Sunday, 8 November 2020

The Queen's Gambit (dir Scott Frank 2020)



I haven't read the Walter Tevis novel on which the Scott Frank and Allan Scott Netflix miniseries, The Queen's Gambit, is based, though I'm quite tempted to. This lavishly-mounted, well-acted and decently-written seven-part drama is enjoyable and impressive, and will surely win many awards. Young Beth Harmon, an orphan being raised in a forbidding Christian orphanage (the authorities tranquillise their charges to keep them docile, sowing the seeds for adult Beth's addictions to pills and booze) is taught chess by the janitor. It turns out she has a Bobby Fischer level of natural genius although without—a canny move by the storytellers, this—any of Fischer's noisome personality traits or paranoia. Beth is perhaps a little chilly, personality-wise, but she is always likeable, humane, relatable. Or relatable except in one regard, for, played by the striking-looking Anya Taylor-Joy dressed immaculately in haute couture, Beth is beautiful beyond all normal human possibility. But this is TV, after all, not real-life.

Teenage Beth is adopted by a childless couple, a distant father who soon leaves the family home and a talented but thwarted, alcoholic, suburban mother. The series traces Beth's rise through the world of chess, from State- to US-champion until, after losing a couple of times to the stony-faced Soviet global champion Burgov, she finally conquers her personal demons and, with the help of her various friends and ex-lovers, defeats Burgov to win the world championship [update: I'm corrected on Twitter; this final match is an international tournament in the USSR, not the world championship].

Perhaps that last paragraph makes the series' denouement sound just a little, well, sappy. I wonder. Snipy of me to say so, perhaps, but there we are. To be clear: it's most certainly not a weakness of the story that it repudiates the conventions of misery-porn and concentrates instead upon a positive uplifty narrative through-line. On the contrary it is a notable strength that it stresses the way Beth's self-reliance is augmented by her friends and lovers to enable her to prevail in the end. That's excellent, and the more so because it's relatively rare in TV drama. No: the problem, I think, is that the obstacles the drama throws in the way of Beth's rise—obstacles needful in a narrative sense, since without such friction we have no drama—get resolved in too facile a manner. Beth's alcoholism and drug-addiction are vividly portrayed, although the show's more fundamental love of the scrupulous, gorgeous recreation of 1960s interiors in all their quiddity and glossy glory rather softpedals the skeeziness of her situation. But it is, I think, a problem that Beth's addictions are, by the end of the drama, simply waved away, with a little help from her friends, and via her final big victory. That doesn't ring true.

As for the chess, the show mostly manages to tread its delicate line, keeping things just actual-chessy enough not to irk real chessheads, whilst not getting bogged down in chessular specifics to the point of alienating audience members who don't know their Nimzo-Indian from a hole in a ground. It's a little over-simplified of course: actual moves are vagued at and the tournament-play seems to consist entirely of one-off matches between great players, almost never drawn. We can chalk that up to dramatic license. Still, without specific content to the games the show has instead to peg Beth's victories or defeats to exteriorities. So, the first time she loses to Burgov is connected, dramatically, to the death of her mother (she dies of hepatitis in their shared hotel room as Beth is playing downstairs) and the second time to Beth being titanically hung-over after a night of boozy Parisian indulgence, painting the town rouge with a French friend. Which means that the third and final time she defeats Burgov, at end of the show's narrative-arc rainbow, becomes less about her gameplay and more about the support of all the characters she had met and befriended along the way.

Still, what occurred to me, having watched the finale, is that this isn't really a show about chess. Or to put it more precisely, it's a show that uses chess, and the visual codes of mimetic historical realism, to tell a superhero origin story. Beth is not a crime fighter, but then again all these superheroic crime fighters, from Superman to Batman, from X-Men to the Avengers, are actually about re-establishing order from chaos, and that is entirely Beth's gift, and the show's throughline story. Chess is Beth's superpower in the sense that her skill goes beyond Batman-style super-preparation and armature of materiel (in Bruce Wayne's case, combat-training, long hours in the gym and lots of high-tech; in Beth's case training-games with other chess masters and long hours reading chess manuals)—that her skill goes beyond this into Superman, Dr Manhattan or Wonder Woman type innateness. She plays key moves intuitively, even her international chess master friends don't understand her total grasp of position and ability to find the right move, and so on.

So far as that is concerned, it's the origin part of the superhero story that The Queen's Gambit gives us. Three of the ‘Origin archetypes’ listed at TV Tropes are especially relevant, I think: the ‘Lucky Accident’ (the ‘Freak Lab Accident, one-in-a-million malfunction, or what have you; e.g., Spider-Man, The Flash, The Incredible Hulk, Daredevil or The Fantastic Four’); a combination of the ‘My Own Creation’ mythos and the origin-story rooted in ‘Augmentation’ (for instance ‘participating in an experiment taking a Super Serum to become a Super Soldier like Captain America’, with the augmentation, here, being the chess-board); and ‘Pure Will’. The ‘Lucky Accident’ narrative takes us back to the reason Beth is an orphan, shown repeatedly in flashback. Her mentally unstable mother deliberately crashes their car into an oncoming truck (‘close your eyes’ she tells young Beth, on the back seat, just before the collision), but Beth is miraculously thrown clear of the resulting pile-up and is discovered standing, unscratched, in the middle of the road. The other two story archetypes are obvious enough.

The point is that superheroes are often orphans, like Batman or Superman; that they are often otherwise unconsidered ‘ordinary’ people, or have unconsidered ‘ordinary’ alter-egos, whilst at the same time being at the centre of global geopolitical crises and crunch-points (Beth beating the Soviets at the height of the Cold War); that they in some sense fight chaos ‘for all of us’ (eager crowds gathering inside and outside the venues at which Beth plays, watching her every move). The point is that there is something miraculous, something touched by wonder, about Beth's chess abilities.

The question as to why ‘we’ are so obsessed with super-heroes at the moment is one future cultural-historians of the first decades of the 21st-century will chew over. I'm not sure what the answer to this question is, actually, although it seems to me a profound one, and it doesn't seem to me surprising that, after the super-saturation of DC and (especially) MCU science-fictional superheroes over the last ten years the trope is migrating to other modes of representation, as here. We may have had enough spandex, without, perhaps, satisfying our appetite for superheroes as such. A few years back I wrote a History of Science Fiction that located the origins of SF not in Hugo Gernsback, not in Wells, Verne or Poe, not even in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, but much earlier: in the Protestant Reformation, during which time, from the early 1600s onwards, a new ‘materialist’ form of the fantastic budded off from that aboriginal storytelling human mode. One consequence of this origin story, I suggested, was that certain elements from the cauldron of the Reformation are still in the, as it were, DNA of science fiction. A key one of these was the debate over the nature and powers of the divine intercessor, the messiah. It certainly seems to me inarguable that SF is fascinated by messiah figures, and we can if we like refer to all such figures, from Paul Atreides to Luke Skywalker, from Doctor Who to Neo, superheroes. It has something to do, and manifestly connects with a great many people on the level of, a mixture of desire for a saviour and anxiety about the saviour's nature and capabilities. 

Friday, 23 October 2020

What Sinks "Underwater"

 


Although, actually, I rather enjoyed William Eubank's 2020 science fiction action horror movie. But it doesn't really work, and I was curious why. Spoilers follow.

It's essentially Alien underwater. A deepwater drilling platform located (improbably enough) at the bottom of the Mariana Trench is hit by what seems at first an earthquake. Kristen Stewart and other highly attractive underwater drilling technicians, as all commercial drilling technicians of course are, run around the collapsing facility in their underwear, closing bulkheads and pressing control panel buttons and so on. Some of them are killed in the chaos. The survivors clamber into diving suits and make their way across the seabed to a different part of the facility, where the escape pods are located. More of them die, this time hauled away by tentacled monsters—hitherto-unencountered lifeforms, mansized pallid motile globs of feelers and teeth. As the facility further collapses more of the cast are, as per Alien, snaffled by these nameless horrors. There is much wriggling through collapsed, flooding corridors, and plenty of shock moments, diving suit helmets suddenly filling with blood as their wearers howl and so on. 

Finally Stewart, Jessica Henwick and John Gallagher make it to the escape pod room, all the slightly less attractive cast members having been tentacled-away. Stewart manages to send Henwick and Gallagher away in their pods, but her own pod is broken, so she stays behind. And this is where the movie stages its big reveal. The human-sized undersea monsters are merely the progeny of one absolutely gigantic tentacle-and-teeth monster

Far, far beneath in the abysmal sea,
From ancient, dreamless, uninvaded sleep
The Kraken waketh
... and it's Cthulhu! It's your actual gigantic Lovecraftian beast. Stewart gazes into the ph'nglui mglw'nafh r'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagnian horror for a while, and then presses the base's nuclear self-destruct (all mining platforms, as I understand it, are equipped with one such) immolating herself and the elder horror both at once. 

The whole movie is expensively mounted, well-made, nicely designed, earnestly acted. It is no more intrinsically silly than was Alien back in 1979. And yet it doesn't work. I wonder if the reason it doesn't work is because this Lovecraftian flourish mismatches the tenor of the movie as a whole. Underwater is, as Alien was, body-horror. Now, body horror can be very effective at spooking and upsetting us, squicking our sense of somatic integrity and safety. But Lovecraft did not write body horror. His stories do sometimes contain horrible bodies, but that's not the same thing. Lovecraft wrote topographic horror. Think how ‘The Dunwich Horror’ begins with pages and pages of eerie scene-setting off the Aylesbury turnpike in north central Massachusetts; or how ‘The Colour Out Of Space’ opens by situating itself in a particular Arkham locale (‘the old folk have gone away, and foreigners do not like to live there. French-Canadians have tried it, Italians have tried it, and the Poles have come and departed. It is not because of anything that can be seen or heard or handled, but because of something that is imagined. The place is not good for the imagination, and does not bring restful dreams at night.’) Heidegger distinguished between space and place in order to valorise the latter as the dwelling of Being. Lovecraft intuitively turned this around, and his work generates a queasy apprehension of place as the iteration of nightmarish inescapability, place as the already-dwelt-in by nameless ghastliness. There's nothing in the generic corridors and control rooms of Underwater's subsea base that can evoke that, and the scenes of the cast lolloping across the ocean bed entail no connection, or recognition, in the audience. Can't have the unheimlich without the heimlich, after all. 

Friday, 2 October 2020

Platonesi: Susanna Clarke's "Piranesi" (2020)


 
Reviews of Susanna Clarke’s Piranesi have been cagey about revealing too much of the plot, as if to say even rudimentary things about the novel would be to spoil it. I don’t see this, I must say. But perhaps you want to exercise caution.

Clarke's title character, narrating in first-person via his journal entries, is the only living inhabitant of a vast mansion—so vast that he can never find a way out of it, so huge an ocean washes tidally through the lower levels, and clouds float through the upper ones. The House consists of an endless succession of rooms and corridors, adorned everywhere with marble statuary past which Piranesi wanders, feeding on seaweed and fruits de mer from the ground floor, and tending the skeletons of thirteen previous inhabitants of the place. Piranesi is an unusually ingenuous, almost a child-like narrator, and we soon realise that the only other person in the House—a twice weekly visitor called ‘The Other’, whom Piranesi considers a friend—is probably not all he pretends, no matter how much Piranesi trusts him.

This is all well-evoked, the universe of the House neither mistily sketched nor over-rigorously delineated. The worst you could say is that it's more cool conceit than rigorous narrative, more a arrangement of striking images than a framework able to furnish all the satisfactions the novel as a form. I suppose those images refract (a) Clarke herself stuck largely inside her house since 2012 with her debilitating, chronic illness, (b) a Lewisian Narnia-style allegory by which the world is God's strange mansion—Magician’s Nephew supplies the novel’s epigraph—and (c) some manner of anxiety about climate change (the lower levels are dangerously flooded!) 

In all it is a good though not, I think, a great novel. I'm not sure it has the unexpectedness or baffling eloquence of particular image that defines the best surrealism (your mileage may, of course vary). Certainly it would be hard to claim it as on a par with Strange and Norrell, undeniably a major work of 21st-century fiction. But I enjoyed it very much, and its core idea has lingered with me since I finished it a couple of weeks ago. It’s an upholstered short-story rather than a novel, but that’s OK.

On the topic of spoilers, I’m a little puzzled by the reviewerish pussy-footing. Aspects of the way Clarke unfolds her story seem to me readily guessable, even from the basic summary of the premise I give here. Things go broadly how any reader who thought about the matter for five minutes would anticipate them to go. Piranesi wandering his strange megadomus would hardly fill two hundred and fifty pages, so of course there are complications. But perhaps you would prefer to stop reading now, if you haven’t yet picked up Clarke's novel, lest I taint your enjoyment. I mean, perhaps you never started reading this blogpost, in which case you obviously have no problem.

My point is that before I'd even cracked the covers of the novel, and just going on the reviews I'd read, I asssumed that Clarke was going to set her drafty, universe of oceanwashed inward marble halls against our world (after all, the epigraph is from the Magician’s stuffing Nephew) and that when I started reading it seemed obvious that the Other would prove to have come from the latter. And so it transpires: not just him but various others including, we soon discover, Piranesi himself. That P. cannot remember the other world is a function of the strange, memory-effacing effect the House has upon those who live within it for any length of time. The Other relies upon this amnesia (he ‘tests’ Piranesi by dropping words like ‘Battersea’ into conversation, to check that they strike him as meaningless). 

So, yes: the story brings in new characters from our world, and takes Piranesi on a path towards an understanding of his actual condition. This includes him encountering other texts and manuscripts, including ones he had himself earlier written but which he now has forgotten. In parallel with Piranesi's burgeoning awareness we, as readers, piece together an our-world-set story about an Aleister Crowley-type magus, called Laurence Arne-Sayles, who gathered a group of acolytes around him with promises that he could access miraculous dimensions, and who used his power over these people to indulge his various sadistic caprices. The twist is that where Crowley was a fraud, Arne-Sayles actually could do what he claimed. He had devised a ritual to open a portal from our world to Piranesi's House.


Arne-Sayles stranded Piranesi (we learn his ‘real’, our-world name about halfway through) in the House. The amnesiac quality of the place has meant he has forgotten this, and all his prior life as well. The story of the novel is really the story of him recuperating that lost knowledge.

That's not the main thing that interests me about this novel. Rather I'm struck by the extent to which Clarke's novel is Platonic. Very Platonic. Much Plato.   

In particular I'm interested in what it says about the state of contemporary Fantasy. Because what Clarke’s novel does is dramatize Plantonism—it takes Platonism, or Neoplatonism, seriously, just as Lewis does in his Narnia books. The final pages of The Last Battle are perfectly up-front about this: both Narnia and our world are revealed as inferior imitations of the Realm of the Forms, Lewis’s God, into which the Pevensies and other good Narnians (but not Lewis’s meshuggener dwarfs, nor his we-can-be-honest Muslim-caricature ‘Calormen’) are granted access. It's all in Plato, we're explicitly told. Lewis, steeped in medievalism, felt at home with a Neoplatonic folding together of the Realm of the Forms and the Christian God and I suspect Clarke does too. If there’s a twist at the end of this novel it is—unless I have misunderstood things—that the House is our world, Plato’s cave of deprivation and forgetfulness, and ‘our world’ figures in Clarke’s conception as the sunlit outside, which is quite a neat reversal. 

I don’t know how common it is to ‘believe’, genuinely, in Plato nowadays. Perhaps lots of folk do, though if so I’m not among their number (I've heard it said that mathematicians are more liable to be Platonists than other kinds of people). But I am interested in the way there seems to have been a little cluster of strictly ‘Platonic’ fantasy novels lately: Stephenson’s Anathem for one, Jo Walton’s Socratic trilogy for another. If I’m right that Clarke is styling the House as a version of Plato’s Cave, with statues and fragmentary graffiti rather than shadows, then the pervasive sea-swell, the scent of salt, the dangerous rising tides, the albatrosses and other oceanic fauna, become an interesting addendum to the parable as originally told in The Republic. Or perhaps not, for according to Marie-Élise Zovko when Plato wrote of a cave it was a sea-cave that he most likely had in mind:
Plato’s Sicilian voyages may have influenced his formulation of the central analogies which form the axis of the Republic, in particular the Analogy of the Cave. The characteristics of Plato’s cave are reminiscent of caves inhabited or in regular use from prehistoric times to Classical antiquity, which lie along the ancient seafaring routes across the Adriatic. A great concentration of these caves are located on the islands and coastline of central and southern Dalmatia in present-day Croatia, as well as in Apulia … Both shores were inhabited by Illyrian tribes in the period when the Mycenaean Greeks first colonized the region, and the Illyrians continued to be a significant presence after the establishment of the Greek colonies of the Eastern Adriatic and Southern Italy. Syncretistic ritual practices of which there is evidence in the caves of Southern and Central Dalmatia appear to have had their roots in a mixture of older Illyrian rituals and Greek mysteries or hero worship. [Marie-Élise Zovko, ‘Of Caves, Lines, and Sea Travels: Plato’s Syracusan Voyages and the Central Analogies of the Republic’, in Heather L. Reid, Davide Tanasi and Susi Kimbell (eds) Politics and Performance in Western Greece Book Subtitle: Essays on the Hellenic Heritage of Sicily and Southern Italy Book (Parnassos Press 2017)]
I suppose Clarke’s cave is filled with neoclassical statuary because, taking inspiration from the artist whose name supplies the novel's title, she conceives not an Ancient Greek house but a later, Renaissance or Early Modern one. And, because Neoplatonism exists in the shadow of its Platonic origins. And I suppose her protagonist lives in the House alone because one of the ways the Early Modern era ‘read’ its duties towards this more perfect form of the divine was in terms of seclusion: eremites, anchorites, hermits living in their cells and so on.

One thing that particularly fascinates me in this novel is the way, as I see it, it styles apocalypse in architectural terms. It’s not just that Piranesi is, as it were, living in the ruins after the cosmic catastrophe, or that the ruins are the world, its that the ruins are interiorised architectural spaces. I’m not sure I can think of another work that figures apocalypse this way—though there are, of course, a great many verbally-rendered apocalypses, from John of Patmos’s Biblical vision through ten thousand religious or science-fictional ends-of-the-world; and we’ve seen an increasing shift in the centre of gravity in the apocalyptic imagination from words to images, from John Martin’s enormous canvases in the nineteenth-century to the plethora of big-screen cinematic renderings of world-ending disaster of modern times. But this move to architecture is interesting, more so (I think) than the story Clarke is actually telling. I wonder if this is also Neoplatonic, or at least inflected by Clarke’s Lewisian interest in older modes of thinking or apprehending the world:
Neoplatonic thought has no concept of the ‘sign’, in which words denote things by representing or standing for them, and in which the sign and its referent are distinct registers. This absence enables us to comprehend the intellectual centrality of the key Neoplatonic doctrine of the interpenetration and respective mirroring of microcosm and macrocosm. That doctrine was ‘influential’ beyond identifiably Neoplatonic thinkers. In this episteme the entire universe, from its smallest to its largest parts, from the humblest animal to God, consists in a series of resemblances, similarities and sympathies. There can be no concept of an arbitrary relation in which one thing, a sign, stands for and represents another. All relations are real relations, and all connections between aspects of existence reflect their respective natures. Hence symbolic relations both have significance and are real relations, or connections in nature. There is no space for the ‘classical’ gap between signs and existence. Renaissance thought is hyperrealist. The world presented to knowledge consists of emblems, traces, signatures and resemblances. These are the marks of that network of spiritual-real interconnections whereby the whole tissue of existence is held together.
I’m quoting here from an essay by Paul Hirst, who moves from this to a meditation on what we might call the ‘architectural Imaginary’:
For Renaissance thought a central question is how to present those traces of harmony and cosmic order—not to represent them but to make them immediately present to human subjects. In such presentation geometry has a privileged position as the fundamental mirroring of the natural order, since it is both an elaborated science of ordered forms and the present and manifest form of the order of the world. The figures of geometry correspond to the constitutive proportions of the world. The two fundamental proportional relations accessible to experience are those of the human body and those of the harmonic scale. Such devices provide traces and resemblances whereby man can be put into immediate contact with the divine. Hence the familiar Vitruvian figure has a philosophical significance belying the fact that it is a commonplace. Such figures and proportions are supra-intentional: they present the cosmic order, even if those who draw them do so merely from convention. For the Neoplatonic architectural theorist the order of the world could best be revealed through conscious purpose, through the rationally planned design of the architect-adept. This systematizes experience, putting it at the service of intellect and the superior perception of cosmic order. Hence the philosophical and practical significance of an architecture that links science, art and spiritual concerns. Proportions in structures are the visible resemblances of the order of man and the universe. [Paul Hirst ‘Foucault and Architecture’, AA Files 26 (Autumn 1993), 54]
I wonder if something along these lines is going on with Clarke’s vision in this novel? And, having started down this line of thought, I'm wondering if there is something similar going on not only in the original engravings by Giovanni Battista Piranesi himself, in all their proliferating ur-fractal architectural splendour and terror—but also in the tendency of my beloved genre to render its worldbuilding in quasi-architectural terms: vast cathedral-like spaceships, floating cities, whole planets smothered with buildings. There's a lot to think about, here.



Sunday, 27 September 2020

Enola Holmes (dir. Harry Bradbeer 2020)

 


Enola Holmes is OK: handsomely mounted, with a charming, energetic performance from Millie Bobby Brown as the would-be consulting detective girl scion of the Holmes family and decent support from ‘toss a coin to your Sherlock’ Henry Cavill and Sam ‘Oswald Mycroft’ Claflin. The plot is bobbins and the mystery and its resolution nonsensical, but that hardly matters: everything bounces along nicely. Nonetheless I found myself disliking it quite strongly. I’ll tell you why. 

At the heart of this story is an idea: that girls can be as clever as boys and should be allowed to choose how they live their lives. Our heroine embodies this idea; stacked against her are the various baddies who believe girls are inferior to boys and should be disciplined into submission and readied for one thing only, marriage. This idea—that girls are not intrinsically inferior to boys—is manifestly true. But it is dramatically inert. I mean, who in 2020 could possibly disagree with it? Of course it’s true. A drama predicated on it might have had bite a hundred years ago, but now it feels like it's fighting an antique battle. 

To be clear, I'm arguing that the problem lies not in this idea's social or ethical truth but rather its dramatic vapidity. Enola is likeable and her antagonists are vile. There’s no nuance here. “Girls are as clever as boys” is not a story, it’s a default.  Compare Enola’s asides to camera—sprightly and well-delivered though they are—with Fleabag’s same (slightly unfair to compare a YA adventure spritz to an adult comedy-drama, but still). Fleabag has the courage to make its protagonist charming, compelling, insightful and broken, needy, often unlikeable. Friction in her drama is provided not by gurning moral-monsters but actual people, some understandably alienated by Fleabag, others caught up in their own lives, selfish and real. The original Sherlock Holmes characterisation is similar, if sketchier; brilliant and obnoxious, compelling and distant. As a result these characters and their stories acquire dramatic heft and audience commitment and belief.

It’s not that there’s no depth to Enola Holmes (there isn’t—but this is popcorn fun not Sophocles, which is fine) it’s that there’s no real tension, that the film can’t squeeze actual excitement or peril or thrills from its adventure conventions. Drama is more than lots of things happening one after the other against a background of Edwardian props and settings.

Friday, 28 August 2020

TENET (dir. Christopher Nolan 2020)



Tenet is a por- and pre- kind of movie: portentious and preposterous. Poor-man's-Bond and pretend-deep. Lots of boom and bang & billionaire-y conspicuous consumption wrapped around a rod of pure Nonsense. I enjoyed it a lot.

It's a hard movie to discuss without spoilers, but I'll have a go. It's overlong. It drags particularly in its final act, a clonking battle sequence (actors filmed running backwards such that the footage can be reversed to make them look like they're running forwards through imploding smokebombs and rubble reassembling into buildings .... don't look like actors running forwards. That's just not how they look). The characters are so thin in terms of writing—and in some cases literally—you could use them as rizlas. ‘The Protagonist’, a beefy if generic John David Washington, is nothing but his superspy character, so disconnected from the rest of the human race that he doesn't even realise his best friend is his best friend until the end, and doesn't even boff the movie's, tall, rigyd no-Bond-y Girl (Elizabeth Debicki). Debicki's English rose is married to a villanous Russian oligarch (Kenneth Branagh, aiming for menace but hitting growly-chunky) who is Antag to our heroic Protag. The narrative is all twisty-turny plot. It's no spoiler to say: once you know the forward-backward timeywimey premise (as we all do, now) you spot the twists a mile away.

Given all that, it's remarkable how much fun it is.

Tenet is not so much high concept as ‘huh?’ concept. Were I to start listing, spoilerishly, all the holes in plot & worldbuilding, why then we'd know how many holes it takes to fill the Albert Hall. Or a Kiev opera house. But you don't want the movie spoiled, so I won't. Not here. I may discuss a couple of the more egregious daftnesses in the comments: St Nemmoce (h/t) N.I. ses ‘sent fads uoiger’. Gee! Rome (h/t!) foe L. P. U. O'Cassuc (Sid). Yam? I ere (h/t!!) on't now, ios'd eliopse, I vom, eh, T T Nawt. Nod. U, oy! Tubes u ... oh a repo veik a rollah treblae htl lifot sekatt. I see! Lo! Hynam (woh!) wonk dew men mey H. W G Nidliubdl row & tolpni seloh, eh, t'l lay L.H.: Sir E Liops-Gnitsiltrat, sot, i.e. rewt (P. Ecnoch) ... uh: sat pecnoch G.I. hh cum ostonsi-tenet. Sit in (ufh ...) cum.

Wo!

Hel bakramers? Tit? aht! Llanevigy, awa' e lima St Siwte (h/t) tops u. Oy! wonodl—la—ew!—saes I, me (R. Pye) mewy emit draw k-cab (drawr of E.H.T. wonk). U! oy! ecno! yas ... O'Treil, ops on St Itolp.

Y? N? Rut ... y? 'ts I wtl la siev. It arrane (h/t Gator PC). I, or ehru, oot gat nasioh: wy? knuh cyl-worgg nittih tube-can EMR of gnimi, ah, ganarb h/t ennekh crag. I, lo! na is sursu on ally vaot dei rams, i.e. sorh silgnes ikci bed ikci bed the bazil ‘el rigyd no-Bond-y girl’, lat sei, vomeht f-fob nevet n' se odd nad, née H. T: Litnud neir f/t. Sebs ... I (Sidnei) raft. Sebs I, he, silaer ne vet'n se ode h/t a h/t e-car namu heh. T: Fotser (eh) t'morf de t'cennoc sidos ret-car ah! Cy (PS re puss ih tub). G-nih tons, I (not G-nih) saw diva. D. N. Hoj.  cire neg fly feeb at sin ogatorpe h/t salzir sa mehte sud luocu (oyy!) llaretil sesac emos nid-nag-nit i.r.w. fos m'ret ninih to Sera's ret car ‘ah'ceht’. Kool? Yeh. T? woh! tonts u jst ahts draw'r of gninnurs rot cae kil koolag .... nidli U-Bot nig nilb messaer el b-bur DNAs b'mobe koms gnid ‘’olp mih!’ Guorhts drawr of gninnur er'yeht e-kil (kool, yeh) tos des revere b-nac me gatoofe h/t (ta! ‘h/t’ ... h) cuss draw k-cab ‘G’ nin. Nurd em lifs rot caec neu qesel t-tab gniknol cat calan if stiny, l'ralucitra (PS: gard tig? no! L.) re. vostiog ‘... aevahll ...’ I, tubs, reli ops tu, oht, I w's sucsi dote. I vom'd. Rah! a stittol, a tidey OJ. Neien, es noner, up fodor ad nuo rad EP, parw no it musnoc suo ucip snocy? Er, I (an oil lib &g nab DNA moob fostol) peed. D. Neterp DNA'd, no B.S. Namroo. P.S.: u o ret?

So: perp DNA? suo it ne trope? I vom fodnik? Erp!

DNA ropa? Sí: Tenet.

Friday, 31 July 2020

John Updike, "The Poorhouse Fair" (1959), "Rabbit, Run" (1960)


I've spent the last howevermany months reading lots, and I mean lots, of new Fantasy novels, on account of me being one of the World Fantasy Judges this year. But now that we're into the horse-trading part of the process I decided to change-is-as-good-as-a-rest things, and reread, and in some cases read, some Updike. To that end I treated myself to the new Library of America edition of Updike's first four.

I hadn't previously read Updike's debut novel The Poorhouse Fair (1959). I now have and ... golly but it's bad. It's actively bad. It's actually very bad. The thing is: going straight from that to rereading Rabbit, Run (1960), I was struck by how good the second novel is, even better than I remember. I'm not sure I can think of another writer with such a precipitous step-up from bad first to extraordinary second novel, really. Can you?

Poorhouse Fair is, in a thin sort of way, science-fiction, set as it is in a near-future (1970s-ish) socialist America. There are glancing asides referencing this, but nothing so substantial as worldbuilding, and the actual paraphernalia of the tale is all solidly 1950s: old people at a state-run retirement facility, moping about and kvetching at the officious young administrator who rules them, Stephen Conner. It looks like their fair, at which the poorhouse's inhabitants sell food, trinkets and quilts to people from the local town, might have to be called off because of the weather. In the end, though, it goes ahead. The oldsters moan about various things: food, chairs, modern society, a diseased cat, an escaped parrot, how Conner isn't as good as the previous administrator, Mendelssohn. A delivery driver, backing his truck in through the poorhouse's narrow gateway, knocks part of the wall down. Various petty grievances come to a head at this, and a number of the old folk pick up some of these stones and chuck them at Conner, but in a pretty desultory way, and he's not badly hurt.

The book opens with old people grumbling because Conner has added name-tags to their porch chairs, to prevent them bickering over who sits where, a development they dislike. It ends with a long passage comprised of the various unattributed voices of visitors at the fair talking, decontextualised and juxtaposed so as to provide a train of jaw-jaw nonsequiturs. The unelected leader, or at least voice of moral authority in the home, is nonagenerian Joe Hook.  Joe talks a lot about God and Conner talks a lot about atheistical materialist utilitarianism and somewhere in the middle, Updike implies, with a certain hoofing obviousness, is the possibility of something J + C Christlike, something that could finally leave the Jewishly-named Mendelssohn behind. It is a possibility of redemption and forgiveness on which the novel never quite delivers. The interpretive superstructure the novel invites us to erect upon its base is, I'm afraid, as schematic and arid as this.

In fact there are two levels of badness here. One is that Updike is not yet quite in charge of his instrument. The book, though short, is dull, stilted, not so much badly paced as not paced at all. The characters are sketched-in, unmemorable and in some cases indistinguishable. The dialogue (generally handled pretty well in Updike's maturer novels) is here mannered and awkward. Hook speaks in a creaky old-time preacher idiom, his diction hyphenated to notate its slowness (‘we must bide our time, for any size-able mo-tion on our part will make Conner that much more in-secure’ [8] etc) like TikTok the Clockwork Man from Oz. Conner himself speaks in excerpts from an ongoing university lecture on humanism. Worse of all, Updike's descriptive prose, the jewel in his fully-formed writer's crown, here feels strained:
The river's apparent whiteness was dissolved in its evident transparency; the contours of bars of silt and industrial waste could easily be read beneath the gliding robe of water. A submerged bottle reflected sunlight. Occasionally, among the opaque fans of corrugation spread by each strand of shore growth, the heavy oblong of a catfish could be spied drifting. [5]
This passage can't make up its mind as to whether the water is ‘white’ (‘opaque’) or an ‘evident transparency’. ‘Gliding robe’ seems to me unconvincing (in what sense do robes glide, after all?) and ‘heavy oblong’ isn't quite on the nose as a description of a catfish. Worst of all is that underlying rhythm, a sort of pastiche blank-verse, as it might be:
A submerged bottle reflected sunlight.
Occasionally, among the opaque fans
Of corrugation spread by each strand of
Shore growth, the heavy oblong of a catfish
Could be spied, drifting.
... and so on. The odour of weak poetry in little magazines, here. Not, I think, a good thing.

To turn from this to the opening few pages of Rabbit Run is to breathe fresh air and brilliance. Here Harry Angstrom stopping by on his way home from work to watch some kids playing the game he used to play, as a kid (and at which he excelled: the only thing in his life of which he can say that):
Boys are playing basketball around a telephone pole with a backboard bolted to it. Legs, shouts. The scrape and snap of Keds on loose alley pebbles seems to catapult their voices high into the moist March air blue above the wires. Rabbit Angstrom, coming up the alley in a business suit, stops and watches, though he's twenty-six and six three. So tall, he seems an unlikely rabbit, but the breadth of white face, the pallor of his blue irises, and a nervous flutter under his brief nose as he stabs a cigarette into his mouth partially explain the nickname, which was given to him when he too was a boy. He stands there thinking, the kids keep coming, they keep crowding you up. ... There are six of them and one of him.

The ball, rocketing off the crotch of the rim, leaps over the heads of the six and lands at the feet of the one. He catches it on the short bounce with a quickness that startles them. As they stare hushed he sights squinting through blue clouds of weed smoke, a suddenly dark silhouette like a smokestack against the afternoon spring sky, setting his feet with care, wiggling the ball with nervousness in front of his chest, one widespread white hand on top of the ball and the other underneath, jiggling it patiently to get some adjustment in air itself. The cuticle moons on his fingernails are big. Then the ball seems to ride up the right lapel of his coat and comes off his shoulder as his knees dip down, and it appears the ball will miss because though he shot from an angle the ball is not going toward the backboard. It was not aimed there. It drops into the circle of the rim, whipping the net with a ladylike whisper. ‘Hey!’ he shouts in pride. ‘Luck,’ one of the kids says.
This is much more immediate and kinetic writing, sharp and lovely. The continuous present tense helps (perhaps more striking and obviously experimental in 1960 than it is today, when every third novel employs it) but also Updike manages to nail his Joycean staccato sometimes-verbless sentences to relevant and on-the-bounce detail. The quasi-poetic estrangements work better too, are better chosen: the crotch of the basketball hoop, the ladylike whisper of its net. It's not over-obvious, but neither is it far-fetched or baffling.

This is another, larger sense in which Poorhouse Fair fails, I think. It's a novel about America (that's fair enough, of course). But the way it tropes that country is as a decrepitude: a nation declining into the vale of years, with nothing but dusty-souled materialists and socialists to inherit its promise. This is, I'd say, just wrong. I mean, wrong as a way of characterising 1950s in the USA, aesthetically as much as anything. Nabokov's Lolita (published four years earlier in Paris, although not in the States until 1967) tropes America as a luscious nymphet, but that's an outsider's, a European's perspective. Updike in Rabbit, Run lights on something cleverer: America is not a 90-something godfearing old geezer, but neither is it an alluring teenager. It's an adult, but one who hasn't properly grown-up. America is, in other words, a superannuated adolescent, inhabiting a big and powerful body, and with considerable charm and sex appeal, but lacking self-discipline and commitment to duty. America is religious, but its religion is window-dressing for a libidinal fixation, a facile eroticisation of the sublime. America has energy and passion but no capacity for endurance or self-sacrifice. America, when push meets shove, will do a runner.

Updike conceived this novel as a twofer: Harry, the Rabbit, was one half of the American yin-yang; the nervy, pop-eyed, randy, make-a-break-for-it type. The other half is the centre of The Centaur (1963), Updike's next novel: a book about a head-down, get-on-with-it, dutiful stayer and worker called George Caldwell (based on Updike's own father), the carthorse as opposed to the rabbit. But of the two it was Rabbit endured, engendering four sequels. The Caldwell type slides out of Updikean view.

One reason for that might be adventitious: Updike decided, it seems on a mere whim, to style The Centaur as a Ulysses-type emulsion of mundane realism and Greek mythology, swapping with ungainly brio between finely written mimesis and awkwardly gauche hey-prithee classicism of gods and monsters, and that's a gimmick tiresome enough the first time, and impossible to imagine extending into multiple sequels. But another, more pressing reason is presumably that Updike just figured: hey, my nation really is more Rabbit than Centaur, an apperception that reflected variously Vietnam-era travails, 1970s-inflation, Reaganite flight from reality into cinematic nationalist fantasy and then Clinton, a very Rabbit-like character, I'd say; and not just because of his sexual incontinence. No prizes for guessing which way Rabbit would have voted in 2016.

With Rabbit, Run, though, all this is ahead of us. Rabbit starts by going home, taking a look at his wife Janice, pregnant with their second child in their poky apartment, realising he can't stand any of it and just going. A bravura 25-page episode sees him get in his car and just driving away, looping round through small-town east-coast America. This running-away is unplanned and directionless, so Harry eventually makes his way back to his home, in Brewer, Pennsylvania (not, though, before imparting to the reader a sense of the scale of America, its topography of endless tiny town and vast intervening spaces). He doesn't return to his wife, though; instead he stays with his old basketball coach, through him meeting Ruth, a single woman and part-time prostitute with whom later Harry moves in. His pastor tries to broker a reconciliation with Janice, but for much of the novel Rabbit stays with Ruth. There's lots of ecstatic sex, which, even more so than their running, is of course what rabbits are famous for. Though 1950s publishing wasn't ready to put out a novel entitled Rabbit, Fuck I suppose.

Having lost his original employment Rabbit gets a job as a rich widow's gardener. This in turn enables some descriptive prose that is, really, Updikery at its best:
In Mrs Smith's acres, crocuses break the crust. Daffodils and narcissi unpacked their trumpets. The reviving grass harbors violets, and the lawn is suddenly coarse with dandelions and broad-leaved weeds. Invisible rivulets running brokenly made the low land of the estate sing. The flowerbeds, bordered with bricks buried diagonally, are pierced by dull red spikes that will be peonies, and the earth itself, scumbled, stone-flecked, horny, raggedly patched with damp and dry, looks like the oldest and smells like the newest thing under Heaven. The shaggy golden suds of blooming forsythia grow through the smoke that fogs the garden while Rabbit burns rakings of crumpled stalks, perished grass, oak leaves shed in the dark privacy of winter, and rosebud prunings that cling together like infuriating ankle-clawing clumps. These brush piles, ignited soon after he arrives, crusty-eyed and tasting coffee, in the midst of the webs of dew, are still damply smoldering when he leaves, making ghosts in the night behind him as his footsteps crunch the spalls of the Smith driveway. All the way back to Brewer in the bus he smells the warm ashes. [242]
A leap from Poorhouse, this, with some lovely, spot-on word-choices (‘suds’!); and the novel is full of similar vividnesses. Playing golf, Harry's attention is taken by ‘the little ideal napkin of clipped green pinked with a pretty flag.’ He goes to the hospital to attend the birth of his baby daughter: it's a Catholic hospital, as many are in the States: ‘The hospital light is bright and blue and shadowless. “Angstrom,” he tells the nun behind the typewriter. “I think my wife is here.” Her plump washerwoman's face is rimmed like a cupcake with scalloped linen.’ [290].

Here Rabbit, leaving church, walks down the street with the pastor's attractive young wife, whom, he thinks, might have a crush on him (she doesn't, I think; but it's Rabbit's consciousness we're inside): ‘Sunshine quivers through the trees ... along unshaded sections of the pavement it leans down with a broad dry weight. Lucy pulls off her hat and shakes her hair; in the broad gaps of sun her face, his shirt, feel white, white; the rush of motors, the squeak of a tricycle, the touch of a cup and saucer inside a house are sounds conveyed to him as if along a bright steel bar. As they walk along he trembles in light that seems her light’ [328]. What makes this kind of deliberately vivified style different from the technically similar, differently focused other kind of vivified style for which Updike is famous, or infamous—I mean his baroquely cod-Keatsian descriptions of fucking and vaginas, the ‘Malfunctioning Sex Robot’ stuff Patricia Lockwood has so brilliantly critiqued—is that this stuff is clearer, actually, on the way an individual like Rabbit can only conceptualise religious transcendence in quasi-erotic terms. It's the ecstasy of Saint Theresa, but mundanified to middle-class 1950s America: the light, and the fuckable woman, yes, but also the clink of teacups as you sit down for a civilised chat with your Episcopalian pastor, or the kid's trinity-wheeled ride that signifies the family that fucking eventually entails. I know Updike sometimes takes flak for his trademark stylistic richness, and it can't be denied that this sometimes trespasses into a sticky over-egging (in U and I Nicholson Baker parodies it without mercy: ‘the blank seemed, in its blankety blankness, and blanketed blinkness, almost blonky in the late afternoon blonk’). But when it works it really works, and most of it works gorgeously here. It is a mode of excess, stylistically speaking, it's true; and sometimes that excess slides into a kind of egregious excessiveness, an excessiveness for the sake of excessiveness. But it's also a mode designed to respond to a perception of the beauties of existence as themselves excessive, as the world itself loading its every rift with ore, and there's something marvellous about that.

It's not all good, Rabbit, Run, mind. Fluent and compelling though most of it is, parts of this novel are raggeder. Instead of sticking with the main character's p.o.v. Updike occasionally shifts focus to interiorised passages from Ruth's or Janice's perspective, or even from Jack Eccles's, the pastor's; these step-aways are jolting and more distracting than enriching. It's important to Updike's purposes that young Rabbit, for all his various delinquencies, be likeable, since young Rabbit is ‘America’, young and randy and not very forward-thinking but, you know: fun, nice, life, youth, beautiful. He's not, though. Likeable, I mean. He's a kind of monster of cock-prompted ego and thoughtlessness, which means Updike has to keep prodding the reader with passages like this:
“Oh all the world loves you,” Ruth says suddenly. “What I wonder if why?”

“I'm lovable,” he says.

“I mean why the hell you. What's so special about you?”

“I'm a saint,” he says. “I give people faith.” Eccles has told him this Once, with a laugh, probably meaning it sarcastically. Rabbit took it to heart. He never would have thought of it himself. He doesn't think that much about what he gives other people. [249]
This doesn't quite carry, though. We don't, I think, love Rabbit as much as Updike loves Rabbit; just as we're entitled to respond to Updike's famous description of his homeland as a conspiracy to make you happy with ... depends on the you, though, homeboy, don't you think?

There's something a bit blooey about the ending, too. The denouement is plotted around Rabbit leaving the woman he left his wife for, Ruth. He goes back to Janice because she's given birth to their daughter; and having gone back can't retrace his steps to Ruth. One reason for this is, knowing that (as a former prostitute) Ruth often performed oral sex on men, Rabbit insists he gets a blow-job too. This somehow ruins their relationship, and Updike, not normally coy about sexual matters, doesn't really explain why. The act sort-of floats around the latter portions of the novel as though it's somehow obviously a dreadful and appalling and humiliating thing. The other thing that happens in the last stretch of the novel is that Janice, always a bit of a boozer, gets drunk, decides to give her new baby a bath and accidentally drowns her. This is properly dreadful, a heart-sinking scene that does not stint on the ghastly, ghastly consequences: the intensity of the grief that follows, for both Janice and Rabbit. The book ends on the baby's funeral, which finally gets too much for Rabbit, such that (in a deliberate echo of the opening) he runs out. But powerfully written as this scene is, it seems to me to entail two problems. One is the bathos, edging ludicrousness, of pairing it with Harry's Improbably Consequential Blow-Job. The other is more enduring: Updike ends the book this way because it is the one thing from which we cannot run. Not our own mortality, which is what, we might intuit, sets all of us running in the first place, but the death of a loved-one, especially the death of your child. Rabbit's tear-blinded dash out of the cemetery at the end isn't going anywhere; he has finally encountered That Which Cannot Be Run From. Except ...

... except that I know, as someone who has read all the subsequent Rabbit books, that Updike decides by authorial fiat that ... he can. Janice suffers no legal sanction for what is, surely, culpable homicide (she's as guilty as, let's say, a drunk driver would be if they killed someone). She would surely go to jail for a term, she would likely be shunned by her neighbours. But more credulity-strenuous still, she and her husband suffer no longer-term emotional consequences. This death is mentioned only occasionally and in passing in the later novels; it's just something the two of them step past. Worse, Rabbit has resumed his lepus-mode. He's still evading responsibility, still running. It's a kind of novelistic infidelity to the emotional gravity of the last chapters of Rabbit, Run, and, actually, hard to forgive.

Then again, that's in the future: in Rabbit Redux (1971), Rabbit is Rich (1981) and Rabbit at Rest (1990), not to mention the 2001 novella Rabbit Remembered. Rabbit, Run's continuous present licenses us to ignore that looming futurity, and to enjoy this novel of fall, and the possibility of redemptive grace.

Sunday, 19 July 2020

"Ad Astra" (dir James Gray, 2019)


I'm pretty thoroughly committed to the idea (you'd expect someone who writes science fiction to say so) that metaphor can be more eloquent than mimesis, fantastical extrapolation more penetrating than drab realist recitation. Still, there are times I wonder. So, to pick an example: let's say you want to tell a story about an emotionally-repressed adult man coming to terms with his distant and abscondant father. Is the best way to do that a story in which the father has removed himself to the planet Neptune from where he beams gigantic beams of mysterious destructive energy back at the Earth? Might that strategy run the risk of coming across as a bit ... silly?

So, yes, I'm honestly not sure what to make of Ad Astra. It's a very handsomely mounted piece of film-making, and contains a great many striking and even beautiful visual images. It's also daft raised to the power of daft. The increasingly muppet-faced Brad Pitt (‘Brad Astra’) falls off a Babel-tall tower and parachutes to Earth. It's unclear to me what this has to do with the rest of the movie. Brad had thought his father dead these thirty years, but now he discovers Dad is still alive, albeit alive, as Tim Curry might say .... in spa-a-a-ace! So Brad flies to the moon, aboard a conventional chemical rocket replete with various old-fashioned, Apollo-era stylings (‘Trad Astra’). He travels round to the dark-side of the moon in a swanky subterranean metro-tunnel (‘Mind-the-Gapstra’) but this tunnel, unaccountably, stops before it reaches the dark-side spaceport, which means Brad must essay a risky drive across the lunar surface for the last bit of his journey, which in turn tangles him in a vacuum-desert car-chase fleeing lunar pirates (‘Mad-Maxtra’). Surviving this, he rockets off towards Mars stopping on the way to battle some feral space-monkeys (I'm torn here between ‘Ad Astr-ape’ and ‘Ad Macaquestra’).

On Mars Brad beams messages to his father from a subterranean Martian recording studio (‘Dad Astra’—why did he have to go all the way to Mars to do this? One of the exposition side-characters earlier said something about this being the only such facility left after the ravages of the Death Beams From Neptune, which strains credulity somewhat. What, every single set-up capable of beaming a radio signal had been destroyed on Earth? Even though it's further from the Magic Beams of Destruct-o than Mars? How do all the pilots on the various space-ships communicate with base etc?). Anyway: after recording this message the powers that be relieve him of all duties (‘Ad Sacked-stra’), but he decides to go visit his Dad in person anyway, which he can only do by stowing away on a spaceship that's headed that way, afterwards inadvertently killing its three-person crew (‘Ad Slaughta’). On arriving at Neptune he discovers his father has gone insane, Kurtz-in-Heart-of-Darkness-style, and slaughtered his crew (‘Mad Astra’). This discovery grieves Brad P., although the whole movie is so dominated by his dolorous mope it's a little hard to tell (‘Sad Astra’). All in all it is, I am sorry to say, Bad Astra.

Rather than lean into the pulp daftness of the plotting, Gray forces his movie in quite the opposite direction, with many Terence Malick-esque ponderous and grave voice-overs, long lingering pans and zooms, lots of smell-the-fart acting from Pitt in close-up and much mood-work with stark colour palates: yellow, grey, green, red and finally a deep cyan blue. It is, as I say, very often beautiful to look at, and the special effects are impressive throughout. But though it aims visually for the grace and profundity of 2001: a Space Opera crossed with Apocalypse Now, it is consistently undercut by a plot that is more Saturn 3 crossed with It's A Mad Mad Mad Mad World. Per ardua ad astra, sure; but this movie is perhaps too much arduousness and too little asterism. Plus nobody in the movie actually reaches any stars, and the obsession that drove Dad mad, to find alien life, is revealed to have been fruitless all along. Subtract Astra.

Maybe I'll watch it again. Maybe it's better second time round.