Wednesday, 5 October 2022

Interview with Will Wiles


[Will Wiles is the London-based author of The Care of Wooden Floors (2012), The Way Inn (2014) and Plume (2019) and now, as ‘W. P. Wiles’, the first volume in a marvellous Fantasy series, The Last Blade Priest. I first got to know him after reading The Way Inn, his expertly written, coolly brilliant topographical fantasia set in the fictitious chain hotel of its title (‘Terence Conran meets HP Lovecraft, Bulgakov staged in the Tate, Kafka as a new Ikea furniture range’ is how the Guardian described the book). When I needed a chain hotel location for my novel The Thing Itself I asked Will’s permission to reuse the brand, and he kindly agreed. Plume, a barbed and vivid journey through contemporary London, and a superb consideration of addiction, writing and place, confirmed his status as a major contemporary writer.

I knew about his love for classic Fantasy, and was able to read The Last Blade Priest in draft, so I wasn’t as surprised as some commentators were by what might look, on the surface, like a change in writerly direction. In fact the things that animate Will’s other books are manifest in this tale too: his superb prose, his fertile, slyly wrongfooting imagination, his engagement and range and potency. There is a kind of architectural solidity to this work (Will also writes, expertly, about contemporary architecture), but his distinctive skill is in the twist he gives to the realities he shares with us. Last Blade Priest is, in short, a great Fantasy novel, and I can’t wait for the next volume in the series. Because I rate the novel so highly, and as I’m working on a critical history of Fantasy, I wanted to ask him a few questions: about the book, and about Fantasy more broadly. In sum: buy his book !— links are at the bottom of the post.]

+++

AR: Let’s start with Fantasy. I’m curious what your perspective on the mode is, and how you see Last Blade Priest fitting into that tradition. It’s not — it seems to me — a particularly trope-y novel, where Fantasy is concerned: you don’t simply deploy those Tolkien/Dungeons and Dragons fixtures and fittings, heroic men, noble elves, stalwart dwarfs, evil orcs, mysterious wizards. Your elves are rather alarming, for one thing. And you have the Scary Big Birds. And a giant mountain that is also an actual god. Did you set out to thwart the expectations of genre cliché when you wrote this novel?
 
 WW: I started writing The Last Blade Priest as a palate-cleansing kind of exercise, hoping to reinvigorate my writing in general by doing something that was purely for my amusement. I deliberately set out to do something which was very much in the fantasy tradition — an homage really. And one thing I was very certain that I didn’t want to do, this time anyway, was subvert anything — I didn’t want to do “a literary take on” fantasy, I didn’t want to play with irony or allegory, I didn’t want to timeslip or worldslip, and so on.

It annoys me when literary authors venture into SF&F and have to go through all these distancing rituals to explain that their stuff isn’t like that other stuff — which often has more to do with marketing and the way space is organised in bookshops than “snobbery”, although snobbery often does play a part. I wanted something that was “pure” fantasy, and shelved that way. I love novels that genre-bend and play games with readers’ boundary expectations — I’ve written at least one [2014’s The Way Inn] — but that was not what I wanted to do here.

However I did want to avoid cliches and anything that’s tired, so I did have a list of things I wasn’t going to do: no dragons. None of the “traditional” fantasy “races” — chiefly Elves, Dwarves, Orcs. (My Elves are Elves in name only). No “chosen one”*, no prophecies**, no secret/unsuspecting royal birth. I would try to find a “middle way” with my magic: it would have serious limitations and rules and not be soft do-anything magic, but it wouldn’t have pedantic, Advanced Dungeons & Dragons roleplaying type rules with entirely predictable inputs and outputs. Do-anything magic can be a narrative problem in all sorts of ways, and nerdy rules-based “hard” magic can be interesting but I feel on an emotional level that magic should be wild and paradoxical and mysterious and have unintended consequences.

[* Arguably Anton breaks this rule but he’s not the messiah, just someone who’s passed vetting.]

[** Arguably I break this rule as well in a very small way but the important thing is there aren’t widely known & believed, legendary prophecies in the world and the magic users do not have the gift of foresight. (Sometimes insight.) It’s not that I dislike prophecy as a form of magic — on the contrary, I wrote my undergraduate dissertation on prophecy in the middle ages! — but I find it’s over-used as a way of adding because-I-said-so authority to a plot. That’s what I didn’t want to do]

For my races, besides the Elves, I tried to think of “fantasy” creatures that weren’t much used. Knomes are abominable snowmen, but of course you can’t call them that without making people smile, so I didn’t. (They were called yetis, or a similar word identifiable as yeti, in the earliest sketches, but that had the same issue.) Bindlings started as mummies but have evolved. I am worried I am sandblasting away layers of mystique here and leaving behind Abbott & Costello so maybe I should stop. And of course there’s the Custodians: obviously I like it when their originality is praised but honestly I’m not sure how original they are. They came out of a simple worldbuilding question — what creatures would get to a magic mountain first? — and I also owe a fairly obvious debt to Dark Crystal.

As for “heroic men” — I think flawed heroes, reluctant heroes and antiheroes, and unlikeable dudes just trying to get on in the world, and deliberately hero-less narratives, are almost as tired as “pure” heroes now. Heroism is an incredibly difficult concept to approach originally. The best recent take has been Abercrombie’s in the First Law books, where he has a pretty useless schmuck manipulated by a scheming wizard into looking like Aragorn in the eyes of the world, but only for said wizard’s own ends. Anton has noble qualities that are consistent with “heroism”, and is moreover increasingly aware that he has to be a hero. But a hero is ultimate a man or woman of action, and that’s what he finds difficult.

I digress, sorry. I think calling my antagonists “Elves”, and then settin g up the book so you think “pointy eared immortal snobs” and only see what they really are quite late on, was the only real bit of intentional thwarting of expectations I did. (There was one other way, I suppose: I wanted to start at the end, or rather start in the world’s most important and secret and well-defended location and then work outwards. A more “typical” fantasy narrative would have the Brink and the Mountain — as it might be, Mount Doom, or the Eye of the World — as the destination and narrative climax — which I do, but I also have another narrative that heads out from there. This is not hugely original but it was a governing part of my thinking.) In general my intentions towards the median fantasy reader were less confrontational, I wanted to interest and amuse and avoid the obvious.

In terms of what I wanted to do, the way that I wanted my book (and, I hope, its sequels, if I’m allowed to write them) to fit in with the broader tradition of fantasy: I didn’t really think in terms of a shopping list of tropes, but rather in terms of atmosphere, and how a book makes you feel. Atmosphere and feeling were what I took from my formative reading in the genre, and those are the qualities I wanted to think about in particular and to develop in the prose.

AR: What Fantasy did you read, growing up (and by ‘read’ I mean: read, watch, play). Do you still read Fantasy?

WW: Very mainstream, I think, and typical for a SFF-loving boy of the 1980s. Tolkien at the foundation: My mother read The Hobbit to me and my sister when we were very young indeed. She later loaned me her copies of Lord of the Rings and I read those. In between those I read all of the Narnia books and the Earthsea books. (As an aside, I think it was the seven Narnia books that gave me a taste for the rewards of “the epic” in the conventional blurby sense — the sense of achievement at getting through to The Last Battle.) My father recommended Peake’s Gormenghast novels and I loved the first two of those, hated the third. I read Pratchett and Fighting Fantasy choose-your-own adventures. Richard Adams was also very important: I read Watership Down and Plague Dogs, but also Shardik (my father had a copy), which was strange and thrilling and had a real sense of contact with an unfamiliar world. So my parents did valuable work! I also read William Horwood’s Watership Downalike (Watershipshape?) Duncton Wood books, which I remember enjoying to a surprising degree. I keep thinking of rereading them, but I fear I won’t enjoy them to any degree on a reread, and their memory will be sullied.

After Tolkien I pursued similar books, and I read a few of Brooks’s Shannara novels, a couple of Donaldson’s Illearth books, the first two or three Wheel of Time novels, but at this point I was getting diminishing returns. Brooks was readable but obviously derivative. Donaldson was more original but I found the books repulsive. I gave up on Wheel of Time very quickly because I felt it was just another Brooks-like retread, obviously it became much more its own thing as it went along. This rather put me off fantasy from the age of about eighteen (1996) for about a decade, alongside an entirely mistaken and dumb notion that I should put aside childish things. (Although I kept reading SF — probably revealing some prejudices there, although I have since shed them.) I did read, and greatly enjoyed, Gene Wolfe’s Book of the New Sun in that late teen period of disillusion though. I should also mention HP Lovecraft who I’ve been reading since I was ten or eleven, and who led me to Ashton-Smith, Dunsany, etc etc and their weird fantasy, which is directly referenced in the geography of The Last Blade Priest. The Gothic and “weird” have been huge influences on me but I will go on forever if I get into that. Er, what else? Helliconia, Once and Future King — I can’t list everything but these are things that steered me one way or another.

Beyond books, trying to be as brief as possible: I adored comics and read 2000 AD for years, which had some excellent fantasy, notably Pat Mills’s Sláine and Nemesis the Warlock. I played some Dungeons and Dragons but preferred Warhammer Fantasy Battle, and WH40K, and I read White Dwarf. I think the art in White Dwarf affected me very deeply: Ian Miller, John Blanche, Gary Chalk. Simon Bisley and Mike McMahon’s art for Sláine as well, and Kevin O’Neill art for Nemesis. Art is very important. It’s amazing how a single book cover can lodge in the mind and shape fantasy worlds. I won’t recap all film & TV but I do think some of the stranger, darker cartoons we got to enjoy in the 80s helped a lot: Ulysses 31, Cities of Gold. And in films: we’ve talked about Dark Crystal, also Labyrinth, Laputa, Time Bandits …

AR: I ask this next question with a particular sense of Last Blade Priest in mind. It’s this: what is the proper balance, would you say, in a Fantasy novel between worldbuilding and storytelling/character/everything else? By worldbuilding I suppose I mean not just the geographical and social lineaments of the imagined realm, but coherent (or otherwise) magical systems, or religious systems? You’ve already partly answered this with respect to magic but I wonder about the larger question.

WW: I suppose the simple, true and useless answer is “I don’t know” — I don’t know what the perfect balance is, or even if there is a perfect balance. I certainly doubt there is a single perfect balance, as it must depend on the tastes of the reader as much as anything, and some have a higher tolerance for worldbuilding than others. There are some readers for whom it’s all about the worldbuilding, and they can’t have too much. I think the increasing emphasis on worldbuilding in the discussion around Fantasy is an interesting phenomenon, and possibly stems from this being an age driven by content creation, since world-building provides excellent material for secondary content … here’s everything are told about X (land/religion/magic system/whatever) … here’s what we don’t know, but can infer or speculate about; here’s why X is good … here are the shortcomings of X. Effective worldbuilding would of course seamlessly tie-into story-telling and character and so on, so they aren’t in competition for space on the page and unfold together. That’s the trick, I suppose, not finding a balance but finding a synthesis.

A very similar question applies within worldbuilding itself, the iceberg question. How much of “worldbuilding” should go on the page, and how much should be left in the author’s head? Naturally the author knows more than the reader and there’s always a portion of the iceberg that’s hidden away, that never makes it onto the page. But the proportion of hidden/revealed varies. Leave too much hidden, and the reader may struggle to follow what is happening to an unpleasant degree (a little struggling is pleasant exercise, but too much ….). Spew too much onto the page and you end up with pages-long digressions into history or magical technique or whatever, and that can also be a struggle. It’s my belief that the reader wants to feel that there is a lot of iceberg under the surface, out of sight, and that this was what gave Lord of the Rings such power, that immense treasury of imagined myth that meant the characters on the page could realistically make historical allusions or references and so on. It certainly felt that way to me, anyway. You want to feel that the history is there.

However I don’t mean that every fantasy novel needs a Silmarillion sitting behind it. It just needs to feel that way. Effective worldbuilding works largely in allusion, I think. The author might, in fact, be only a couple of steps ahead of the reader, and not know anything about the allusions they are making — Many Shuvs and Zuuls knew what it was to be roasted in the depths of the Slor that day, I can tell you! — but as long as it has the right ring to it, it works, it intrigues and enchants and gives a sense of a rich living backdrop. And writers should be helped here by remembering that people (real people, and also characters in books) don’t have accurate pictures of their own history or literature.

I’ve talked about my feelings re magic already, but the role of religion is an important one as well. In a lot of fantasy religion is oddly muted, amounting to characters’ choice of mascot, or it doesn’t feature at all, supplanted entirely by myth and magic. What religion are the Hobbits, for instance?

AR: Preshobbiterian?

WW: Certainly not. And you can see why it gets muted, as religions are very complicated things to render in an effective way. They have a particular body of history, myth and literature of their own. They have power structures and social structures, sometimes more than one, in competition. They shape and direct the thinking and behaviour of their followers — sometimes in straightforward ways like dietary restrictions, but also in hugely subtle and important ways, like the way the concept of forgiveness sits at the heart of Christianity. That’s a lot of world to be built, and it’s the subtle philosophical influence of religion, the mindset, the way it guides characters’ choices and internal dilemmas, that is the hardest to create and to render realistically, in a way that’s still engaging to the reader. You can’t always gloss and contextualise a character’s feelings in cases where they’re very different to our own — “rather than anger he felt shame because of this or that aspect of what his upbringing said about this situation”. It can be done, of course, and some of the greatest fantasy does it very well, which contributes to its greatness, but it’s difficult. No wonder most authors don’t really get into it, and stick to “we worship the mouse god, that’s why I have a mouse on my clothes and we don’t eat cheese on Tuesdays” or whatever. Or religion is made entirely literal, and you know what the mouse god wants because she came down here and told you (cheese, I expect). This is really something I wanted to dig into in my own fantasy — the mindsets and philosophies,I mean, not the mouse god.

AR: But the Mouse God is Apollo — also god of poetry, and our — yours and mine — patron saint!

WW: To be honest I only said mouse because we have one as an unwanted tenant and they’ve been on my mind. We’ve been leaving him offerings in temples of doom.

AA: The next question is lengthy, though your answer may be as brief, or nonexistent, as you like. But I want to lay out one of the theses I’m interested in developing in my History of Fantasy, and I’m curious what you think of the argument it makes generally, and how you think it relates to a novel like Last Blade Priest specifically. It’s not my thesis, in fact: I’m nicking it from my friend Alan Jacobs, who published an essay a few years back called ‘Fantasy and the Buffered Self’ [The New Atlantis 41 (2014), 3–18]. Jacobs takes the idea of the ‘buffered self’ from Canadian philosopher Charles Taylor, who says this:

Almost everyone can agree that one of the big differences between us and our ancestors of five hundred years ago is that they lived in an “enchanted” world, and we do not; at the very least, we live in a much less “enchanted” world. We might think of this as our having “lost” a number of beliefs and the practices which they made possible. But more, the enchanted world was one in which these forces could cross a porous boundary and shape our lives, psychic and physical. One of the big differences between us and them is that we live with a much firmer sense of the boundary between self and other. We are “buffered” selves. We have changed.

Here is Jacobs’ gloss on the idea:

To put that shift in simple terms, a person accepts a buffered condition as a means of being protected from the demonic or otherwise ominous forces that in pre-modern times generated a quavering network of terrors. To be a pre-modern person, in Taylor’s account, is to be constantly in danger of being invaded or overcome by demons or fairies or nameless terrors of the dark — of being possessed and transformed, or spirited away and never returned to home and family. Keith Thomas’s magisterial Religion and the Decline of Magic (1971) specifies many of these dangers, along with the whole panoply of prayers, rites, amulets, potions, chants, spells, and the like, by which a person might seek protection from the otherwise irresistible. It is easy, then, to imagine why a person — or a whole culture — might, if it could, exchange this model of a self with highly permeable boundaries for one in which the self feels better protected, defended — impermeable, or nearly so.

The problem with this apparently straightforward transaction, Jacobs notes, is that the porous self is open to the divine as well as to the demonic, while the buffered self is closed to both alike.

Those who must guard against capture by fairies are necessarily and by the same token receptive to mystical experiences. The “showings” manifested to Julian of Norwich depend upon exceptional sensitivity, which is to say porosity — vulnerability to incursions of the supernatural. The portals of the self cannot be closed on one side only. But the achievement of a safely buffered personhood — closed off from both the divine and the demonic — is soon enough accompanied by a deeply felt change in the very cosmos. As C. S. Lewis notes in The Discarded Image (1964), the medieval person who found himself “looking up at a world lighted, warmed, and resonant with music” gives way to the modern person who perceives only emptiness and silence. Safety is purchased at the high price of isolation, as we see as early as Pascal, who famously wrote of the night sky, “Le silence éternel de ces espaces infinis m’effraie” (“The eternal silence of these infinite spaces frightens me”).

I quote this at length because it seems to me so interesting. Anyway, to the point: Jacobs’ thesis is that a kind of yearning back towards porosity and its attendant enchantments is behind the great contemporary vogue for Fantasy:

Might it not be possible to experience the benefits, while avoiding the costs, of both the porous and the buffered self? I want to argue here that it is precisely this desire that accounts for the rise to cultural prominence, in late modernity, of the artistic genre of fantasy. Fantasy — in books, films, television shows, and indeed in all imaginable media — is an instrument by which the late modern self strives to avail itself of the unpredictable excitements of the porous self while retaining its protective buffers. Fantasy, in most of its recent forms, may best be understood as a technologically enabled, and therefore safe, simulacrum of the pre-modern porous self.

Do you think this is right? Does it have any point of connection with what you, as a writer of Fantasy, are doing?

WW: Yes, this all sounds very plausible. Though I think there is perhaps more porosity in the modern “buffered self” than we might at first believe, and we do have our own demons and rituals and amulets and so on — and possibly this tendency is increasing as modernist certainties fracture into a hall of mirrors. I am reminded of Carl Sagan’s much-circulated quote about “clutching our crystals, heading into a new Dark Age”, where information isn’t lost or suppressed, but is overwhelmed by the signal-to-noise ratio and the decline of commonly agreed authorities. There are quack cures and pseudoscientific charms — magnets, crystals, copper bands etc to ward off 5G rays — but you can also see ritualistic behaviour around public health measures of proven merit, like mask wearing. If we’re not getting a good signal on our phone, we raise it in the air, even when it makes little sense to do so. Send us your bars, oh lord …

There are those who have fallen prey to disinformation and conspiracy theories and who believe that satanic child-trafficking cults rule over us; but there’s also a counter-tendency to that which sees disinformation and the hand of the enemy everywhere, like puritans seeing the devil’s work, and has developed into a rigid and brittle kind of “rationalism” that I think of as junk scepticism. But I suppose a key difference is that many of these tendencies fester in our little media cocoons rather than through direct personal contact with people in the agora, which we should be doing more of. We might have a slightly better rational apparatus than the pre-modern villager, but to our disadvantage we spend a lot more time on our own in the dark, staring into the fire, seeing visions of Hell. There’s also medicalisation: birth and death mostly take place in the hospital, not at home, and have little in the way of ritual accompaniment. We’ve just seen a vast and fascinating ritual exercise unfolding in this country, following the death of the Queen, with attendant effusions of popular enthusiasm and ritual behaviour — notably The Queue, a pure pilgrimage, undertaken by many not in spite of how arduous it was, but because it was arduous, and a physical expression of depth of feeling. These things evidently matter.

In terms of whether these things connect to my work: they absolutely do. I studied history at university, specialising in medieval history — a choice which was probably partially influenced by my fondness for fantasy. And various works of history, ones that do a particularly excellent job of getting within the often alien-seeming minds of people in that long, varied era, have become touchstones for me — including Keith Thomas. I would also mention The Stripping of the Altars by Eamon Duffy, about iconoclasm and Protestantism and state versus popular religion; Carlo Ginzburg’s The Cheese and the Worms, about a Friulian miller who came to the attention of the religious authorities in the 17th century for, more or less, coming up with his own religion, or cosmology, based on rather eccentric reading — an absolutely exquisite book; and Peter Burke’s work, in particular Popular Culture in Early Modern Europe. And I think it’s significant that when I started writing TLBP, I was reading John Julius Norwich’s three-volume history of the Byzantine Empire, although that wasn’t something I read at university. (Runciman’s history of the crusades was.)

But there were two books that I would say have mattered above any others. First is Johan Huizinga’s classic The Waning of the Middle Ages (1919), which does a remarkable job of conjuring the people of the middle ages, and their lives and beliefs and sensory universe, into being for the reader. “Luminous” is an overused word when it comes to describing books, but it applies here. He seizes the reader in the famous opening paragraphs, and does not let go — it’s an opening that connects very strongly to what you outline above:

“To the world when it was half a thousand years younger, the outline of all things seemed more clearly marked than to us. The contrast between suffering and joy, between adversity and happiness, appeared more striking. All experience had yet to the minds of men the directness and absoluteness of the pleasure and pain of child-life. Every event, every action, was still embodied in expressive and solemn forms, which raised them to the dignity of a ritual. For it was not merely the great facts of birth, marriage and death which, by the sacredness of the sacrament, were raised to the rank of mysteries; incidents of less importance, like a journey, a task, a visit, were equally attended by a thousand formalities: benedictions, ceremonies, formulas.

Calamities and indigence were more afflicting than at present; it was more difficult to guard against them, and to find solace. Illness and health presented a more striking contrast; the cold and darkness of winter were more real evils. Honours and riches were relished with greater avidity and contrasted more vividly with surrounding misery. We, at the present day, can hardly understand the keenness with which a fur coat, a good fire on the hearth, a soft bed, a glass of wine, were formerly enjoyed.”

I could happily quote on. Huizinga cemented my affection for the study of the Middle Ages by making it feel like a quest into this fascinating, sensually rich, lost world, and of course that has a bearing on what I like to get out of fantasy as a reader and a writer.

The second important book was Norman Cohn’s The Pursuit of the Millennium, about millenarianism, apocalyptic cults, and waves of religious mania, which more or less lies at the foundation of The Last Blade Priest and (if I am allowed to write them) its sequels. These religious manias — flagellants, pogroms, sudden revolts, roving peasant-armies — are superficially baffling to us. People would throw away their lives for them. And it takes a great deal of scene-setting and explaining and social and cultural history to understand them, which is what Cohn provides. He calls the fever dreams that drove these manias “phantasies”, which is apt. A particular recurring feature of many of these movements supplied The Last Blade Priest with a crucial aspect of its plot, although I can’t say what because it will spoil it.

The common thread through all this is religion, rather than kings or queens or knights and horses. Which is why I wanted religion to be at the heart of my own fantasy — and ultimately why I want to try and create this same sense of religious mania, cults, crusades and so on, through the series. A world that is in an advanced state of decline, but that rottenness is causing dozens of weird flowers of possibility to bloom. This seemed like territory in which something original could be done, and informed all the choices I made.

+++

Buy The Last Blade Priest from: [UK] Angry Robot; Waterstones; Amazon; Kobo; Black Dragon; signed-copies from Broken Binding. [US] Penguin; Amazon

Tuesday, 6 September 2022

from “The Uxbridge Guide To Middle Earth”


 
Aulë. Like an owl.

Balrog. He’s having a ball. He’s a bit of a rogue.

Bree. Where the cheese comes from.

Dwarf (plural: dwarfves). In popular usage, when we say something “dwarfs” something else we mean it makes the something else seem small. This is because dwarfs are really, really big.

Ent. A tree with ears, nose and a throat.

Gil-galad. An elf born in the First Age. Known as ‘Old Gil’.

Lothlórien. This is French; it means ‘never Lothló’.

Manwë. Masculine urine.

Morgoth. Likes Sisters of Mercy to a greater degree than you.

Númenor. Or what? No really. What’s the alternative?

Saruman. The man with the Saru. If you ask me to defnine Saru, I can only tell you that it's a very difficult word, very difficult indeed. Truly, Saru seems to be the hardest word.

Silmarillion. A famous prog-rock band took their name from this. You remember: The Sils.

Tom Bombadil. Hey dol! merry dol! ring a dong ditty!
Ring a dong! hop along! flatten the city!
Tom Bomb, jolly Tom, Atom Bombadillo!

Old ’tom Bombadil over-water bringing
Enola Gay is bearing him and OMD are singing
Hey! Come merry dol! derry dol! and dream-o,
Brighter than a thousand suns above old Hiroshim-o!
Poor old mortal-man, tuck your roots away now!
Bomb's in a hurry now. Night must follow day now!

Saturday, 3 September 2022

Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (2022)

 


Two episodes in, a review is surely premature. Maybe, to adapt the immortal words of Will Self, it will turn into Tolstoy at the 121 minute mark. But so far, my reaction has not been one of entirely unalloyed positivity.


Some people I know, people who themselves know and love Tolkien, and whose opinion I respect, are loving it; so perhaps my reaction is the one out of whack. But then again, a lot of people are dunking on this billion dollar—let me just say that again, this billion dollar—project. For a billion dollars you might think you could expect a lot. Is a lot what we get?

Not so far. One kind of consensus is emerging, I think, from the fan-reactions: astonishing visuals, excruciating dialogue. There's something in this, although the visuals, which are often absolutely dripping with lovingly and intricately designed Middle-Earthitude, are perhaps not as stunning as some people are saying (I'll come back to this). But certainly the dialogue is bad, on a par with the herky-derky storytelling and the ludicrous shifts and turns of the plot. 

One problem is that the elves get the lion's share of the screen-time, and they're dull, dull, they're a-elbereth-gilthoni-dull. This need not be the case: in the Silmarillion the elves are a rather more lively, dramatically-speaking, prone to the kinds of failings Tolkien considered compatible with their dignity and elevation (pride, arrogance, hauteur, impetuousness etc). But in Rings of Power there's not even that. Instead there is a lot of pompous, humourless posing about, lots of mouthing the given dialogue slowly ensuring each syllable gets its ponderous weight, lots of standing still in golden clothes with arms at their sides, looking off into the middle-distance. The exception is Morfydd Clark's Galadriel, who gets to run and fight and leap about and so on, and is provided with a clunky but vivifying piece of motivational backstory (her brother was killed by orcs). This leads to her hunting orcs up and down Middle Earth. But it seems that all the orcs are gone, and she has to content herself with battling a lumbering CGI Snow-Troll, encountered in the CGIce of the frozen northern wastes. A few video-game leaps and swordstrikes and there's no troll left. (Get it? -s no troll left! Yeah? Yeah?)

(Yeah?)

Anyway, in fact, and as ep 2 makes plain, the orcs are not gone, but have instead taken Paul Weller's advice concerning going underground. It's, we might say, surprising that nobody has noticed this subterranean ruse, especially the dwarfs who are surely experts in that whole Middle Earth basement thing. But nobody has. So we wait future episodes in which, I presume, the orcs will swarm back above ground and make things orc-ward, sorry, awkward for the regular Midland-Earthers.

All the orcs being gone, or so everyone believes, Galadriel is rewarded by the elven king with permission to return to Valinor, the undying lands. This, by the way very much isn't canon: the Silmarillion tells us a ban was placed on Galadriel returning to the undying lands by Manwë, a kind of god, on account of her joining the revolt of the Noldor in the First Age. She's just a Gal who can't say No(ldor). But the show's not interested in any of that. In TV-land access to Valinor is in the gift of the king, somehow.

So off Gal goes, an ocean voyage across a body of water that looks, on the map helpfully panned-over on screen, about as wide as the Atlantic. There are various shots of Galadriel and some other elves standing on the deck of their bijoux little sailing ship, gold clothes, arms at their sides, staring straight ahead with actorly intensity. When they get to the Undying Lands a big SF-nal portal opens up in the sky and then, at that stage and not before Galadriel has second thoughts and jumps overboard before the ship is magicked away forever. Her plan? To swim back across the Atlantic I guess, which doesn't seem to me entirely thought-through. She does a servicable front-crawl for a little while, but then luckily encounters a raft of the medusa, or equivalent.

Meanwhile, Amazon not having acquired the rights to represent hobbits on screen, despite paying $250 million for said rights, the show opts instead for arche-hobbits, a kind of ur-hobbit species called Harfoots. There's some lumbering rural comedy with these scatty, unwashed little fellers, gabbling on in their stage Irish. Then there's an overlong interlude during which Elrond visits Durin IV and his wife Disa (Owain Arthur and Sophia Nomvete) in Khazâd-dûm, which gives the show the excuse to try for a little levity, and some sub I Love Lucy-style domestic-squabble-comedy, wincing and unfunny but at least a change of tone (“I Love Lúthi”). And one undeniable positive emerges from the whole sequence: Durin's enormous red beard, which is tremendous. Really, I can't state too emphatically how great his huge red beard is. It deserves a spin-off show of its own. It brought to my mind the celebrated William Khazâd Williams poem:
so much depends
upon

the red beard
dwarrow

praised for fine
metalwork

beside the white
diggings


Meanwhile Downton Abbey/The Crown stalwart Charles Edwards stretches himself by playing a posh elf. This is Celebrimbor, the smith who is going to forge the actual rings of power:  


One other important development: a gigantic fireball crashes down into Harfootland (Hartfootshire, Hertfordshire, whatever). Boom! In the midst of the crater is a young-ish beardy man (Daniel Weyman, billed in the credits only as ‘the stranger who falls from the sky in a flaming meteor’). At first he is confused and seemingly language-less, although he possesses nascent magical powers. Some friendly Harfoots, Harfeet, whatever, take pity on him. Presumably his identity will be revealed in a later episode with a plot-twisty flourish, but also (presumably) he's young Gandalf, send by the Maiar to aid Middle Earth. His kindly treatment by the Harfoots is I suppose inserted to explain why old Gandalf in Lord of the Rings has such a soft-spot for hobbits. Of course there's nothing about a flaming meteor man in the Silmarillion, and this whole sequence has a much more War of the Worlds than Tolkien vibe to it, really. Perhaps it's not Gandalf, sent by the Maiar, at all. Perhaps it's Tom Bombadil (that would be a truly catastrophic reveal, for a hundred reasons, but I wouldn't put it past the script-writers). Can it really be Gandalf, arriving à la War of the Worlds? After all, the chances of anything coming from Maiars/Is a million to one/He said.

That's enough facetiousness. What about the show's strengths? A billion dollars is a lot of money, and you can certainly see the cash splashed on screen: huge sets, elaborate costumes, casts of thousands and top-tier CGI. This has been very elaborately rendered, and will give trufans the chance to freeze-frame and pore over all the little details with squeals of delight; but as elements in a screen drama I thought the landscapes and cityscapes over-detailed, visually clogged, in some cases positively horror vacui. Over-egged, too rich.  There's a reason why the show lifts when Galadriel, having opted for her insane swim-across-the-Atlantic last-minute change of mind, ends up on the raft with those others: the screen is simplified, water, sky, a few actors and every now and again a giant CGI sea-serpent. When it pares the scene down, the show becomes considerably more interesting to watch. Maybe things will improve with later episodes.  

---

Update. I watched the whole series. Things did not improve with the later episodes.

Friday, 2 September 2022

Peter Nicholls, “Genre Fiction: The Roaring Years” (2022)


This is very good: a collection of reviews and essays by the late Peter Nicholls, of SF Encyclopedia editing fame—he edited and co-wrote the first edition of the encyclopedia with John Clute, and the later editions with Clute and David Langford, whose ‘ansible editions’ are the publisher of this collection. Nicholls was also the editor of Foundation in the 1970s, and one of the first people to establish an academic base in Britain for the study of SF, out of the North-East London Polytechnic (now the University of East London). Several of the pieces assembled here are autobiographical and Nicholls, sad to say, really doesn't have happy memories of this decade. He also, several times, expresses his low opinion of academic SF criticism as a discipline: for him, the fannish is fitter. Eventually Nicholls returned to his native Australia where, his encroaching Parkinsonianism notwithstanding, he seems to have been much happier. He died in 2018.

I never knew Nicholls, although I know many of the people he mentions in his various memoir-essays—Clute, Langford, and others. Still: not being part of the UK SF ‘scene’ in the 70s and 80s, I read Nicholl’s energetic accounts of the fun-times he had at various cons with a sense of melancholy, actually. People partying-hearty in the dead depths of the last century, in-jokes and namechecks and strenuous assertions of how much fun it was. Reading accounts of a party to which one was not invited, and where many of the people partying are now dead, can’t help but evoke the vibe described in Browning’s ‘A Toccata of Galuppi's’:
Did young people take their pleasure when the sea was warm in May?
Balls and masks begun at midnight, burning ever to mid-day,
When they made up fresh adventures for the morrow, do you say?

…

“As for Venice and her people, merely born to bloom and drop,
“Here on earth they bore their fruitage, mirth and folly were the crop:
“What of soul was left, I wonder, when the kissing had to stop?

“Dust and ashes!” So you creak it, and I want the heart to scold.
Dear dead women, with such hair, too—what's become of all the gold
Used to hang and brush their bosoms? I feel chilly and grown old.
Nicholl's con reports, and particularly his overlong and self-indulgent ‘The Great Seacon Freakout Seacon ’75, the 1975 UK Eastercon’, certainly left me feeling chilly and grown very old, and I wasn't even there. Parties can’t be memorialised in a way that captures their in-the-moment vibrancy and point, I think.

But most of the collection is not this, I'm glad to report: much more of it is reviews and essays from the 1970s through to the early 2000s, and these are very good indeed. Memorialising old books is a much more worthwhile business than memorialising old parties, and Nicholls is insightful in his judgments and often witty in his prose.
Both Tau Zero and Ringworld derive their intellectual force from grand scientific concepts, concepts of such massive scale that they both deserve their reputation as landmarks (spacemarks) in the history of hard science fiction—that surprisingly small but important branch of the genre in which the science is central and not simply decorative.

But there are two important differences. First, Tau Zero is based on a known scientific principle that has been in the public domain for 68 years, while Ringworld is based on a grandiose piece of engineering whimsy that has a vanishingly small chance of ever finding fruition in the real universe. Secondly, Tau Zero takes its initial conception and develops it with a satisfying logic; Ringworld takes its initial conception and treats it rather like the man who spends £300 on a Hi-Fi Stereo, and shows it off by playing stereophonic records of a ping-pong match.
He develops a number of interesting and resonant critical positions—‘the writers of hard sf are as a group probably more, not less, Romantic than their soft sf colleagues’ for instance—and is especially good on the crossovers between SF and theology, and the sublime. On this latter he is surely right with what he calls ‘a point that’s not often made: one thing about the sublime is that it is dehumanizing. It makes us feel small and unimportant and indeed hardly there at all. I think this feeling, of our vulnerability and littleness in the context of cosmic vastness and indifference, is one of the root feelings of space fiction, a sort of default feeling that almost all space fiction at some point approaches. When you hit science fiction’s “enter” key, that’s where the cursor goes.’ I don’t know if dehumanizing is quite le mot juste where the Sublime is concerned, but Nicholls is absolutely right about its centrality to space fiction, and actually to SF more generally, and how much of that depends upon the existential implications of scale as such.

You see Nicholls developing and improving as a critic as you read through. His earlier pieces are flatter, sometimes concerned with irrelevancies such as his personal rankings of writers (his 1973 review of The Farthest Shore includes this who-cares account of children’s literature: ‘I would put Ursula Le Guin in the first rank, along with Alan Garner, and perhaps T.H. White from an earlier generation. They are closely followed by William Mayne, Phillipa Pearce, John Gordon and J.R.R. Tolkien.’) But as he goes on, his pieces becomes sharper: more insightful and thought-provoking and also funnier. There’s a brilliant 1990 review/essay on Ian Watson, the great if now catastrophically underappreciated British writer—one day I hope to write a short monograph on Watson’s writing—and an excellent paean to Gene Wolfe (‘he is the metaphysical poet of science fiction; he has a great deal more in common with Donne or Marvell or Crashaw than he does with Heinlein. I’m being quite serious, while fully conscious of rendering myself liable to incarceration in Pseud’s Corner.’) He’s also nicely pointed about his friend and co-editor Clute:
Another celebrated critic represented [in this collection] is John Clute who, when in obscurantist mode, as he is in this analysis of the Hyperion novels of Dan Simmons, is magisterially opaque: “When history cannot be perceived with any clarity, the consequent absence of a firm past haunts as Hyde haunts Jekyll through doppelgänger erosions of public masks.” Well, yes. Or no. I think.
Clute supplies the introduction to this volume, proceeds from which will go towards maintaining the SF Encyclopedia, currently in its 4th edition. It’s a worthwhile cause and the book is very much worth its purchase price. I might add that I read the ebook version, which contains various typos and slips, presumably from where the text has been scanned to make the file (James Blish becomes ‘Jina Blish’ at one point [update: this has now been corrected]). But that’s a small nitpick. Overall this is an often brilliant and always entertaining collection.

Monday, 29 August 2022

Arthur C Clarke Award 2022: Shortlist Roundup

 


The shortlist for the 2022 Arthur C Clarke Award has been revealed. The winner will be announced on the 26th October at a gala Science Museum event in Kensington. Back in the day (remember the day? Ah, what gay old quotidian times we had!) I used to do a round-up review of the Clarke Award shortlist. But it’s been a long time since anyone has commissioned such a piece from me, for I’m sure highly valid reasons, and this post is less a proper review of the shortlist and more a set of links to other places, mostly blogposts, where I happen to have reviewed the individual titles.

Harry Josephine Giles, A Deep Wheel Called Orcadia

Kazuo Ishiguro, A Klara Called Sun

Arkady Martine, A Desolation Called Peace

Courttia Newland A River Called Time

Mercurio D Rivera, Wergen: an Alien Called Love War

Aliya Whiteley, An Inn Called Skyward.

As you'll see, if you have the patience to click-through those links, and going from worst to best: I thought the Newland, for all its energy and engagement, sloppily made and often bizarrely, even badly, written (re-reading it now, that review is rather more forgiving than might be the case if I wrote it today).  Ishiguro's Klara and the Sun is hard to judge: in one sense, it's classic Ishiguro touching on his perennial themes and as carefully rendered as anything he has done; in another sense it's just really quite bad, incoherent, patchy, miss-more-than-hit, cheesy, askew. Riviera's Wergen is an OK, middle-of-the-space-road fix-up about aliens and humans interacting, neither a very bad nor especially a good book. Martine's Desolation Called Peace is again OK, though a step-down from the previous volume in her series. Giles's Deep Wheel Orcadia is rather better, a poem written in synthetic Scots (I don't say ‘synthetic’ dismissively) with a Joycean ‘English’ translation running underneath, about a space station. The verse achieves some nice effects, though not in an altogether sustained way, and the story itself is a touch pat. But it's good. Still, far and away the best title on this list is Whiteley's powerful, unsettling and penetrating Skyward Inn, a very remarkable piece of writing.

It’s not, overall, a very strong shortlist, especially set against the wealth of books published last year—only one of these titles (the Whiteley) really deserves to be here, I think. But part of the function of a list like this is to provoke discussion and debate, to get people reading SF widely and talking about it and all that. We might argue that a contentious shortlist is more provoking and therefore better at this task than an actual list of the six best SF novels published in a given year. In which case: hats off to the judges. This is a contentious list, contending against value, assessment and in some cases common sense. It manifests a narrow set of repeating fascinations—fully half these titles are about blandly complacent creatures (aliens, robots) under the careless or cruel treatment of humanity. Most construe the relationship between their story-location, a peripheral or parochial space, and some imperial or quasi-imperial ‘centre’. I’m not suggesting these things aren’t important, but there are other things SF can be about, and the narrowness of thematic focus in this list feels a bit pinching, a reflection of the judges' personal crotchets rather than a reflection of where genre is more broadly, at the moment.

Of course, me saying so may merely reflect my own personal crotchets. We all have them. I didn’t find much to love in last year’s Clarke Shortlist, I’ll be honest (are any of those books still a lively part of today's genre conversations? Were they really the best books published in 2020?):—and this year I was surprised at the number of big hitters (Monica Byrne’s The Actual Star, Tade Thompson’s From the Light of Heaven, Adrian Tchaikovsky’s Shards of Earth, Nnedi Okorafor’s Remote Control, Ada Palmer’s Perhaps The Stars and Richard Powers’s Bewilderment to name only the most obvious half dozen) overlooked ... less surprised by the absence of titles like Alice Albina’s Cwen, Qiouyi Lu’s In The Watchful City or J O Morgan’s The Appliance (though all three are better than most of what has been shortlisted here).

But railing against the judgment of the Clarke award, though a pastime with honourable and indeed Priestian heritage, is not my purpose here. Rather I’m jotting a few more overview-y thoughts. How does the prize stand up on longer timescales? What’s its hit rate, looking back across its three and a half decades of life? What has it got right and, more importantly, what has it missed? On the latter point I should say, incidentally, I’m not here to argue that it has missed me. I’ve never won the Clarke, and don’t now expect to, but I have been shortlisted three times (the last time in 2010), which is probably more than I deserve, and it would be both wrongheaded and otiose to suggest the award needs to reward more straight white US/UK blokes. On the contrary, it has pretty much tracked the larger current of SF across the 21st century, in which the genre-primacy of straight white US/UK blokes has given way to a much more diverse and exciting spread of women writers, writers of colour, queer writers, international writers, iterations of the expressive and eloquent encounter with difference that defines the genre as such. The last all-male shortlist was 2013, the last all-white shortlist 2015, and I don’t expect either eventuality to reoccur again as the prize moves forward. Or at least I would hope not.

That said, looking back over the award’s various shortlists, it’s hard not to notice blindspots in the judge’s judgments. For instance: how can it be that the Clarke has never shortlisted a tie-in franchise novel, a Star Trek-, Star Wars- or Alien-universe title? Many such books are rubbish, of course, but many are good and some are very good, which is what we should expect given that some extremely talented writers—Una McCormack, Pat Cadigan, Diane Duane, Ian Watson—have written them. Hard to shake the sense that the mode is considered infra dig by many, a dalit-style untouchability that strikes an unpleasantly ironic note within our prickly ‘why won’t the literary establishment take our beloved SF seriously?’ self-defensive culture. Writing a good tie-in franchise novel is a very exacting technical challenge, balancing prodigies of backstory and lore, with very specific and tight franchise parameters, and yet telling an exciting, well-characterised, imaginative story of your own. I really don’t see why the best examples of the mode aren’t ever noticed by the Clarke.

Similarly YA: This is a strange omission indeed: YA is not only huge, varied and full of wonderful writing; it has been arguably the key cultural idiom of the early decades of the 21st-century. The last (and, I think, only) time the Clarke listed a YA title was Steve Baxter’s The H-Bomb Girl, all the way back in 2008 [update/correction: over on twitter it is pointed out to me that Patrick Ness's Monsters of Men was shortlisted in 2011, James Smythe's Way Down Dark in 2016, and Patience Agbabi's The Infinite last year, and are all YA or more precisely two are YAs and one a middle-grade title. This considerably dilutes my point, I have to concede; although I don't know if it entirely demolishes it]. YA fantasy, YA dystopia and on occasion YA science fiction have provided some of the key works of the last twenty years, and it just looks odd that the Clarke tends, broadly, to overlook the mode. I could say the same thing about the Booker, but there my expectations are lower.

Saturday, 27 August 2022

Arkady Martine, ‘A Memory Called Empire’ (2019), ‘A Desolation Called Peace’ (2021)

 


The first volume in Martine's Teixcalaan dyad, A Memory Called Empire (2019), was one of the hits of its season: winning the Hugo, nominated for the Nebula and the Clarke, widely praised (as you can see from its cover blurbs). It’s a cleverly-written, intricate space opera that is ‘about’, in the broadest sense, empire: in this case the Tleixcalaan empire, which combines (a) a high degree of filigree social formality and hierarchy, ritual, poetry, culture and architecture with (b) a high-powered spacefleet militarism that sweeps through the galaxy crushing all before it. We come at this vast, rather-Roman, just-a-little-Japanese, quasi-Byzantine space empire (Martine is a scholar of Byzantine and medieval Armenian history) from the outside. The story opens on an onion-layered space habitat called Lsel, its 30,000 inhabitants making a living via, I think it is, space mining. Lsel sort-of is and sort-of isn’t in the Tleixcalaanli imperial ambit, and it is a major plot-driver of the novel whether the emperor will allow their semi-independence to continue, or will actually annex them into the empire (Darth Vader replying to Lando Calrissian’s outraged ‘that was never a part of our agreement’ with: ‘it would be unfortunate if I had to leave a garrison here.’)

Lsel’s previous ambassador to the Tleixcalaanli homeworld, Yskandr, has died after a twenty year stint of ambassadoring. His replacement is the novel’s protagonist: Mahit Dzmare, who gets the job despite being young and inexperienced, embassy-wise. She at least has the advantage of an implant called an ‘imago’. What's that, you ask? Well Lsellians use implanted devices called imagos to benefit from the life-experience and wisdom of older, wiser individuals, whose consciousness is uploaded thereunto. Over time the simulated personality of the imago merges with the actual personality of the bearer. But there are some problems with Mahit's imago. One is that the last time Yskander visited his home-habitat was fifteen years previously, so the imago-Yskander Mahit carries to Tleixcalaan is fifteen years out of date. Another is that it turns out that actual Yskander, having gotten embroiled in imperial politics, was murdered, and the murder is being covered up. A third is that Mahit’s imago malfunctions soon after she arrives in the imperial centre. Then there’s the briar-patch complexity and danger of imperial court politics to navigate, Mahit nearly gets blown up in a bomb attack, the elderly emperor is dying and doesn’t have an heir, and so on. There’s also, waiting in the wings, a menacing alien civilisation that might be readying to attack. It’s all nicely done; Martine manages to convey a lot of worldbuilding data, or more precisely society-building data, without clogging a very serviceable throughline story and mystery. There’s the hint of romance between Mahit and her imperial liaison Three Seagrass (Tleixcalaanli names are all number + object; such that in this world Ronnie Barker would be called ‘Four Candle’) and Mahit comes perilously close to falling under the spell of Tleixcalaanli charm, as—we discover—Yskandr did before her. But the real emotional heart of the story is Mahit’s growing relationship with first fifteen-years-out-of-date Yskandr and later, in a slightly awkward interior menage-a-trois, with just-before-he-was-murdered Yskandr as well. The novel ends with Mahit and her two internal Yskandrs (Yskandrae? Yskandrim?) repudiating the empire and its alluring but toxic beauties, and returning home.

Nicely done but hardly, I thought at the time, earth-shattering: there are plenty of imperial space-operatic works in the SF backlist after all, and this one doesn’t have the deftness and charm of (say) Banks’s Culture, or the economic thought-through complexity of a Charles Stross composition, or the scope of a Lois McMaster Bujold, or the thrilling oddness of Yoon Ha Lee's Ninefox Gambit. But it’s perfectly fine.

Several critics—and the author herself, as evidenced in the book’s dedication—noted that A Memory Called Empire is a novel about the dangerous appeal of imperial cultures. Martine would not be the first scholar simultaneously to deplore the rapacious violence inherent to an imperial project like the Byzantine and to fall in love with Byzantine art and culture. The novel repeatedly tells us, although it doesn’t deign actually to show us, that Tleixcalaanli art and culture are simply superb—there is a reference to a rather unenticing-sounding ‘seventeen-thousand-line poem which described the city’s architecture’ for instance—but nobody is going to say that the Aeneid justifies the Roman empire, any more than they’d say that Dickens and Jane Austen justify the British. Reading A Memory Called Empire I had a different thought, bothered as I was that the Tleixcalaan empire as portrayed didn’t seem to me to square the circle of archaic social mores and heirarchies and super-advanced space-tech and in-effect beyond-scarcity galactic sweep. I came to the epigraph to chapter 7 (Martine supplies each chapter with a Frank Herbertian set of epigraphs from notional in-imperial texts):
[…] whilst Tleixcalaanli literature and media remain a mainstay of the 15-24 age group’s entertainment preferences, this survey also reports large numbers of Lsel youth whose primary reading material is by Lsel or Stationer authors. Particular emphasis should be placed on short fiction, both prose and graphic, distributed in pamphlets or perfect-bound codexes, both of which are easily constructed by every tier’s plastifilm printer. These pamphlets and codexes are often composed by the same people who consume them as entertainment (i.e. the 15-24 age group) without the approval of intervention of the Heritage Board for Literature. —report on “Trends in Media Consumption,” commissioned by the Aknel Amnardbat for Heritage excerpt.
It only goes to show: you can build starships that traverse the galaxy and implants that contain whole deceased consciousnesses, but you can’t get the plural of codex (‘codices’) right. The point of this is not the strange in-world archaism of its samizdat productions (pamphlets, plastifilm books and so on) but the fact of them at all. Which is to say, this is fanwriting, and Martine is gesturing towards a future that includes AO3. The first sentence of the chapter that follows, which begins ‘the fan-vaulted roof of the Palace-Earth ballroom …’, seems to me a sly reference to the fact. Nothing wrong with fanwriting of course, but it in turn made me wonder if this novel is less a meditation and dramatization of actual empires, like the Byzantine or British, so much as it refracts SF’s fascination with galactic empire, in a metafictional move that acknowledges how appealing so many of us find these star-spanning imperiums. We love them, though we know empire as such to be a violent and oppressive geopolitical idiom.

At any rate, now we have the follow-up volume: A Desolation Called Peace, recently shortlisted for this year’s Arthur C Clarke award.

It’s not a terrible novel, but it’s not nearly as good as A Memory Called Empire. Adding a further 500 pages does not very much amplify the world-building richness to the initial conceit. Instead we get a conventional space-opera/alien threat storyline, revisiting our favourite characters from the first novel and ranging a little further outside Tleixcalaan itself.

A Desolation Called Peace follows straight on from the earlier volume. Ambassador Mahit has persuaded the new empress—who comes over as a thoroughly decent sort, actually—not to invade her homeworld but instead turn the attention of her hideously beweaponed space fleet towards the encroachment of the Scary Space Aliens. These turn out to be a hive mind entity that vermiciously knids its way through its human opponents, scattering corpses left right and centre. And, it being space, up and down as well. Mahit is still ambassador, it seems, but she has retired back to Lsel. Three Seagrass hitch-hikes across space on a series of cargo spaceships to visit Mahit there, which struck me as improbable (try going down to Felixstowe and thumbing a lift from a container ship, see how far it gets you) but also irresponsible, since we discover the fate of the galaxy hinges on her mission, which suggests a more secure and formal approach might be called for.

Then there's Nine Hibiscus, who is the newly appointed supreme commander of the space navy, the so-called yaotlek, charged with winning the war against the alien incursion. And here the novel faltered, I felt. The aliens themselves are effective, if generic, antagonists—they winkle-out and eat pilots from their spacecraft like oysters from a shell, and communicate not with words but a hideous phoneme-less shriek that I imagined sounds something like an old dial-up modem. But where in Memory Martine conveys a convincing sense of office politics—imperial court politics, which the novel renders as a higher-stakes version of the same thing—she really doesn’t capture a convincing sense of the practicalities of military command in Desolation. Early on we get this detail:
She leaned her elbows on the strategy table. There’d be elbowprints later: the soft pillowing of her arms leaving its oils on the matte surface, and she’d have to get out a screen-cleaner cloth to wipe them away. But Nine Hibiscus liked to touch her ship. [13]
Picture General George S Patton leaving an oily mark on a polished table: do you really think he would hurry away, fetch a damp cloth and wipe it away himself? Of course not. He had subalterns to clear up after him, in every single aspect of his day-to-day. He would march off barking an order. Having subalterns to clear up after you is a large part of the point of being a five-star general.

This is not, I think, an incidental observarion. We might, if we were so minded, imagine a non-hierarchical army ... but all armies hitherto have been intensely hierarchical organisations, and the army of an extremely socially-hierarchical top-down authoritarian empire like Tleixcalaan would be so a fortiori. But this isn’t what Martine gives us. We are told (not shown) that Nine Hibiscus commands the fanatical loyalty of her troops, and some space battles are described, swarms of interlinked ‘shard’ fighter-craft sweeping hither and yon like a video game, but the military scenes lack the fictional heft of viability. Sure: this is a space-war and not the Byzantine army marching against the Abassids, but nothing about Nine Hibiscus convinces as not a but the imperial military commander. She’s too nice. She spends her time pondering, agonizing, hosting dinner parties (‘she had planned this meal—a strategy dinner’) and, as we have seen, fetching damp cloths to wipe away the marks she herself had left on the polished surface of her flagship’s polished surfaces. There’s no sense here of what a senior military commander actually spends their time doing: logistics, say. Processing intel and issuing orders. Delegating. Shouting: for as the Duke of Wellington himself so famously said, ‘there’s only one way to win a war—shout, shout and shout again!’ 

But then, everybody is nice in this novel. There’s no coldness and cruelty, nothing of the unnerving sadism that strictly hierarchical societies, especially militaristic ones, inculcate and encourage, nothing of that Lawrentian Prussian Officer grasp of the way having power over another human being gratifies itself via the performance of the humiliation and tormenting of the subaltern. Even the empress is nice. Indeed, the empress in this novel is especially nice, which, I have to say, isn’t how emperor/esses have generally manifested in this Justinian, Caligulan, Stalinesque, Pol-Potian, Trumpian world of ours. There is, it’s true, a certain amount of gross-out and violence, especially in the latter portions of the story, but that’s all focused on the hideous alien threat, which isn’t the point I’m making.

Martine has a habit of italicising words, for no very pressing reason: it’s a species of nerd emphasis (‘Lsel station was little’ [115]; ‘Her hands hurt so badly … “you are fascinating, Mahit … also you’re really pretty naked’ [345]), a mannerism that is all over this book, like a rash. The cliffhanger chapter-endings that were handled well in Memory—unexpected explosions, riots, revelations—are watered-down affairs in this novel, often relying on alarms going off, or I should say alarms going off (‘the proximity alarms on the pilots’ deck of the Station went off at once’ [103]: ‘the entire spaceport seemed to explode with noise … the shrill, incessant scream of an evacuation alarm’ [354]).

The command of language is often off. From a sex scene: ‘Mahit was viciously, delightedly sure that when she got her hand between her legs she’d find her dripping wet’—but vicious means pertaining to vice: wickedness, immorality or depravity, and that’s not what Martine means here (savagely, I suppose). And the plotting just wasn’t as clever as the first novel, a fact I think Martine knows, which is why she occasionally felt the over-compensatory need to prod her readers: ‘that was fucking clever’ [277]—it’s not, on this occasion, actually. (Later: ‘“Oh clever,” said Five Agate’). The aliens turn out to be a fungally-infected hive-mind, not malign (not, we might say, vicious) so much as incapable of comprehending human individuality, and the compromise that is reached to end the war is thin and unconvincing, both on its own terms and as a dramatic pay-off to such a lengthy novel. More interesting aspects of the worldbuilding were left unexplored. In particular, there’s huge potential in exploring the way the ‘imagos’ work. There is a passing reference to ‘people who ended up with incompatible imagos’ [102]—the novel specifically makes the gender dysmorphia connection (‘[people] whose gender identity was stronger than they had thought it was and found a cross-gender memory match unbearable’)—but that’s all we get, and Mahit’s three-ply subjectivity becomes less, not more, pronounced as the novel goes on. And the fan-flattery felt less organic in this novel, and so more egregious: at one point Mahit goes to an actual kiosk and buys a literal pulp SF magazine (printed, we're told, ‘on paper, made from flattened pulp rag’): ‘The Perilous Frontier, starring Captain Cameron’. Right. Or I should say, right.

All this doesn’t altogether sink the novel: the story moves along, driven by this exterior threat narrative, and by the carried-over momentum of ‘I wonder what the characters from that first novel are up to now?’ But it’s a markedly less-well-achieved novel than Memory, and I was a little surprised to see it shortlisted for the Clarke. But second guessing the Clarke judges' rationales is a mug's game in which I shall not partake. 

Monday, 15 August 2022

Aliya Whiteley, ‘Skyward Inn’ (2021)


 

Skyward Inn is, amongst other things, a reworking of Daphne du Maurier’s Jamaica Inn (1936), which was in turn (amongst other things) a reworking of Wuthering Heights (1847). But the Gothicism and gnashing intensity of the latter gets watered-down in the du Maurier, and in Aliya Whiteley’s Clarke-shortlisted title it gets swapped-out for something else entirely: a somatic-dissolution more pataphysical than surreal, a planetary romance uncanniness, a dreamy weirdness not incompatible with sharper affects of cruelty and violence. As a version of Gothic this swampy and ultimately liquefying fable is a very striking thing, and as a novel it is highly accomplished: clearly written, expertly paced to suck the reader down as into quicksand, well-characterised, an effective mystery and punctuated with many dream-haunting moments and images.

The story is set a little way in the future, in three locations of which two are where most of the novel takes place. One is ‘the Protectorate’, a portion of walled-off, or self-walled-off, west-country England that has turned its back on the space-faring high-tech modernity of the rest of the country, and lives a rural idyll that is in actuality pinching, grim, worn-down, hand-to-mouth agrarianism ruled over by quasi-puritanical governance that justifies the Cromwellian name the territory has given itself. There’s a quantum of Brexit satire in this (one character ‘when he gets very drunk’ likes to ‘talk about how beautiful the Protectorate is, and how the businesses he runs now are free from so many regulations and technological nightmares’ [113]), although Whiteley, wisely, doesn’t press this pedal too hard.

Across the Severn, Protectorate citizens can see Swansea, now a space-port. The rest of the UK, you see, is a high-tech, spacefaring, and indeed space-imperialising power. A hyperspace portal called ‘the Kissing Gate’ has been discovered in the solar-system—been discovered, or has suddenly appeared—and through it earth space-ships have easy access to an alien world called Qita, a pleasant place with breathable atmosphere and many valuable resources. When Earth fleets first arrived they met the native Qitans: humanoid though blue-skinned, sometimes scaly, large-chinned (there’s quite a lot in the novel about big chins, actually) and with a history amongst themselves of warfare and aggression. But, puzzlingly, the Qitans do not fight the incursion of earthlings. On the contrary, they welcome it, roll over and permit themselves to be exploited. It’s a compellingly odd reaction, and one of the great strengths of Whiteley’s writing is how effectively she writes her Qitan characters, at once genuinely alienating and strangely familiar, simultaneously kindly companions and Vancean strangers.

We get only a few scenes in Swansea. Most of the novel is divided between the Protectorate and scenes set on Qita. There’s a trio of key human characters. One is Jem, who runs the titular pub, a popular Protectorate drinking hole in which she not only serves the usual stouts and lagers but also a Qitan ale called ‘Jarrowbrew’ which is much prized by human drinkers for its soporific and mildly hallucinogenic effects. Jem has a teenage son called Fosse who is chafeing at life in the Protectorate; early scenes see him playing truant from school, wandering around an abandoned farm, wanking, bashing up a tree-trunk with an axe and the like. Soon after having Fosse, young Jem had left the Protectorate altogether, joined the space force and travelled to Qita. Her job there, it seems, was putting up posters and distributing leaflets assuring the Qitans of Earth’s benignity (‘we offer the hand of friendship to join our great nations … we bring peace and opportunities for a brighter future’) even as Earth asset-stripped Qita and killed Qitans. In her absence Fosse was raised by his uncle, Jem’s brother Dominic, a community officer and true-believer in the Protectorate project. Jem soon returned from outer space to run the Skyward Inn, but Fosse continues living with his uncle and harbours a congeries of resentments concerning his mum’s abandonment of him. Relations are tense between sister and brother Jem and Dom too, and are made more tense by the fact that Jem has shacked-up with a Qitan called Isley—actually called some singsong harmonic soundburst uncapturable by human orthography, but known as Isley in Devon since he, or it, is a fan of the Isley Brothers music.

This relationship, between human Jem and Qitan Isley, is where the novel starts. In general the Protectorate hates and fears outsiders and won’t permit aliens in their land, but an official permission has been granted to Isley so that he can live in the Skyward Inn and concoct the Jarrowbrew so popular with human drinkers. The locals are wary of the alien presence, and baffled by Jem’s relationship, but are broadly accepting of the state of affairs since it means they can quaff their Jarrowbrew. Isley himself (itself) is a charming, gentle-mannered soul, and you see why Jem has fallen in love with him (it). There’s no sex involved, and indeed, for reasons that become clear towards the end of the novel, Isley doesn’t permit Jem even to touch him, but they are beautifully companionable with one another, and Jem finds in her alien partner a connection and belonging she does not have with her son, her brother or any of her community.

I’m making heavy weather of laying out the set-up of this novel, something Whiteley herself does deftly and involvingly. And from this point-on I’m going to start straying into spoilers, so: you know. Have a care.

A second Qitan arrives in the Skyward Inn, this time illegally (she, or it, is called Wonton, but known as Wanda) and Jem hides her (it) in the cellar. Jem then recruits her brother, against his better judgment, to try and smuggle Wanda out in secret and back to Qita. This project does not go to plan. Teenage Fosse gets involved with a newcomer to the area—the Protectorate is eager for settlers to come and work its many abandoned farms—called Cee, a man who gives off dangerous vibes. He has two adult daughters, one or other or both of whom Fosse lusts over. Scenes on Earth are intercut with Jem’s memories of exploring Qita and observing Qitan life and society.

There is a through-line narrative to follow, and in a manner of speaking a mystery, or secret, at the story’s heart which the novel unravels in a way any reader can follow with satisfaction. I say so to stress that readers who prize plot above all will find much to enjoy here, but I also say so in order to assert something else: that the greatness of this novel does not depend upon its plot. Whiteley has been called a surrealist writer, and I have seen Skyward Inn compared to VanderMeer’s Annihilation, but neither is right, I think. There is something quite distinctive, tonally and imaginatively, about this book, and it inheres neither in the Freudian subordination of rationality to the subconcious that marks surrealism, nor the distorting intensities of VanderMeer's New Weird-posturing Southern Reach environmentalism. Whiteley is a distinctive writer, unlike anyone else. There's something perhaps Chris Priestian about the opening chapters here, and I got a certain Ted Chiang vibe about the middle portion of the book, but it flows brilliantly into its final sections in a quite inimitable way.

Skyward Inn is a novel about loneliness and togetherness, about separation and assimilation, in which the strange life-cycle of the Qitans, and the mystery of their blithe acquiescence in their own colonisation, stand as metaphors for something profound and arresting in the human condition. It is a novel that works as a series of gorgeous, unsettling, quasi-poetic moments and images, disposed along a more conventionalised narrative line. Here's an example: local widow Mrs Satterly calls at Dom’s house, and Fosse lets her in. She has lost her dog at the graveyard, where she had been visiting her husband Bob’s grave, and wants help retrieving the pooch. Bob was there, she tells Dom. ‘“He’s buried there,” Dom said. “I know that,” she snapped. “But the ground by the tree, the soil, was different. And he was in there.”’
“Different how?”

“Softer,” she said … “It hasn’t been raining.”

“No.”

“It was like jelly, and I put my hand in, and Bob held it. Under the soil. He held it.”

“You felt something grab you?”

“Bob did.”

“Okay,” said [Dom] in that patient, unbelieving tone [Fosse] knew so well.

“He did!” Mrs Satterly said, indignant.

“How did you know it was him?”

She thought about it, and then said, “Who else would hold my hand?”

“All right,” said Dom. “All right.”

“We stayed that way for a little while,” she said. “It was fine. It was fine. I wasn’t scared. But then I realised that I couldn’t feel my own fingers any more—everything was sort of mixed-up under the soil—so I pulled free and then something snagged me. Caught my sleeve. I didn’t see what it was, but it wasn’t Bob. And then Bailey ran away. Poor Bailey. Poor Bailey.” Fosse watched her cry. It wasn’t a performance. [118]
Bailey is her dog. Fosse, sent out to retrieve the hound, visits the graveyard spooked by this (of course) spooky story, and for a while the novel flirts with the tone of its matrimonies, Brontëan, du Maurian—that is, with a Gothic uncanny and strangeness, the echt horror-story shiver. Whiteley even sets this scene at Halloween. But the novel as a whole isn’t really interested in this affect. It is doing something rather less derivative, rather more potently original. Isley is no Heathcliff (though he is a compelling stranger). The secret lurking in the moonlit alleyways and fields of the Protectorate is not, as per du Maurier, smuggling and shipwrecking (although Jem does try to smuggle Wanda out, and the legality of the Jarrowbrew is a little unclear). What Skyward Inn does with Jamaica Inn is deepen the earlier book’s portrait of the complicated, guilt-generative nature of belonging, and desire, as such. 

Du Maurier’s Mary Yellen is alarmed and frightened by the vicious world into which she arrives, the cut-throats and ship-wreckers, but drawn to them as well. She arrives at Jamaica Inn as an orphan to live with her aunt and her aunt’s husband—the towering, villainous Joss. She can see that something is awry in this world, but at the beginning is not sure what. It seems for a while as if she is being courted in the traditional sense by Joss’s younger brother Jem. He takes her in a ‘jingle’ (a light carriage) to the town of Launceston and buys her some gold earrings and a red cape. But Jem got the money for these gifts by horse-stealing. He boasts to Mary that he has many ‘wives’ in Cornwall and urges her to spend the night with him. When she refuses he abandons her to walk the long nighttime way home. Not a good sort, in other words, and Mary has to pass through peril and assault, witness violence and murder, before the story’s end. That end—spoilers for Jamaica Inn, but you really ought to have read this famous novel, or at least seen the (much inferior) Hitchock movie version—is the revelation that the local vicar is the ringleader of a local gang of ship-wreckers, centred on the titular inn. At the story's climax Bad Vicar jumps off a cliff rather than be captured by the local Squire and his posse, and Mary resolves to leave Cornwall to return again to her childhood home and make a new life there. But on her journey out she bumps into Jem, driving a cart with all his possessions in it and after a brief exchange agrees to go with him.

Skyward Inn ends on a very different note, but there is in the literal dissolution of flesh into flesh, and the surrender of individuality into the extraterrestrial gestalt, a related sense of the way desire—for sex, for partnership, for belonging—pulls against the grain of the conventional and respectable, which is to say the normal and the familiar.

About halfway through novel, teenage Fosse kills old Cess (who may or may not be his father) with an axe. It’s a curiously underdetermined, and indeed underpowered, scene, this; and I wondered if the lack of affect was a deliberate move, a dialling-down of shock. If so I’m not sure it works. Fosse flees the Protectorate, is recruited by the space navy and travels to Qita. The novel handles his guilt at this crime in a strangely patchy manner. Sometimes he remembers that he murdered an adult in this gruesome manner. Much of the time he seems to forget, distracted by a kind of Qitan pilgramage. He ends the novel a more likeable individual than he begins it, which is a strange trajectory to pass along given what he has done. But my reaction here may simply index the effectiveness with which Whiteley has wrongfooted me, and it is in this wrongfooting, or what we might call Whiteley's skill at estrangement, that the novel’s greatness inheres. The denouement is both revolting and strangely attractive, calming, desirable. 

As a commentary upon imperialism (which is I suppose one of the things this complex, intricate novel is) Skyward Inn is much more powerful and insightful than its fellow Clarke-award shortlistee, Wergen: the Alien Love War, a book that also contains weirdly complaisant colonised aliens. That also presents itself as a novel about love, but it looks thin indeed beside Whiteley's amazing, subtle account of the topic. Whiteley understands how, paradoxical though it sounds, love is both a desire to immerse oneself wholly in the other and a desire to bolster one’s seperateness, one’s hermetic individuality, to separate from the other—because, I suppose, love is the necessary ground for the self, and therefore of self-esteem and self-uniqueness. We are caught between our desires to be intimately with others and our concomitant desire, just as strong, to be free of others and entirely alone; or not caught between these twinned desires, but defined by them, construed into subjectvity by their dialectic. The novel finds a beautiful way of articulating that state of affairs. 

And the setting, the inn of the title, is important too. The pub is a place where we come to drink alone together, after all. Drinking is an individual business in that it affects individual sensoria; and yet we come together to drink.

On Qita, both Jem and later her son Fosse visit the alien equivalent of the Inn. This is ‘the market’, where Qita traders, wearing a stone slab around their neck balanced on their chest to make a ledge, walk round and round a courtyard ‘selling’ Jarrowbrew to the gathered customers. I put selling in inverted commas there because the transaction doesn’t involve the exchange of any wonga. ‘The most inexplicable part to me,’ Jem later recalls, ‘is that no money changes hands’:
Locals insisted trade is the concept that explains Langzin Square best, but this is not supply and demand: when the glasses have all been used and the container is empty, the trader must leave. It does a trader no good to offer a more or less popular product—not that they strictly offer it at all. [21]
Back on Earth, Jem learns from Isley that she doesn’t have the whole story. ‘The traders are meant to leave the market when they’re sold out,’ he confirms. ‘But here’s the thing—they have accomplices. Helpers have worked outside the walls to make very small tunnels, slanted downwards, through which Jarrowbrew can be poured. They wait outside and at a set time a trader stops by their hole, and refills their flask. Everyone knows it, and it is tolerated.’ As a result of generations of secret-but-everyone-knows-it hole drilling ‘the walls are weakened … the square is in danger of collapsing’ [23]. This is a nice image for the pub as such, the way society knows the damage alcohol and alcoholism does yet nods along at it, tolerates it within notional limits (21 units a week maximum) that everybody ignores: a rebus for the structural damage and danger of that. It’s also an eloquent expression of something else which, I think, is more interesting: it isn’t the rules of an alien society that gives you an insight into the nature of the place, but knowing which rules it is OK to break. True, that.

Whiteley is exceptionally wise and insightful on this question, the nature and scope of difference, personal, cultural, social, and how we broach these differences, the accessibilities and inaccessibilities of all our intersubjectivities. Alcohol, from real beer to fictional Jarrowbrew, disinhibits and so promotes sociability, it reveals a kind of truth (in vino veritas and all that) and yet occludes our mentation, it thrills the mind at the same time as muddling it. Anne Carson’s great poem ‘O What A Night (Alkibiades)’ juxtaposes the drunkenness of the Attic ‘symposium’ (a drinking party, of course) with the mind-reeling philosophy of Socrates, which is also about insight and connection and sex.
When Sokrates speaks, on the other hand,
I experience something uncanny,
I don’t know what

it is—a wild feeling
like a heart attack, or like dancing—
those nights you dance as if in a trance
and glance in the mirror to find you’re in tears.

I’m not drunk.
This is different.
I know it sounds
like the same old same old.
It is, and it isn’t, the same old same old. In one of his earlier novel Anthony Burgess speculates about the sacramental nature of the British, or more specifically English, centrality of the pub to social life, as the local landlord Ted permits the narrator to keep drinking after closingh hours (a 'lock-in' they used yo call this, in my day):
It is recognised in England that home drinking is no real pleasure. We pray in a church and booze in a pub: profoundly sacerdotal at heart, we need a host in both places to preside over us. In Catholic churches as in continental bars the host is there all the time. But the Church of England kicked out the Real Presence and the licensing law gave the landlord a terrible sacramental power. Ted was giving me grace of his free will, holding back closing—which is death—making a lordly grant of extra time. [Anthony Burgess, The Right To An Answer (1960), 18]
This is one of the differences between Whiteley's novel and the others I mention above, the VanderMeer and the like. There is something sacramental at the heart of her vision as a writer, something in which drink and food and divine blood and actual bodies are all versions of one another, real presences that iterate the holiness of our interconnectivity and our individuality both, even in sinfulness (evem so extreme as murder). Skyward Inn is a rare novel, brilliant and penetrating and unnerving, a book about love and belonging and alienation and fear, a work that understands that solitude and togetherness are not, actually, opposites. It is, by a long margin, the best novel on the Clarke shortlist.