to escape. After these two versions of death—drowned in our world, Unthank swallowed by the earth—we learn that the next time Thaw expires he will ‘actually’ die, and the novel ends on this nihilistic, or perhaps nirvanic, note.

Gray worked for many decades on this novel, and its appearance in 1981 was in a sense untimely. It owes much to Mervyn Peake’s pseudo-Gothic fantastika, and anticipates by 20 years or more the surge of interest in ‘Weird’ fiction, but nothing else like it was being published at that time. Still, though it stood alone, it was a hit, and has remained a cult classic. Hard as it is to ‘fit’ into a narrative of genre fantasy in the 1980s, it is harder to decide whether the novel engages politically—published as it was at a politically divisive and highly agitated time—or not. For novelist Jonathan Coe, Lanark is ‘the quintessential political novel … its theme is the individual’s relationship to society, and this theme is inscribed not just in the narrative but in the formal apparatus of the novel itself, which embeds the story of the hero’s coming of age in the framework of an Orwellian dystopian fantasy.’ [Coe, ‘Nae new ideas, nae worries!’, London Review of Books, 30:22 (20 November 2008), 18]

Sara Wasson and Emily Alder see the resurgence of interest in Gothic, and the various neo-Gothic texts of the years 1980-2010, as indices of ‘late capitalism and its discontents’: ‘the 1980s saw an economic transformation in the West’ and neo-Gothic addresses the ways ‘the human subject [had] become increasingly biologized, the ideological hold of liberal humanism over the foundations of identity destabilised … with the Gothic not only unearthing the hidden, be it repressed desire or secret anxiety, but also as itself a thing of desire’ [Sara Wasson and Emily Alder (eds), Gothic Science Fiction 1980-2010 (Liverpool University Press 2011), 8, 14-15]. Gray, a socialist and Scots nationalist, devoted much of his life to political engagement, through pamphlets and articles as well as speeches; and the frontispiece for the novel riffs on that of Hobbes’s Leviathan, as if Lanark itself is a midrash upon the collectivised vision of polity of Hobbes’s vision, as standing against his fundamentally dystopian sense of life as nasty, brutish and short.

And yet—as you can see, Gray has altered Hobbes when rendering the legend of his version. The original, in the Introduction of the Leviathan is: ‘For by art is created that great LEVIATHAN called a COMMONWEALTH, or STATE which is just an artificial man—though bigger and stronger than the natural man, for whose protection and defence it was intended’ (by ‘art’ Hobbes means ‘thoughtful planning, contrivance, design’; the word was used, in the 17th-century, in contradistinction to ‘nature’, and refers to all that happens artificially rather than naturally). Gray changes this to: ‘By Arts is formed that great Mechanical Man called a State, foremost of the Beasts of the Earth for Pride’. Pride, clearly, is not the same thing as ‘protection and defence’, and arts, in the narrower 20th-century, sense of the word, were the business of Gray’s life, drawing, painting, design. Lanark includes a number of what we might call metafictional gestures, including an epilogue in which Gray introduces himself into his own story, but this frontispiece has already tipped the nod. Lanark is an intensely personal novel, looking not forward to the deracination of global capitalism and neoliberalism of the 1990s and 21st century, but back to Gray’s own childhood. The ‘fantasy’ of the book actualises and externalises the existential claustrophobia of a being-in-the-world curtailed physically by asthma and weakness and psychologically by neurodiversity, shyness and difference. It is a book of large scope, and many pages, that reverts repeatedly upon small spaces, imprisonment, being swallowed rather than swallowing. It is, I know, a precarious business bringing purely subjective responses into a work of what ought to be disinterested criticism, but I can perhaps report—as an individual who has suffered lifelong, and continues to suffer, from debilitating asthma—that when I first read Lanark as a teenager I was deeply struck by how accurately Gray represents the experiential aspect of that disease in this novel. Newer drugs make it more manageable now, but that was not Gray’s patience in the 1950s (or mine in the 1970s and early 1980s) and Lanark vividly captures how chronic, pervasive breathlessness shrinks one’s existence, seals one away in clinging cellophane. It is no coincidence that Duncan Thaw dies (the first time) by drowning. There is, believe me, nothing worse. ‘Thaw’ is a another kind of ironic reimagining, like Gray’s personalised arts-and-crafts Hobbesianism (which reverts Hobbesian collectivism upon one individual’s experience, and that individual Gray)—the Norse god Thor is the epitome of superabundant strength and outgoing-ness, where Thaw is physically weak and debilitated. But just as Thor wrestles the great ocean-dragon Jörmungandr—the ‘Midgard’ or World Serpent—that seeks to crush the breath from him and drown him, so Duncan not only wrestles asthma and an Eliotic ‘death by water’, he actually begins to transform into a dragon, and his experience renders Unthank as Midgardian, between the daylight of ‘our’ world and the final destiny of Duncan below in absolute death.

Of course, in a slogan popular in the decade when Gray completed his first draft of Lanark, the personal is political. The novel flirts with this: Sludden, expatiating on the proper role of work and love, says: ‘perhaps I've surprised you by putting work and love in the same category, but both are ways of mastering other people’ [Lanark, 6]. A grim sort of blurring of the personal and the political—though, we could say, perfectly Hobbesian. But elsewhere the ‘political’ is troped as a kind of hideous self-division. In Unthank Lanark meets a woman called Nan, who relates a strange sickness that afflicted him:
“I began to grow mouths, not just in my face but in other places, and when I was alone they argued and shouted and screamed at me. Sludden was very good with them. He could always get them singing in tune, and when we slept together he even made me glad of them. He said he'd never known a girl who could be pierced in so many places. … But they drove even Sludden away in the end (the mouths did), because as I grew worse I needed him more and he didn't like that. He was going into politics and he had a lot to do.” Lanark and Rima cried out together, “Politics?” and Rima said, “He always made fun of people who went into politics.” [Lanark, 371]
Ultimately Lanark represents a withdrawal from the social, from the intersubjective—from politics as such—into a private fantasy. It’s not a very comforting fantasy, but the retreat into the merely personal often is not comforting. Gray’s next book, 1982 Janine (1984), though a kind of masterpiece, further embeds this retreat: its narrator abandoning himself to elaborate erotic reverie and sexual fantasy even as he laments the failure of his fellow Scots to (a phrase Gray adopted from poet Dennis Lee, and made into his own slogan) ‘Work as if you live in the early days of a better nation.’ Gray published many other things, but Lanark and 1982, Janine remain his two major achievements, riffs on ‘fantasy’ in, respectively, a generic and a sexual sense. Lanark is a great novel of Glasgow, and rehearses inter alia that city’s sectarian tensions between Catholicism and Protestantism—in itself a reason for the book’s Fantasy.

Thursday, 24 August 2023

Tad Williams, ‘Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn’ (1988-1993)


 Williams is, to this day, best known for his Tolkienesque trilogy Memory, Sorrow and Thorn, comprising The Dragonbone Chair (1988), Stone of Farewell (1990) and To Green Angel Tower (1993). These very lengthy novels—the third one so ample its half-million words had to be split between two separate, blocky volumes upon paperback publication—detail the rise of a lad called Simon Mooncalf, from his lowly status as a kitchen boy in the castle of dying King Prester John, to saviour of the realm. Williams calls his Middle Earth ‘Osten Ard’, his elves ‘Sithi’, his wizards ‘mages’ and his Old Forest ‘Aldheorte forest’, folding into his story magic swords of power, enigmatic prophesy, wicked sorcerers, quests, enchanted scrolls, intelligent wolves, trolls, and all the paraphernalia of an enchanted pseudo-medieval Europe. What makes his trilogy different to the, by the late 1980s, excessively over-familiar fare of post-Tolkien heroic fantasy is the detail: the novels give us great shovelfuls of specific detail, a textual strategy Tolstoyan in ambition if not in execution. It means that the series is slow to start, the curtain rising on several hundred pages of scene-setting and authorial throat-clearing that a reader may find immersive, or else frustrating-offputting, depending. Eventually a larger story emerges from the welter of detail: Ineluki the Storm King, undead ruler of the Sithi, blights the land with the power of his dark wrath, forcing the scattered remnants of humanity to rally at the ‘Stone of Farewell’. Simon, rising from servitude and adolescence into an important adult role in the ‘League of the Scroll’, is caught up in the final battle of good against evil.

Williams’ prose is prolix but inexact. Of Ineluki, we are told: ‘he has become a smoldering ember of despair and hatred … he exists to see the present state of the world obliterated and its injustices made right, but his only window is anger’ [Stone of Farewell, 123]—writing that, in a general sense, communicates its meaning, even if it leaves us pondering how a smouldering ember can have a window and how such fenestration can be constructed out of so unsolid a material as anger. Late in the trilogy, Simon thinks back on all he has been through.
These old stories are like blood. They run through people, even when they don’t know it or think about it. He considered this idea for a moment. But even if you don’t think about them, when the bad times come, the old stories come out on every side. [To Green Angel Tower, 190]
Important, I feel, to keep your mind focussed at all times on the fact that blood is circulating around your body in a network of veins and arteries. Stop thinking about it, even for a moment, and it’ll start oozing out from every pore. Memory, Sorrow and Looooooong.

Tuesday, 22 August 2023

Randall Garrett and Vicki Ann Heydron, ‘The Gandalara Cycle' (1981-86)

 


The ‘Gandalara Cycle’ novels were co-authored, according to the books' title pages, by Randall Garrett and Vicki Ann Heydron. In fact they were written by Heydron, from a series of notes provided by Garrett, her husband (he having at that time a higher profile amongst SF fandom). The first novel in the series, The Steel of Raithskar (1981), sets-up the premise: first-person narrator Ricardo Emilio Carillo, an elderly and infirm university professor in ‘our’ world, is taking a cruise in the Mediterranean when a giant fireball crashes into the ship, as is typical of these sorts of cruises. Ricardo passes through ‘heat, pain and blinding light’ to awaken in the body of a young and vigorous man called Markasset, in the orientalised cod-Arabian fantasy-land of Gandalaran (a map is provided). Markasset embarks without excessive delay upon a series of adventures, alongside his companions: the beautiful female illusionist Tarani (she ‘speaks in a low and vibrant voice that set my spine tingling’) and a giant intelligent cat named Keeshah with whom Ricardo shares a telepathic bond. Seven novels.

In The Steel of Raithskar Ricardo is suspected of stealing a sacred jewel called the ‘Ra’ira’ and must prove his innocence via the expedient of questing-about, fighting people with swords and generally getting to know his new land, all the time riding his cat-friend like a horse. The Gandalarans are not surprised at Markasset’s consciousness being supplanted by a mind from another world: ‘it happens,’ an old man called Thanasset tells him, if ‘rarely’ (‘maybe once a generation ... I have read the accounts of most, if not all, of the Visitations’). To begin with, Ricardo/Markasset is often distracted by memories from his previous life (‘there was no way to say coronary thrombosis in Gandaresh’ [69]) but as the series goes on he increasingly immerses himself in his fantasy idiom and forgets his former life: adventure, fighting, sex (discretely rendered) and all the satisfactions of youth in a magical realm. There are giant white apes, beautiful princesses, a desert land, mysterious magicians, an ‘All-Mind’ overpower: all very John Carter of Mars in flavour. One thing that Burroughs doesn’t give us that Garrett-Heydron does is a strange (or at least, strange to me: I daresay this only indexes how square and sexually-repressed I am) tooth fetish: ‘I kissed her, tantalizing my tongue on the rounded tips of her large canine teeth. All thought was swept away’ [230]; ‘Her canine teeth were as well-developed as mine. Somehow, they looked even better on her’ [50]; ‘Her large canine tusks looked eager’ [207]. Phwoar, and so on.

There is rather a lot of bourgeois comfortableness in what is, notionally at least, a feudal bronze-age Arabian world:
The room we had first entered was merely a wide hallway with chairs. It led into a large, private sitting room which connected with several other rooms, including a tiled balcony where meals were served. We were in the private sitting room now, and Tarani was adjusting a fold of the gown while Zefra admired herself in a polished-brass mirror. [The Bronze of Eddarta (1983), 130]
They may not have discovered how to smelt iron, but these are people who appreciate the benefits of a private sitting room and comfortable chairs. Priorities in cultural/social evolution.

In the later volumes, Ricardo travels to the land where the giant intelligent cats come from, and also meets the draida, ‘dog-like in the same sense that the sha'um were cat-like’ [The Well of Darkness, 19]. So all your pet-needs are catered for. Eventually Tarani becomes new High Lord of Eddarta, announcing her intention to end its corrupt traditions of slavery, though this doesn't go smoothly to plan. Still, there are consolations:
Her lips were soft, responsive, eager. With a thrill of joy I slipped my hand under the fabric of her tunic and caressed her breast, full and firm. She moved and made a sound—and we took the time, then, to be free of all our clothing. [Well of Darkness (1983), 96]
Hot!
Gandalara is always hot, but the reflective quality of the sand in the desert made it seem suffocatingly, blisteringly hot. [The Search for Ka (1984), 260]
Hot!

Friday, 18 August 2023

Evan Winter, "The Rage of Dragons" (2019)



‘The fighting men and women of the Chosen were already onshore, were already fighting and dying’ [3]; ‘He grabbed the man's wrist, breaking it across his knee. The dagger fell to the sand and Tsiory crashed his forehead into his opponent's nose. With his enemy stunned, Tsiory shoved all his weight forward, forcing the rest of his sword into the man's guts, drawing an open mouthed howl from him that spattered Tsiory with blood and phlegm’ [10]; ‘Tau stabbed and swung at limbs and faces. He sliced away someone's fingers, praying they'd come from an enemy's hand’ [44]; ‘Aren lifted his sword to defend. Kellan adjusted, hitting him on the wrist, separating hand from forearm’ [111]; ‘Blood from the wound on his face dripped on the floor’ [125]; ‘The jagged cut Lekan had given him was bleeding through its scabs. The man's head had felt like a rock when he'd slammed it into Tau's face’ [151]; ‘He hit him in the shoulder and then, as Jengo hopped back in pain, he cracked him in the neck. Jengo made a strange high-pitched sound and went down’ [179]; ‘Tau drew his arm back, near to blacking out from agony, and lashed with his remaining sword, slicing the demon across its chest’ [239]; ‘Tau fell to the murky ground and felt his insides spilling out. He looked down and cried out in pain and horror. His intestines were exposed to the air, ropes upon ropes of them. He reached down to try and push them back. The pain was indescribable’ [265]; ‘The creature closed its jaws on the back of his neck, cracking his spine and dragging him to the ground. With his spine severed Tau could not feel the leg or his rib cage being torn open by the two demons. He could hear them though, as they slopped up his innards and shook his body with their jostling’ [311]; ‘Tau's head lolled. He was dying. It hurt. It hurt so much’ [315]; ‘The bastard shot his other sword out and low, burying a handspan of bronze in the meat of his left hip. Kellen screamed and fell’ [415]; ‘Tau launched himself into the fray, swords whirling, and the closest man took a dulled blade to the face, shattering his eye socket’ [417]; ‘... a warrior woman with full lips, caramel skin, and astonishing green eyes. She moved like an ocean storm, her bladework brilliant. He took her hand off at the wrist and she gawped at him, as if to ask why he'd done it. He wanted to tell her he wasn't sure, but his bronze was deep in her breastbone and there was nothing to say that would have meant a damn’ [443]; ‘Tau dropped, cutting through the man's calf with his blade. The Indlovu began to fall, and as he did Tau drove his sword through his skull. The dead man collapsed on the tiled floor’ [486]; ‘She fell to her knees and clawed at her neck, and blood erupted from her ears, mouth, nose and eyes. With fingers clawed, she tore at her face, peeling stripes of flesh away in rolls. She opened her mouth wide, as if to give birth through it, and vomited a torrent of filth, her arms giving way as she did’ [491]; ‘The pain coursed through Tau like a tsunami ... he looked down at his wound. The demon had him open from belly to groin’ [509].

It's exhausting.

I'm not saying its badly done. If you like this kind of thing (which is to say, if you like ultraviolent Fantasy war-adventure with lots of hack-n-slash) then this, I would hazard, will prove the kind of thing you like. But, sheesh. I'd suggest ‘ugh’, but I really not sure Rage of Dragons rises to the level of a Lawrentian or Burroughsian ‘ugh’. Not to damn with faint praise or anything. What I'm saying here, it should be evident, reflects my own squeamishness as much as anything else.

It's a larger question, of course. Larger than this one novel, I mean. Why is contemporary Fantasy so often so ultraviolent? Is it the same reason why so much of contemporary culture more broadly is so in hock to ultraviolence? I read reviews of the recent Harley Quinn flick Birds of Prey that praised the movie specifically for its representation of violence—visually inventive, say the critics; fun, they say; well-choreographed they say, as if grievous bodily harm is an elaborate and expressive dance rather than an affront to our collective humanity. Such celebration goes, it seems to me, in tandem with critics praising the movie for putting women in front of and behind the camera, a tacit argument that Birds of Prey dramatises the revolt of oppressed womankind against patriarchy. Don't misunderstand my weariness, here. Manifestly, patriarchy is a structural violence, and manifestly men are often actually violent against women. But it seems to me the myth of the ‘kick-ass femme’ reproduces, rather than deconstructs, both those things. As if Harley Quinn could figure as a role model to any but the most morally amaurotic! I mean, it's possible that that's exactly where we are. But one hopes not.



I understand, of course, the argument that says: this is neither a representation of, nor a call to, actual violence—it's cartoon violence, like Tom and Jerry. Still, Tom and Jerry used to be a five-minute interlude between Crackerjack and Blue Peter. Now it's the whole schedule. Sure, we chafe against the restrictions of Civilisation and Its Discontents, and (sure) those discontents stem from the way we must constrain our desires and aggressions in the face of the provocations of others. But the fantasy that acting out our violent instincts would free us from this bind is as fatuous as it is mendacious. Do it really need saying? Physical violence in facile books and films simplifies, frees, acts cathartically and manifests graceful physicality; but physical violence in real life is always ugly, always upsetting, always graceless, never effects any longer-term catharsis and always, always but always complexifies and degrades the situation into which it is inserted. Violence is another word for intolerance—is, indeed, the purest somatic embodiment of intolerance. If intolerance, more broadly framed, is our problem, injecting more intolerance surely isn't the solution, howsoever we urge ourselves on with self-assurances that our intolerance is the good kind, not like their nasty and bigoted intolerance, and so on, and so forth. But, look: I'm getting preachy. You know the drill. I've hummed and ha'd around this question before, and at some length. Still harping on tortures? Apparently so.

There's an episode of The Sopranos (‘For All Debts Public and Private’ I think it is) where Tony gifts Christopher the identity of the now-retired cop who killed his, Christopher's, father. Tony drives him to this man's house and waits outside as Chris goes in. Later, during his session with his psychoanalyst Dr Melfi, Tony confesses that he sat in the car thinking about the ‘beating’ taking place, and wishing it was him, inside the house. This is connected, we assume, with Tony's sense that he's not as young as he used to be, his fear of waning powers. But Melfi's question, with respect to this desire to be where the beating was actually happening, is perceptive: ‘giving it?’ she asks. ‘Or taking it?’

Reading this novel, and having read many like it, I find myself struck that two things are always at play. On the one hand there is the idea of violence as something you inflict on others, others ‘who deserve it’ (to free you from any qualms your conscience might try to insert into the situation)—the idea, in other words, of violence as freeing, a freedom both from societal constraints and from your own motivations, thoughts and prompts (hence: an acte gratuit). But always, alongside this fundamentally sadistic notion, runs the masochistic one. The Rage of Dragons puts enormous emphasis on the long, exhausting and often painful training its characters must undergo, and spends as long on the wounds our guys receive as the ones they inflict: gloating accounts of enemies being hacked to pieces, and equally gloating accounts of we ourselves (that is, our fictional proxy) being on the receiving end of others' violence. Maybe that fictive jink that divides the universe in goodies (us) and baddies (them) isn't quite the get-out-of-jail-free card our conscience needs. Perhaps we must receive as much violence as we dish out in order that we are able to continue dishing it out. An eye for an eye, we might say, cuts both ways.

It's certainly hard to deny that movies from Rambo to Starship Troopers and Captain America: Winter Soldier are as much about how much violence and pain our hero can absorb as they are about how much he (in most cases it is a he) can direct against others. Swapping out the kick-ass hero in favour of a kick-ass heroine does not challenge or upend, but rather internalises and intensifies, this structural relation. It's not actually a case of ‘women have been on the receiving end of this kind of crap for generations, now it's our turn to dish it out’. That's for several reasons I think, and not the least of them is: men are on the receiving end, and always have been. In life, but egregiously so in art. Sylvester Stallone squatting in a cave and gurning in agony as he sews up his own wounds without anasthetic: Rambo is much more a masterpiece of masochism than it is an outwardly projecting power-fantasy. And that makes a kind of sense, doesn't it: because the System (Power, Foucault would say) absolutely depends upon our capacity to absorb its punishments—upon, in fact, our ability not just to take this, but to convince ourselves that we should, that this is the logic of reality, even that we secretly enjoy it. It isn't us, but we're encouraged to believe it is. In truth, as Ballard's Richard Pearson says in Kingdom Come (2006) ‘Violence is the True Poetry of Governments.’ So here we are.

Violence is a physical action, and its representation in art is an emotional prompt (to exhilaration perhaps; or disgust). Which is another way of saying: violence is not an idea. Me, I'm old-fashioned enough not to wish to forego the idea that SF is a literature of ideas. The problem is that an idea is always a constraint upon emotion; an idea is always a formulation, and therefore a formalisation, which is to say: a form. All the bollocks about violence as something to be ‘choreographed’, as a kind of ‘dance’, is a fundamental and, I think, self-serving evasion of the truth that violence degrades form, is always about breaking shit, not forming it. Our confusion (one, I'm tempted to say, structurally imposed upon us) is our belief that our guilt merits violence, along with this ideolegeme's correlative that violence is the necessary idiom of all punishment. But it need not be so. In Coldness and Cruelty Gilles Deleuze argues that ‘even guilt and punishment do not tell us what the law is.’ Rather he says, they ‘leave it in a state of indeterminacy equaled only by the extreme specificity of the punishment.’ He adds: ‘this is the world described by Kafka.’ Oh for a properly and fully Kafkaesque Fantasy novel today! Vain hope, I know.

So, yes: I suppose I'm suggesting this style of writing, so common today, only superficially appears sadistic. It's actually masochistic, in this specifically Deleuzian sense. In place of sadism's essentially institutional, apathetic and quantitative powers, connected as they are in our post-Enlightenment epoch with the demonstrative reason of the superergoist state, these sorts of novel are exercises in Deleuzian masochism. These works only mimic heat; they are in fact cold. They pay mere lip-service to justice and liberation; in fact they are cruel, qualitative and contractual (since the reader knows in advance what to expect here and will be angry if they feel ‘cheated’ of that; but also in the way violence against the other is ‘paid for’ in the currency of violence absorbed by the self).


Friday, 9 June 2023

Katherine Kurtz, ‘Deryni Rising’ (1970)

 

Katherine Kurtz's Deryni Rising (1970) was the first installment of what has since grown into a very lengthy series of linked trilogies of fantasy novels. The titular Deryni are a race, or caste, of humanoid warrior-sorcerers, possessed of various magical powers, who once ruled over the muggle human populations of Gwynedd—a version of early medieval England and Wales. Their power was overthrown centuries before, their people outcast and persecuted for many years, but as the series starts the Deryni are starting to re-emerge into human society again. 

I had not previously read any Deryni novels, but reading a little about them made them seem promising. Kari Spelling notes that Deryni Rising was the first book included in the Ballantine Modern Fantasy Series that was not a reprint from an earlier or dead author. Though ‘unequivocally fantasy’ it is, she says, ‘written more in the mode of the historical fiction of the time than its companion books on the Ballantine and other lists.’
It is closer to the complex and thoroughly researched novels of Dorothy Dunnett, Maurice Druon, and Zoe Oldenbourg than the fantasy that surrounded it …. Its treatment of magic too was dramatically different. This is a world of highly formal, ritual magic, without sorcerers, or demons, or exoticized and stereotypical “witchdoctors.” Magic requires training, careful and sometimes demanding preparation. It is never easy, or casual, and it is hard to come by … And it is set against a background of closely observed and detailed faith, which is closely intertwined with every aspect of her characters’ lives. [Kari Sperring, ‘Matrilines: The Woman Who Made Fantasy: Katherine Kurtz’, Strange Horizons (30 March 2015)]
Kurtz herself claimed that ‘in 1969, when I actually began writing Deryni Rising, the sub-genre of what I now refer to as historical fantasy did not exist. I was making it up as I went along, though at the time I thought that all fantasy had to have magical creatures, rhyming spells, and special languages.’

Reading this got my hopes up. Reading the actual novel, though, got those hopes right back down again to where they belong. It is possible that the later books in the sequence are more detailed and nuanced, more complex and rounded, but Deryni Rising is, well, not. It's a pulp melodrama with medieval trappings. The king of Gwynned, Brion Haldane, drinks poisoned wine whilst out hunting and dies. His teenaged son Kelson Haldane, inheriting the crown, must protect himself and his kingdom from the Deryni usurper who murdered his father. It' is easily readable, page-turny, and with some gestures towards things like court politics and the importance of church power. But there's nothing here of, say, Dunnett's richly woven complexities and textures.

Character are central-casting, stereotypes. Or, flatter than that: monotypes. The good characters are heroic in look and deed (‘dark, lean, with just a trace of grey beginning to show at his temples, he commanded instant respect by his mere presence in a room. When he spoke, whether with the crackle of authority or the lower tones of subtle persuasion, men listened and obeyed’). The wicked characters are decadent, devious, orientalised. If a man, feminised and semiticised. The main villain is the sorceress Lady Charissa, ‘the Shadowed Lady of the North’, attended by her dark-skinned ‘Moors’. This is how she first appears: ‘sat motionless on the pillow, a slender, pale figure shrouded in richest velvet and fur, delicate hands encased in jewelled doeskin gloves [her] blue eyes searched serenely across the clearing, noted with satisfaction the black-robed Yousef standing guard over the horses.’ Here is her accomplice, the cruel and wicked Ian Howell. Not that Ian Howell. This one:
Tall, slim, almost ascetic of face and feature, Lord Ian Howell viewed the world through a pair of eyes even deeper brown than his hair. A meticulously-tended beard and moustache framed a rather thin mouth, accentuated the high cheekbones, the slight cant of the round eyes—eyes which outshone the dark jewels that glittered coldly at his throat and ears. [17]
Howell, Howell, Howell, Howell! O, you are men of stones. Had I your tongues and eyes, I'd use them so that heaven's vault should crack and so on.

Stylistically the novel is egregiously in hock to cliché. It’s not often one encounters the phrase ‘why oh why’ in the wild, used in earnest rather than as Private-Eye satirical ridicule (‘why oh why had he promised Jehana there would be venison for her table tonight?’ [3]). Characters ‘laugh mirthlessly’ and ‘toss their heads defiantly’, heroes move with ‘catlike tread’, eyes ‘sparkle’ and ‘flash angrily’, and sometimes leap clean out of skulls and go scuttling around.
His eyes darted briefly over the Moor who reached up for his horse’s bridle, then came casually to rest on the grey-shrouded form of the woman. [14]
Characters scheme and plot in an excessively obvious plotting-scheming manner:
“I must confess, I rather like your little plan, my pet,” Ian murmured. “The deviousness of your lovely mind never fails to intrigue me.” He glanced down at her thoughtfully through long, dark lashes. “Are you certain no one besides Morgan will suspect, though?” Charissa smiled complacently and leaned back against his chest. “You worry too much, Ian,” she cooed. “Brion will feel nothing until my hand clutches at his heart—and then it will be far too late”
People don’t fight, they ‘cross swords’. Nobles pour themselves glasses of wine out of ‘crystal decanters’ from tables ‘of burnished oak, claw-footed legs resting solidly on the polished marble floor.’ Libraries have secret doors (‘a portion of the wall recessed to reveal a dark stairwell descending’). Deryni magic is an early video-film special-effect: ‘long sparks of golden light streamed from her fingertips’; ‘blue and red auras met, a sparkling violet interface crackled brightly in the darkness’.
Morgan whirled defensively on his haunches. [189]
That’s a neat trick! Not easy to do.
As he headed slowly for the door, watching her every flicker of an eyelash, every rustle of her gown, she smiled languidly. [131]
Can one watch a rustle? (‘a soft crackling sound similar to the movement of dry leaves’). Or perhaps we should say instead: eyesight sharp enough to capture such a thing would naturally make short work of a single flickering eyelash. So it all works out. On occasion the prose strains desperately for effect, bathetically-hilariously:
Brightness ... pain... swirling colors ... pain throbbing . . . a cool shiver of—what? . . . Pain subsiding... better now... cool weight in the hand ... Look! ... Colors ... swirling... faces: ... light, dark . . . light fading... faces... growing darker... spinning ... darkness ... Father! … [173]
The novel is not long, and the story not complicated. Though it should be obvious to any simpleton that Charissa is behind the poisoning of King Brion, the wrong person is suspected until the right person is. In the antepenultimate plot-turn, it seems Charissa has triumphed. Her champion Ian fights, single-combat, against Morgan, the king’s champion, and though cut down Ian manages to throw one last dagger, badly wounding Morgan. Charissa crows over him.
Charissa began to laugh. “Yes, who now is ruler of Gwynedd, my proud friend?” she taunted, as she strolled easily to where Ian still writhed on the floor. “I had thought you better trained than to turn your back on a wounded enemy.” 
As Kelson, Nigel, and other of Morgan’s friends gathered around the wounded general, Charissa glanced down at Ian and prodded him with her toe. When he gave a low moan, she stooped over to look him in the eye. “Well done, Ian,” she whispered. “What a pity you. won't be here to see the outcome of our little conspiracy.”

Ian grimaced with the pain, tried to protest. “Charissa, you promised! You said I would rule Corwyn that we would—Charissa, please—”

Charissa put her fingers across his lips. “Now, you know I detest pleading.”

… Charissa’s other hand moved in another spell. For a few seconds, Ian struggled to breathe, his hand clutching at her cloak in desperation. Then he relaxed, the life gone. Casually, Charissa stood up again. [246]
Of course there’s a final twist: Kelson, despite being a human and not Deryni, discovers he has within him Deryni powers, and blasts Charissa with a beam of scarlet magic: ‘the crimson at last engulfed her, she let out a long, agonized scream, edged with fury, which slowly faded as she grew smaller. Then she was gone.’ [267]. So much for her. Thereupon Kelson is crowned king, by a human crowner and also a sort of spectral Deryni crowner: ‘figure supported the crown above Kelson’s head—a tall, blond man garbed — in the shining golden raiment of the ancient High Deryni Lords … the shining stranger used the ancient Deryni formula, which bespoke quite a different destiny for the brave young King he crowned.’ [269]

Now it may be that Deryni-fans, the Deryniphiles, all those Deryni-girls (and Deryni-boys), the knights-who-say-Deryni, will tell me: I need to read on in the series. That it improves as it goes, gets less clumsy and gnashing. If so I will persevere. Should I?

Tuesday, 6 June 2023

Hannes Bok, ‘The Sorcerer's Ship’ (1942/1969)


Hannes Bok was the pseudonym (the moniker being, it seems, a variant of ‘Johannes Bach’, a favoured composer of the author) adopted by artist and writer Wayne Francis Woodard (1914-1964). Bok is known today for his fantasy-themed illustrations, many of which appeared in Weird Tales, and, amongst odd books on codes and astrology and whatnot, his writing of two short novels: The Sorcerer's Ship (first published in the magazine Unknown in 1942; reprinted as a Ballantine Adult Fantasy series paperback, 1969) and Beyond the Golden Stair (1948). To look at the first.

Gene Trevelli, a man from ‘our’ world, goes swimming off Coney Island and nearly drowns. He wakes to find himself floating on a ruined raft upon a strange ocean, rescued eventually by a ship that appears like ‘an old Venetian galley, two sails puffed and ablaze with colored lanterns’ [6]. He finds himself in a Fantasy realm, and is caught up in the battle between Koph and Nanich, two large island nations (the ocean is occupied only by them and ‘the uncharted isles in the far seas beyond’). The ship belongs to the beautiful Princess Siwara of Nanich, who is sailing upon a peace mission to Koph. But there is a traitor on board! Gene is immediately caught-up in the political machinations, whilst also developing a romance with the toothsome Siwara. The passage from mundanity to fantasy is explained away by Gene himself as an arbitrary Fortean happenstance (many people, we’re told, have ‘passed through a door which was a flaw in the elements which make the world … a man named Charles Fort compiled books of them’ [39]).

The ship, blown off course, odysseys through the uncharted islands, running upon a dead pyramid-city whose only inhabitant, an ancient fish-man creature, worships a mad god called Orcher, which deity obligingly makes himself known to the voyagers.
Orcher’s musical voice was enlivening, like a psychic wind which fanned the fires of life into a fiercer heat. Though it was tainted by nothing remotely resembling humanity, it was colored with passions, but passions no human could ever hope to know, so intense that at their faintest they would have blasted a mortal's body into atoms. And though the strange entity was only a great splash of light, Gene knew that it had eyes. [116]
At this encounter the tone of the book shifts, from a rather arch, rococo bookishness to a tenor of intensified violence. Koph has sent an armada to invade Nanich. Orcher decides to intervene, which he does by scattering destruction indiscriminately around, raining fire from the sky, summoning giants to crush the houses ‘like paper boxes’, and obliterating everything on both sides. His point, it seems, is at once to teach humanity the futility of war, and yet also somehow to taunt them into more fighting:
Orcher’s voice beat down on the captured city like a sledge of sound. “So you would make war, would you—you puny microbes! But can you do this? And this? And this? Then what good are your wars—what good can they accomplish? Some of you wanted power — what are your powers beside mine? Can you fight me? Will one of you — all of you — come forth to try it?” [196]
Then he vanishes leaving the survivors to pick up the pieces. Gene and Sirawa sail away to find refuge on an island somewhere. That's where the novel ends.

The romance between Gene and Sirawa is entirely without spark or believability, in part because the Princess is so entirely spindly and two-dimensional, more doll than woman, given equally to childish ingenuities and childish tantrums (‘she peered up at him, stamping a small foot in rage’ [54]). That Gene, a New York office worker without military training, suddenly finds himself a potent warrior with sword and bow in a Fantasy war is, of course, improbable; although that improbability is itself merely the index of the function of the novel as, precisely, wish-fulfillment. But that Sirawa is so cardboard, so unenticing and sexless, speaks to a more interesting disconnection of desire and reality. For all that this is a novel, in Paul Kincaid’s words, about how ‘a traveller from our world who finds himself in colourful, magic lands that are far more attractive than our own’ [Kincaid, ‘American fantasy 1820-1950’, in The Cambridge Companion to Fantasy Literature, (CUP 2012), 46] the actual colour and magic here are all told rather than shown, enchantment declared rather than evoked (‘the air here—it seems different—as if charged with electricity’ [12]). The book is a two-tone composition, half a faded and exhausted gesture in the direction of an—enchanted, heroic, heteronormative—adventure, half a violent swamping of that very fantasy in apocalyptic destruction.

This, it seems to me, is what is most interesting about his odd little novel. It was not the actual ‘fantasy’ of bookish, hermetic, gay Wayne Francis Woodard to leave his comfortable New York apartment, festooned with his artwork and horoscopes and precious items, and range out into the hostile world as an oceangoing warrior who seduces a conventionally-categorised beautiful princess-woman female. And yet this is what he has written. ‘It has caused me the greatest trouble,’ Nietzsche said in The Gay Science, with a lesser flavouring of his complex irony than usual, ‘and still does always cause me the greatest trouble: to realise that what things are called is unspeakably more important than what they are.’ There’s a great truth in here, alas. The individual called ‘the man who makes America great again’ is unspeakably more important than the satsuma-coloured idiot-buffoon Ubu Roi who actually occupies the White House. History is what the winner call prior events, even though those prior events do not flatter or justify the winners. Performative statements such as the marriage service’s ‘I do’ and even the one-on-one’s ‘I love you’ name, but do not necessarily actualize, these realities. Bok knew he wanted the harmony and beauty, the enchantment and glory of Bach, but he cannot quite reconcile Bach with Book and ends-up truncated. Perhaps this is the real insight of this slight, spotty and yet strangely compelling book: that it dares to put into words not just that what we think we desire is not what we desire, but the more radical proposition: what we desire is not what we desire. The fantasy (as with ‘Fantasy’) is not what we crave, so much as we desire the catastrophic annihilation of what we have fantasized, which is to say, of fantasy itself.

I appreciate that this is a reading that depends upon finessing ‘Fantasy’ as a cultural mode (Narnia, Middle Earth, fairyland) with ‘fantasy’ as a psychological operant that numerates and denominates human desires more broadly. I don't expect you simply to accede to this: there are things we desire, and Fantasyland might be desirable to us, but these two qualia don't necessarily, of course, map precisely one upon the other. Nonetheless it seems to me ww miss the point of Fantasy as a genre if we pretend that it is not informed by prodigious psychological cathexis on behalf of the reader, or viewer, or fan of that Fantasy. And so far as that goes, it is worth noting that people don't Fans might claim that they love this or that Fantasy world because it aligns with their values, or desires: because it is suitably diverse in representational terms, or because it elaborates a satisfyingly complex and coherent worldbuilding and magic system, or simply (I would have said this, if you'd asked teenage me why I was so obsessed with Tolkien) because I really wanted to be there rather than here. Such responses are not being, although they are perhaps a touch unaware of the dynamic of desire itself. Hungarian poet and novelist Sándor Márai published Conversations in Bolzan in 1940 (it was not translated into English, by George Szirtes, until 2004). It's a novel in which Casanova confronts his own hyperbolic desires, under the rebuking logic of the Duke of Parma, who says:
You know very well that we do not love people for their virtues, indeed, there was a time when I believed that, in love, we prefer the oppressed, the problematic, the quarrelsome to the virtuous, but as I grew older I finally learned that it is neither people’s sins and faults nor their beauty, decency or virtue that makes us love them ... We simply have to accept the fact that we do not love people for their qualities; not because they are beautiful and, however strange it seems, not even because they are ugly, hunchbacked or poor; we love them simply because there is in the world a kind of purpose whose true working lies beyond our wit, which desires to articulate itself as much as an idea does.
And so here we are.      

Monday, 5 June 2023

Poul Anderson, ‘Three Hearts and Three Lions’ (1961)


Poul Anderson here reworks Mark Twain’s A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court (1889), although without the humour, and replacing Twain's satirical critique of the horrors of modern war with a reactionary valorisation of the heroic soldier and the Just War. Holger Carlsen a member of the Danish resistance fighting the German occupation of his country, tangles with strange Nazi technology in a battle at Elsinore (‘Hamlet’s home town’ the novel tells, in case we didn’t know) and finds himself transported to a parallel universe, a medievalised European realm. Carlsen must resume his combat on a more existentially prime level, as the forces of ‘Law’ battle the forces of ‘Chaos’—Anderson, who published the first short-story version of the novel in 1953, may claim precedence for establishing this as a concept of Fantasy, something Michael Moorcock, Sword and Sorcery more generally and especially ‘Dungeons & Dragons’ and other RPGs wholeheartedly took on.

Kitted-up as a chivalric knight, and accompanied by the dwarf Hugi and Alianora, a swan maiden, Holger goes on a series of peripatetic adventures and quests, aiming at once at victory in the fantasy war, to win the heart of the beautiful Alionara and to find a way home to ‘our’ world. The amalgam of tough-guy adventure narrative and medievalised cod-archaisms, especially of dialogue, makes for a sometimes tonally dissonant blend, and the latter in particular is not beyond mere ridiculousness:
“‘Tis Alianora, the swan-may.” Beer gurgled down the dwarf’s throat. “Hither and yon she flits throughout the wood and e’en into the Middle World sometimes, and the dwellers tell her their gossip. For she’s a dear friend to us. Aaaaah!” [29]
The storytelling logic here is pastiche: the novel is perfectly upfront about recycling the Matter of France, Arthurian romance, Norse mythology, witchcraft—in this realm, with indiscriminate panache, all these myths and legends are ‘real’, as are the character of Spenser’s Faerie Queene and Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream. Eventually Holger comes to understand the intertextual primacy of Twain's book as the original upon which his own adventures are merely a midrash, and is able, by ‘taking a crib’ from the book, ‘from literature—the Connecticut Yankee’ [150], to triumph. Whether the explicit embracing of this notion, of Fantasy as a palimpsest of jumbled-together prior Fantasy, remits the novel from the pitfalls of mere cliché is the question. We could say it’s playful, a game of spot-the-source (Mirkwood is mentioned, as are Wargs—though with madcap adulteration of the Tolkienian source: ‘“there in Mirkwood do the Pharisee lairds hunt griffin and manticore,” whispered Hugi’ [44]). Then again, we might say its plagiaristic, tired and tiresome. Hugi, meeting Holger for the first time (after expressing himself indistinctly in what Anderson perhaps believed was attractively flavoursome Scots dialect: “oh, Ay git aroon, Ay do, we-un bin a-drayvin’ a new shaft thisaboots”) announces: “Thar’s gold in them thar hills.” [25]. Is this funny? Lame? It's not just stylistic. The gender politics of the novel are clichéd in a more substantively malign manner:
Holger decided he had troubles enough without a hysterical female on his hands. He pulled her around, shook her, and said between his teeth, “I have nothing to do with this. Hear? Now will you come along like a grown human being, or must I drag you?” [75]
Alianora’s response? ‘She gulped, stared at him with wide wet eyes, and dropped her lashes. He noticed how long they were. “I'll come wi’ ye,” she said meekly.’ Those lashes are a major part of what perhaps we might call Alianora’s ‘characterisation’. They are what Holger first notices about her:
She approached shyly, fluttering long sooty lashes. Her only garment was a brief tunic, sleeveless and form-fitting, that seemed to be woven of white feathers; her bare feet were soundless in the grass. “Welcome,” she said, in her soft contralto. “Sir Knight, sith ye be a friend to my friend.” [30]
And so on, passim (“please,” purred Alianora. She waved her lashes at him’ [117]). The novel ends as she finally declares her feelings (“I love ye, Holger”), although this moment is swamped, rather, by the fact that this is the precise time Holger finally understands who he is—a version of what Moorcock would later call ‘The Eternal Champion’—and so rides off into the dawn, abandoning her:
Holger Danske, whom the old French chronicles know as Ogier le Danois, mounted into the saddle. And this was the prince of Denmark who in his cradle was given strength and luck and love by such of Faerie as wish men well. He it was who came to serve Carl the Great and rose to be among the finest of his knights, the defender of Christendie and mankind. He it was who smote Carahue of Mauretania in battle, and became his friend, and wandered far with him. He it was whom Morgan le Fay held dear; and when he grew old, she bore him to Avalon and gave him back his youth. There he dwelt until the paynim again menaced France, a hundred years later, and thence he sallied forth to conquer them anew. Then in the hour of his triumph he was carried away from mortal men. [178]
In an epilogue we learn that Holger is back in our world—sequels by Anderson and other writers detail his quest to return again to Alianora—and that he has converted to Catholicism. This final touch speaks, I suppose, to what Charles Taylor might call a ‘de-buffering’ of Holger’s sensibility: a return to the old religion and the enchanted world which it frames. I’m not convinced the novel, though it is lively, readable, full of incident—actually communicates this sense. There’s something pat, a strange combination of frantic and stale, about the texture. But that may just be my long, silky, waving lashes speaking.