Friday, 10 July 2020
"Frozen 2" (dir. Chris Buck and Jennifer Lee, 2019)
Frozen (2013) was fun, wasn't it? I mean, it was an oddly broken-backed piece of storytelling that sacrificed larger satisfactions of structure and narrative for a barely logical ‘aha!’ gotcha story-twist, and it was extraordinarily White—the Whitest Disney since Tangled, and that film's all-Aryan cast of Rapunzelly goodies, its fetishization of blonde hair and its witchy Jewess villain (all, I'm sure, both fine and dandy. It's not as if resurgent Nazi ideology or anti-Semitism are still real-life political issues nowadays, after all). Then again, the Nordic racial purity of Frozen was at least leavened by a Christina-Rossetti-y sisters-don't-need-men agendum it was easy to like. The movie also had some nicely-judged humour, and, most of all, it had a raft of absolutely sterling songs. People will be karaoke-ing ‘Let It Go’ for a very long time, no question. It cost Disney $150 million to make and it earned them $1.3 billion, which is a quantity of beans that guarantees a sequel.
So here's Frozen 2, whose makers have thought long if not hard about how to build on so financially-fecund a base. What they've opted for is, mostly, more-of-the-same: artfully-rendered Scandinavian landscapes, sisters doing it for themselves, ice-magic and Olaf goofing about. They've also decided, narratively speaking, to carry forward Frozen's daft aha! reveal, in which the man you thought was good turns out, in an undermotivated and arbitrary way, to be evil (in this case, it's the handsome grandfather rather than the handsome fiancé, but same difference).
The snow-Whiteness of the first film has been addressed by making the sequel a story of our Nordic heroines making friends with a kind-of Sámi population of folk trapped in a magical forest up north. So there's your ethnic diversity. Although, like flower-arrangers stepping back from what they've done and deciding it's not quite there yet, the film-makers have also added an extra, token character: Matthias, the heroic Captain of the Arendellean Guards and a man of African heritage. Happy now? To be fair, they've also made the through-line of the story about recovering the buried truth of colonial oppression. You see: back in the backstory, King Runeard of Arendelle, all smiles, brokered a treaty with the indigenous folk of Northuldra, building a mighty dam in their homeland as a goodwill gesture. But Runeard is actually evil. The point of the dam was to block the Northuldra's waters which would, in some manner that remained obscure to me, cause them harm, because Runeard hated them and wished to subject them to his rule.
The dam seems to me an awfully roundabout way of doing this, I must say. The more usual Colonisation strategy, surely, is: march your army in and kill lots of people. And, indeed, Runeard does then provoke a fight with the Northuldrans in order to justify his armed response, something which hardly needed a pretext. I suppose, actually, that the dam is there as a rebus not for colonisation as such so much as for the skein-thin justifications colonising nations bring forward: ‘yes we stole all your wealth and killed many of your people, but we did at least build some infrastructure, look.’
Nonetheless it's hard to see what the notional justification for a dam might be, in terms of the movie's worldbuilding. It's certainly not there to generate hydroelectric power, since the street- and houselights in Arendelle are powered not by electricity, nor even gas, but by elemental sprites of fire. We know this because, angered by the dam, the Four magical Elements of Fire, Water, Earth and Air manifest their displeasure by withdrawing from the human world, respectively: turning off the city lights; trapping everyone in the Enchanted Forest with a wall of impenetrable mist; shaking the paving stones of Arendelle's streets such that everyone has to evacuate the city; and—eh—withdrawing all air? such that the resulting vacuum, uh, asphixiates the entire cast? Is it?
Not that last one, obviously.
The ‘four elements’ archaism of the Frozen universe is on a par with the trademark inverted-Phlogiston physics of Elsa's ice-magic; so it ought not to have surprised me that the story in Frozen 2 would be moved-along by naked homeopathy. But here we are: surprised I was. Water, we are told not once but several times, possesses a magical memory, and Elsa's ice-sculpture actualise the hidden history of her grandfather's badness. It's deemed the damn dam must be dismantled even though the resulting downwash will destroy dainty Arendelle. Which is to say, the historical realities of imperialism stifled by official narratives of spreading missionary civilisation, must be undammed in today's discourse, even though the resulting downwash will engulf narratives of White exceptionalism. That seems clear enough, commendable even, although the story's denouement actually pulls this punch, with Elsa riding a magic horse made of water down the downwash and magicking away the destructive consequences of Arendelle's historic actions. It's a kind of Black Lives Matter But Only Insofar As White Lives Avoid Karma kind of deal I suppose.
Otherwise the plotting is rather arbitrarily episodic and unsatisfying. Characters are killed off only to be brought back again by scriptwriter's fiat. The humour more often than not misfires, the new characters are wire-frames rather than fully-realised figures, and the songs aren't nearly so good as the first film's. The one exception to this is ‘Into The Unknown’, another Idina Menzel belter that attempts to catch ‘Let It Go’s lightning in a second bottle. It doesn't manage this, quite, hamstrung as it is by its belatedness. Still, I can't deny it's a pretty stirring piece of songwriting: Norwegian singer Aurora's minor-key oo-oo-ing works hauntingly in the background as Menzel slams out another full-throated paean to .. what? Well, looking at the lyrics you'd have to assume: the yearning of an only-outwardly-happy suburban housewife tempted by a thrilling extra-marital affair. I mean, the song kind-of fits the logic of Frozen 2's story, that Elsa is chafeing at the comfort of living in Arendelle and longs to explore the unexplored north. Kind of. But, really, its heart-thudding yearning makes more sense in a sexual context, I'd say.
Anyway, here we are: a movie that blends precisely calibrated quanta of sameitude, new-in-a-familiar-way and minimal self-criticism to produce, I thought, a dud.
Dud, did I say? Oh no. It seems I am very wrong. Like Frozen, Frozen 2 cost about $150 million to make, but it has already, despite the latter end of its cinema run being curtailed by Lockdown, earned more than its predecessor. People love it. Ah well.
Saturday, 4 July 2020
M. John Harrison, "The Sunken Land Begins to Rise Again" (2020)
It's not every novel that has a metrically flawless iambic pentameter for its title. Indeed it's not, we can be honest, every writer who could carry-off that kind of thing, without (that is) tripping our pretentiousness alarms. But Harrison is not every writer. Harrison is a law unto himself, and The Sunken Land Begins to Rise Again is a novel so good all the usual reviewerish superlatives barely seem superlative enough.
Half of the novel is set in a run-down bit of West London (down near the river, Teddington-way: East Sheen, Barnes Bridge, that neck of the woods. I lived for a time in Wandsworth, then Putney, and then moved to Staines; I know the area in-between pretty well, and MJH gets it absolutely spot-on). The other half is set in west England, near the Welsh border overlooking the Severn. In the former location lives one of the novel’s deuteragonists: Shaw, a fiftysomething single man, recovering, or not really recovering, from some kind of mid-life breakdown. He rents a scuzzy little room in a house ‘south and west of Hammersmith bridge’ and works for a strange fellow called Tim he met in a pub one time. Tim runs a odd mini-company out of a run-down barge on the river, from where he sends Shaw off on various puzzling errands, sometimes delivering peculiar packages of things or collecting other things, visiting and filming a medium (who turns out to be Tim’s sister) or attending the trial of an old man who caused a breach of the peace after, he claims, seeing strange green aquatic creatures germinating in toilet bowls.
Shaw has an on-off relationship with Victoria, who sometimes stays over in his shonky rented room but spends most of the novel in the west country where her mother had gone to live, and where she died. This is Bristol [or maybe not; see comments below], although Harrison never names the town. Victoria has inherited her Mum’s house and she spends many weeks doing it up, mending the roof, replacing the electrics and so on. During this time she befriends (although friendship in the usual sense of the word is really not the currency of their relationship) a waitress at a nearby café called Pearl. Renovating her mum’s house also introduces her to various elderly local workmen, odd, rheumy old geezers to a man. Pearl claims to have been close to Victoria’s mother—the two went swimming together, she says, in local pools and rivers—but the woman Pearl describes sounds nothing at all like the mother Victoria knew. Various things, baffling, menacing, are hinted at without quite being spelled-out.
All this depends upon, works or doesn't, according to how effectively the novel is able to maintain its particular mood: an eeriness or uncanniness that persists without collapsing into either sheer bafflement or else into the crassness of formulaic weird or oddball gubbins. The Sunken Land Begins to Rise Again manages this balancing act perfectly. The dialogue is full of non-sequiturs, people talking apparently at cross-purpose. With a different writer this could become a gimmick, and irksome, but Harrison manages it flawlessly. The characters are opaque only after the manner that real people in the real word are opaque. Sentence after perfectly-pitched sentence describes urban decay, the kipple of early 21st-century life, strange non-spaces and, always, water: it’s always raining, or flooding, the land is always sodden, something is always bubbling up from underneath.
Victoria crossed the river and walked further than she had expected. She had packed no lunch. Later, half a mile down the hillside in fine blowing rain she thought she saw a woman walking ahead of her, making her way quickly between dark, glossy rhododendrons towards a house at the edge of fields. She was wearing a flower print and high heels. White gloves. By the time Victoria got there she had vanished inside, if she had ever been there at all. The grey four-square walls were home to yellow lichens. Coughing could be heard from an upper room. The small, sodden garden featured: one child’s swing, an empty pond, a fire pit full of charred beer cans and M&S prosecco bottles. Over in one corner rotting apples were strewn beneath a well-grown holly. [113]This is just out-of-kilter enough (high heels worn to walk across the fields; a holly tree apparently shedding apples) to add bite to its phantasmic air of incompleteness.
It’s quite the trick, technically, to balance so much closely observed, almost hyper-realist specificity of description against such a sustained atmosphere of haunting uncertainty. Real places, realistically-evoked people, a bedrock of unnerving unreality. There’s a Sebaldian vibe to much of this (more Sebald than Ballard, I think) although of course MJH was doing this kind of thing before WGS ever put out a book.
Something is going on, although I won’t spoil what, here. The workman renovating Victoria’s house keep offering her copies of Kingsley’s Water Babies. The novel’s title is taken from Kingsley’s Thoughts in a Gravel Pit (prose, despite the title’s metrical regularity). Lewis Carroll hovers behind much of the unheimlich-ness too: the pond where Pearl likes to swim is called ‘the pool of tears’, and Victoria’s queenly name speaks to some incomprehensible game of existential-chess game going on somewhere, outwith the ken of the two main characters. The Kingsley and Carroll intertexts were both catnip to me, I must say; cleverly and unobtrusively woven throughout, delightful to a specialist in Victorian literature. Though of course you'd expect what Harrison does with Water Babies’s Darwinian allegory of Christian redemption to be rather more Quatermassian than it is Kingsleyan. Soon after arriving in Bristol, Victoria is wandering about, looking for Marks and Sparks. She climbs the old packhorse stair off the main street, where ‘the rock was poisoned with oxides, thick with cobwebs’, to where ‘she could see the backs of the houses and shops on the high street’:
Suddenly warm soapy water poured down the stairs, around her feet and away, only three inches deep but strong and turbulent, with foam … It had a smell she couldn’t account for, faint and chemical, perhaps some kind of cleaning fluid. The object that washed down with it, slithering then sticking to the cobbles, then slithering again, was translucent and tinged faintly with green; otherwise it looked like a still-born kitten.This object with its ‘foetal look’ (‘it wasn’t a mammal, perhaps not even a fish’) makes her shudder. ‘“How horrible,” she said aloud, looking up at the sky again.’ When she returns later in the day it has gone.
Victoria put her hand over her mouth.
‘Well I don’t know!’ she heard someone shout from a window high in the backs of the buildings. [55]
***
The Sunken Land Begins to Rise Again is a Brexit novel, I think; an oblique state-of-the-nation book, and extremely penetrating as such. The Severn is described as a river flowing towards the sea with a counterflow running through its depth. Late in the novel the café has been changed into ‘Shropshire Fish Supplies’ and filled with aquaria. Peering through the glass, Victoria sees how each tank contains a model drowned village or landscape. One includes a miniature waterfall. ‘Victoria pointed. “That waterfall?” she said. “It’s made of plastic. Doesn’t it give you such an uncomfortable feeling? Water flowing under water?” She felt herself shiver.’ What was it David Byrne sang, contorting himself in his cheap revivalist-preacher suit and tie?
Water dissolving and water removing... going on to hoot echoingly on the next word of the song's lyric ‘remove’. And you may find yourself. Like I said: it’s catnip to me, all this.
There is water at the bottom of the ocean
Under the water, carry the water …
It’s also a novel about writing, although not in any self-regarding way. None of the characters are writers, although Tim runs a Fortean-style blog called The Water House reporting unusual events all around the country. But from Shropshire Victoria writes regular emails back to Shaw, who only reads them intermittently, and who never replies. This sense of the writerly disconnection, of putting words out there and having no idea whether anyone is connecting with them, understanding them, even registering that they exist—that’s, certainly not catnip, but intensely relatable to me, as a writer. Shaw is sent to Wolverhampton by Tim on yet another puzzling errand. On the train he can’t help but hear ‘a couple talking in the seat behind his.’
With a little inadvertent sigh of pleasure the woman said, “There must be some meaning to these clouds.”Where, indeed, is Michael? A treacherous business, the attempt to locate the author in his own book, not any less treacherous if undertaken by the author himself. Those potentially meaningful, Hamletian clouds lead us, I think deliberately, back to the life aquatic. You see, don’t you, yonder cloud that’s almost in shape of a camel? By the mass, and it is like a camel, indeed. I think it is like a weasel. It is backed like a weasel. Or like a whale? Very like a whale. Something watery in the idiom and medium. Something watery in existence, when you hit a certain age, and life has eroded the solider sureties. Something big and far below the surface, something oceanic, rising up. Deep waters, here.
They were complex, layered, torn about by winds, bathed in a dull metallic light; but the man next to her wasn’t interested. “Where’s Michael? Where’s Michael?” he kept saying into his phone, his voice too quiet and too close to Shaw’s ear to be comfortable. “Don’t forget now. Don’t forget!” All with a kind of hidden urgency, as if fearing surveillance—“Where’s Michael?” [162]
Wednesday, 15 April 2020
Paul McAuley, "War of the Maps" (2020)
The blog tends, not by design so much as the sheer cumulative pressure of stuff—what we might call the sum of a remainder of an unbalanced equation inherent to the world of commercial SFF programming, vis-à-vis ‘good versus mediocre’—to the Negative Review. This, I know. More: I’m reading a dumpertruckful of fantasy as the moment and there’s a danger that this blog will sag into a swampy, snarky monotony as a result. So let’s break that monotony. Let's talk about a novel I read recently I really rate.
I am, I should say before going further, a hard-core McAuley fan. Part of that is, I think, a simple admiration for his technical skill as a writer: he has a marvellous sfnal imagination, writes very good prose (his default style is deceptively unshowy, but it packs a significant amount of artistry and evocative sleight into its hand), structures his stories well—never too rushed or over-busy, rarely too slow—and sketches character deftly and compellingly. But part of it, as with any writer a reader really groks, is personal. I happen to like very much the way McAuley blends aspects of SF pulp melodrama with what (for want of a better phrase) I’d call a literary sensibility. He articulates certain recurring fascinations, and in some cases recurring images, that happen to really resonate with me, for who-knows-what reason: dogged plodders and Odinic antagonists, secret sharers, strange biologies, iterations of loss and withdrawal, particular refractions of London and some other, I think closely related, refractions of fairyland (some of these latter surprisingly austere). Art is sometimes highly personal like this, and that’s fine. What lands with me may not with you. It might be interesting to try and pin it down a little more precisely—interesting for me, I mean—but then again I’m not sure I do want to murder to dissect, actually. We’ll see. Where we are at the moment is that he’s one of those authors (it’s a smaller list, for me, than you might think) whose work I buy automatically, all of it, as soon as it comes out.
Which brings me to War of the Maps (2020). This is a Big Dumb Object novel that is, I presume by design, (a) relatively lean (400 pages or so), (b) smart rather than dumb, and (c) much more about subjectivity than objectivity. The BDO here is an unusual Dyson sphere built around our sun but in the far future after sol has become a white dwarf. The sphere is constructed at that radius where the sun’s gravity pulls 1g on the outside surface of the structure, and here, illuminated not directly but by networks of orbiting mirrors, is where the characters live. It’s a vast topography, of course, although mostly given over to a ‘world ocean’ in which continent-sized (and smaller) islands, known as ‘maps’, are located. The ‘maps’ terminology is also used to refer to the inhabitants' various gene-lines, which some of the inhabitants of this BDO are skilled at editing. Anyway: the original, godlike builders of this world have long since abandoned it, and its myriad ordinary inhabitants are living with a series of mundial delapidations, not the least of which is a kind of quatermassian ‘red plague’, a ‘tailchaser virus’ that rewrites biological forms in monstrous and spreading new forms. The story is hung on a central thread: a lawman, known as the lucidor, has come out of retirement to track a dangerous criminal—another of McAuley’s charismatically deranged geneticist wizards, this one called Remfrey He—through foreign lands. The first two thirds of the story or so follow the peripatetic, episodic adventures of the lucidor; the last third brings the story to its denouement at the (extraterrestrial, or extradysonic) source of the plague.
Like many major artists, McAuley returns over and again with a kind of creative obsession to certain types, or tropes, or images. His bibliography is divided broadly between far-future space opera, and now-or-near-future-thrillers, with the occasional alt-historical or environmental standalone dropped in (he’s also written a few non-sf thrillers and procedurals). War of the Maps revisits his Confluence trilogy: not in the sense that it’s set in the same world—it’s not—but very much in terms of vibe and focus. This is not a criticism. I consider the Confluence books, taken as a whole, one of the very best works of 1990s SF. Confluence is a trilogy, and so, in its briefer compass, is War of the Maps: it’s three parts are, respectively, a sort-of Western, a war story and a weird sea-story Treasure Island retread, into which is mixed, as I noted earlier, a Conradian Secret Sharer narrative.
The lucidor tracks across this strange world and has various adventures. Some readers might find the pace over-leisurely, but I think it’s right, since it gives the Les-Misérables-from-the-cop’s-POV narrative just the right amount of time to accrue the needful momentum for the ending to punch its weight. McAuley is an old hand when it comes to providing his reader with artfully suggestive glimpses of his larger world, and some of these were definite highlights. Not that it all comes off, I think. Inhabitants of these maps have various, if mild, X-Men-mutation-esque powers (Remfrey He, for instance, has the ‘silvertongue’ power of rhetorical persuasion; the Lucidor’s power is also an X-Men staple, the power to damp-down other characters’ powers) but this aspect of the story isn’t entirely developed or integrated into the larger whole. The huge ‘alter nests’, filled with plague-mutated humans living ant-like lives shorn of higher brain functions, make for some striking and memorable biogothic set-pieces, but there are also quite a lot of sub-James-Herbert giant crabs, which spooked me rather less. And although the slower pacing here didn’t bother me, it’s not always easy to hold a radically episodic plot in a larger shape. More, there seemed to me something slightly, well, blurred about the representation of the lucidor himself. He’s an older man, a widower, determined and dogged, and that determination and refusal to give up not only powers the plot but drives the denouement—well done, I'd say. Sometimes the novel has him as a kind of Clint Eastwood, or perhaps more a Mike from Better Call Saul, figure, which works fine. But sometimes he is a rather different, less outward character: more a figuration of grief as such, somebody internally locked down, often affectless except for his one driving shard of determination to go onward (man, to quote Thom Gunn, you gotta go). This, I think, is better, and not entirely miscible with the elderly action hero version of the character.
And if I had to call it, that’s what I’d say War of the Maps is really about. McAuley has been eloquent about grief in several of his earlier novels; he can write that condition from the inside out, and do so expressively, movingly, never over-playing it. It seems to me, for all that his novels often contain whizz bang outward-urge space operatics, that McAuley's peculiar genius is for loss: an affinity for that which is passing, a sunt lacrymae rerum particularity. His real interest sits, I think, in a strange lagrange point between a fascination (evident in his life as an academic biologist) with the bursting fecundity of life, and a fascination with entropy, actual and metaphorical. In that sense War of the Maps does have a different centre of gravity to Confluence: that earlier, and I think greater, novel is about things flowing together; this new one is about things falling apart, the centre struggling to hold, and the anarchy of losing that which matters most being loosed upon the world. It’s about the edges of maps, about here-be-monster liminalities as a trope for being old and alone and facing the end. It’s a fine, powerful novel and easily the best thing I’ve read in 2020. So far.
Wednesday, 8 April 2020
Maria Lewis, "The Wailing Woman" (2019)
The fourth in a series, this: ancient societies of werewolves, witches, vampires, demons etc cohabit secretly with regular humans in contemporary Australia, a sort of What We Do In The Shad-Oz, though, obviously, not as funny. I haven't read the first three, and so cannot comment on their quality (they might be Tolstoy for all I know); but I have read the fourth, which concerns banshees. The screaming of these folk causes destruction and death, and so they were all transported from Ireland to Oz long ago: ‘they came on six prison ships, fifteen hundred women … they were brought out thin, pale, smelling like piss and shit. Some of them were wearing a Scold’s bridle’ [53]—the latter detail to prevent them doing their terrifying and fatal scream, you see. The descendants of these women now constitute a kind of Untouchable caste in modern Oz, working with the dead in funeral homes and cleaning-up blood-soaked crime scenes and so on, since it is with the dead they have their magical affinity.
There's a precipitously steep hierarchy in magical society, and banshees are low down, though not so low as vampires (‘loathed, nasty cat-like creatures ... they were considered below ghouls, which were part of a lower tier of supernatural creature that didn't have any kind of cognitive behaviour or quantifiable intelligence’). Anyway, our heroine Sadie has her throat mangled as a girl to stifle her banshee shriek; but when she is grown-up she falls in love with the sexy son of the man who undertook that mangling, a geezer called, with some improbability, ‘Texas Contos’. Their true-love-not-running-smooth narrative involves much running around, secret-uncovering, some gore and ick, and a quantity of jovial, sweary, matey bantz. This latter is the novel's default, really.
As fable, this novel is saying something about the subaltern voice: about the many Celts pitilessly banished by Anglo imperial power centuries back who have now made their own antipodean realm in Sydney and like cities (‘fuck you, England!’). It's also, clearly about gender, and is amongst other things a story about the patriarchal desire to silence women, to impose procrustean standards of behaviour upon them, and accordingly of the elation channelled by women refusing to collaborate with that mode of oppression (‘fuck you, men!’). As Lewis announces in her afterword, utilising here as throughout the book her rather haphazard vernacular: ‘thank you to all the IRL wailing women out there, the otherworld sisters and what not. This book is supposed to be about finding your voice and using it, so hopefully that's what you take away from it.’ Fair enough, and what not. Commendable, even. But my hesitant male voice burbles on nonetheless, in a manner that inescapably indexes patriarchy, of course, and can accordingly be discounted.
The truth is my cliché-geiger-counter continually sputtered and fizzed as I read this novel, as eyes ‘lit up’, as events ‘took her breath away’, as they saw one another ‘in the flesh’ and were ‘proud as punch’, as ‘her blood ran cold’ and so on. Indeed so much was this a case of and so on that my cliché-geiger-counter blew its fuse somewhere around page 100 (‘Sadie hated silence: she loathed it with every fibre of her being’ [107] may have been the final straw).
My problem is presumably mine alone: but cliché means stereotype, and stereotyping is precisely the problem with sexism, as with racism and other such prejudices in which human specificity is overwritten and human individual potential shut-down in favour of a caricature and generalised stock-image, a collective negative cartoonification. This is a novel with its heart in the right place, no question. The thing is: novels are not made out of heart. Novels are not made out of feelings, or vibes, or righteousness, or bantz, or even out of stories or characters or imagined worlds. Novels are made out of words. If we wish to challenge the bigotry of stereotype in such a medium, surely we need to work as hard as is necessary to avoid stereotype when we put those words together? Make war on cliché on the level of style and form, as well as on the level of content? No?
No? Well alright then.
The consensus does run the other way nowadays, I suppose. Not only do readers (who, as you can see on Goodreads, adore this novel) not mind cliché, they actively embrace it. Much of the appeal of this book, I'd guess, is its vibe: of having fun with your mates, danger and love and excitement: Sadie's sisters and friends, and of course the adoring Tex, whose physiological reaction to arousal is almost as improbable as his name (‘he gripped the fabric of her dress, his pulse racing so fast he worried his Adam's apple would burst out of his throat’ [209]). The gang are here to ground the protagonist's adventures (which is to say the p.o.v. character's—which is to say, our—adventures) in a mileu of supportive camaraderie, and the thing with friends is that they are familiar, that we're comfortable with them, they are the relationship correlative of cliché.
Perhaps readers don't want a style that ‘gets in the way of’ the things they hope to extract from their book-reading experience. Maybe there's an Oz aspect to this too (though I run the risk here myself of stereotyping, I know) that prefers straight-talking, even if it errs on the side of the stale, to fancy-pants up-yourself pretentiousness. That values a common touch over fine writing. Either way we're talking about an attitude that sees the actual stuff of novels, words cast into sentences, sentences assembled into blocks of text, as impediments to the story and the character and the Feels, rather than seeing the story (and the feels) as radically shaped by the particularities of the words the author chooses. I daresay I'm the one out of kilter on this. I should lighten up. I wouldn't want to get so worked up that my adam's-apple bursts out of my throat, certainly.
Saturday, 28 March 2020
The Swearin Swearer's Swearin Sweared
Swearing is like jeans. Once, either historically-actually or else (more likely) in some mythic fiction of the past we like collectively to buy into, adults spoke with formal propriety and decency and it was young rebels and tearaways who swore. Now, if anything, it’s the other way around. Similarly, jeans used to be the kind of trousers young rock-n-rollers and noncomformists wore to show that they weren’t Slaves To The Man (who, naturally, Wore ‘Proper’ Trousers), whereas jeans are now worn by middle-aged fogeys like Jeremy Clarkson or Tony Blair or, er, me, and young people sheathe their legs in fancier, better-tailored strides. That’s fine of course. Wear what you like, I’m not the boss of you. My point is the obvious one: an odour of desperation clings to the middle-aged man who thinks it makes him cool to swear, or wear jeans, or play the guitar. The desire to be ‘down with the kids’ is undignified enough; the notion that one can insinuate oneself with those down-there kids by adopting styles, sartorial and linguistic, that they themselves regard as lame, old-people gubbins is just sad.
I’m not saying younger kids don’t swear. Of course they do. My hunch is they don’t swear as much, or with the same particularities, as middle-aged folk, but the coronavirus prevents me from doing the extensive sociolinguistic research needful to evidence such a hypothesis. I'm saying that middle-aged people swearing because they think it makes them appear edgy, sassy, unconventional—because they think it frees them from the shackles of middle-age—are Steve Buscemi in a “MUSIC ‖ BAND” T-shirt saying ‘how do you do fellow kids?’
Or perhaps that’s just me. I swear quite a lot, it’s true. I fear I’ve internalised the idea that swearing is big and clever—although I’ve also, I have to say, internalised some quite significant taboos about swearing: I rarely if ever say ‘cunt’ for instance, although it’s acquired ‘fuck’-like levels of ubiquity with many people I know (it still strikes me as misogynistic, in the same ballpark as ‘bitch’). My eighteen-year-old daughter swears little, certainly around her parents, but I think with her peers too, whose interactions I sometimes (inadvertently of course) overhear, in real-life or via snapchat or otherwise. If I had to guess I’d assume that once swearing becomes something middle-aged-people do openly it becomes, a fortiori, something young people want to avoid doing, so as to keep that vital clear blue water between them and us. Quite right too.
Melissa Mohr’s Holy Shit: A Brief History of Swearing (Oxford 2013) sketches two main semantic fields where swearing is concerned, one derived (as it were) from above and one from below. The former, linked to serious business of swearing oaths and so on, derives its taboo words, the expression of which releases the pent-up or articulates that our passions exceed proper restraint, from the divine: God’s wounds as they say in hey-nonny-no historical novels. God! Jesus! and so on. The latter relate to what Bakhtin calls the lower bodily stratum: shit, piss, fuck, bollocks and the like. The story about the Deadwood screenwriters is that they wrote their characters using the second kind of swear-words although historical 19th-century Americans largely used the former, because when they tried historically appropriate swears they struck modern audiences as quaint and underpowered. In order for their swearing to register as swearing, the Deadwoodians had to utilise the second type of words. Actually I suspect the crossover from one to the other happened later than we might assume. Lennon caused genuine shock as late as 1969 when, in ‘The Ballad of John and Yoko’ he sang ‘Christ! you know it ain’t easy.’ It's a line that seems vanilla to 2020 sensibilities, although Mohr’s point is that these two magisteria actually cross-over, both practically (hence the titular ‘holy shit!) and conceptually.
That said, I'd argue there’s a kind-of Nietzschean Genealogy of Morals point about swearing that Mohr doesn't really address. We all swear, but we all also understand that there’s something low about swearing. In The Canterbury Tales, Chaucer’s high-born Knight is proud of the fact that he ‘nevere yet no vileynye ne sayde’: ‘villainy’ meaning not law-breaking but pertaining to villeins, commoners, of low-birth. Our public-us, our Sunday-best ps-and-qs-minding selves are our posh selves, and much of the release a good profanity entails comes from our sense of breaking through those restraints, of embracing a temporary lowness and vulgarity as a holiday from the formality of higher social standing.
Actually I think my point, or the argument I’m making, is twofold: that as class flattens (without, of course, going-away) it becomes generational: middle-aged people with houses and salaries are ‘high’ in a material sense, in relation to the new ‘low’: young people lugging-around debt, working zero-hours contracts, for whom a mortgage is a distant dream. But young people are ‘high’ in another sense, being by definition wealthy in that which our world today values most highly of all, youth itself; where the decaying, lined and bald (or more pathetic: the botoxed and surgically taut) elderly are ‘low’ by virtue of lacking that thing. How ‘youth’ became the prime socio-cultural value is an interesting question in its own right—it certainly wasn’t always that way. But here we are. I mean look at me. I’m not old, bald, set-in-my-ways, conventional, Establishment, and I can prove it: ‘fuck!’
You see?
So, yes. Colin Burrow argues that ‘many of us now liberally sprinkle our language with swearwords to show we have a liberal attitude to sex and to bodily functions’ and I think that's right. But I wonder if it's also the case that many middle-aged people liberally sprinkle their language with swears to show that they're cool, my doods, which is to say, with-it and uninhibited, untainted by the hideous constraints of old-age. Which is to say:
These thoughts are occasioned, in part, by Jackson Ford’s The Girl Who Could Move Sh*t With Her Mind (2018). Not the novel so much—which is fine, if a little over-long, and over-busy, too scared of losing its reader’s attention to ever let any of its runaround settle—as that title. Arresting, no? But: why the asterisk? Whose pudeur are we protecting with such maladroit bowdlerism?
The girl (not, I note, woman) of this book's title is Teagan Frost: a 22-year-old undercover agent working for a US government black ops. That she can move sh*t with her mind speaks to her superpower: telekinesis (she calls it ‘PK’), a talent she alone possesses, or so it seems at the beginning of the novel. The story here is that Frost gets framed for an unusual murder: Steven Case, killed in such a way that only Teagan, and her Magneto-style talents, could be responsible: strangled by ‘a piece of steel reinforcement bar—what house builders call rebar ... twisted tight like it was nothing more than a length of wire [wrapped] around his throat so deep that it's almost decaptitated him’ [93]. Teagan just wants to kick back and enjoy a beer, but instead she has to go on an action-filled LA runaround, trying to clear her name, solve the mystery, and repeatedly getting tasered (try to hit her with a metal bar and she can move that sh*t with her mind to stop you, but luckily for Ford's confection of narrative tension her skills don't work for bullets or tasers: ‘a taser prong launches at around a hundred and eighty feet per second; way too fast for me to stop’ [132]).
This is all fine: fast-paced and eventful, and the pages flap by rapidly enough. That's not to say it's especially good. ‘Jackson Ford’ (a pseudonym for nobody-knows-whom, although we're told s/he has previously published ‘sixteen bestselling novels’) goes all-in for the kinetic, thrusting prose style, so as to communicate the excitement and urgency of everything. So the weather's not hot, ‘the heat grabs me in a fist, beating down from the sky’; and rather than laughing a character ‘clutches her stomach howling with glee, erupting into another guffaw.’ Instead of closing her eyes, a woman ‘slams them shut.’ That kind of thing. But this a diminishing returns sort of strategy for the reader, and leaves the writer liable to active badness as s/he scrabbles for yet another over-forceful piece of phrasing. Exhibit A: ‘Annie accelerates, long legs exploding out of her willowy body’ [17]. Sounds painful.
This, though, is not my main point. The Girl Who Could Move Sh*t With Her Mind is fine; not Proust but fine. What it definitely is, though, is sweary. Given its title this shouldn't surprise us, although it seems to have caught at least one reader on the hop.
One person found this helpful. And why not? It's true: ‘Yo take that shit out. I said, fucking quit it’ [3]; ‘[She's] the bouncer no one fucks with’ [4]; ‘“Shit,” Annie says ... I find her staring at a clusterfuck of tangled cables’ [9]—and we're not even into double figures, page-count-wise. The whole of this novel is ‘what in the almighty storm of fuck is going on?’ [144] and ‘fuck you, man’ [260] and ‘motherfucker come on!’ [405], all the way through. I don't doubt that there are 22-year-olds who talk like this, but if ‘Jackson Ford’ has really published sixteen best-selling novels I'm guessing s/he is closer to middle-age than his/her protagonist and I start to wonder if the effing and jeffing isn't his/her way of in some sense evoking youth. Story-wise The Girl Who Could Move Sh*t With Her Mind is YA; but the book's swear-word quotient rather excludes it from that bookshop classification. It's not Scarface level swearing, where the swear-words are so continuous that monotony starts to erase them from perception (I can't remember who it was described British squaddies' use of fucking as merely a warning that a noun is coming). In Ford's novel there are just enough fucks and shits to mean that we keep registering them as fucks and shits. Which leads me to the question: why? Because swearing is edgy, and cool, and young perhaps. Because it is believed to add spice. Because it connotes rebellious hipness of youth. Fuck you grandad. Music. Lightning sigil. Band.
It's perfectly possible, and I suppose even likely, that the asterisked ‘sh*t’ on the cover was a publisher's, rather than an author's, call. But it's also what's on the inside title page, and on Bookscan, and so is, I suppose, actually what the book is called. And I'm going to suggest it's, well, lame. It's not as if there's any doubt the word with this photoshopped starburst over its nipple is shit, after all, They're not fooling anyone. More, we understand that shit, here, means stuff. No reader will pick this book up assuming that Teagan's powers are a peculiarly specialised mode of laxative. Why call a spade a sp*de? What makes it especially evasive is that the whole premise of the story concerns a character who lives a life without the reality-principle inhibitions on thought that constrain the rest of us: her thought becomes, magically, action.
You recognise the blog title's allusion. In one of his books about language, Anthony Burgess celebrates the syntactical versatility of fuck, and recalls how during his wartime service he overheard a mechanic tell the driver of a broken-down army lorry: ‘the fucking fucker’s fucking fucked.’ A glorious sentence, I think we can agree. And if I prefer fucker as a generic non-specific noun, over shit and certainly over sh*t, it's probably because fucking is a doing, a joy and sometimes a making, not a signifier of waste and decay. Of course, your fucking mileage may fucking vary.
Sunday, 22 March 2020
Grammars of Whimsy
No one seems to know the exact etymology of ‘whimsy’. Originally the word meant ‘dizziness, giddiness, vertigo’ (‘obsolete’ says the OED, quoting Charles Blount in 1656 complaining of being ‘troubled with such a whimsey in the head’, and also Thomas Middleton's play Old Law: ‘in my head already,/The whimzy, you all turne round’). From there the word came to mean crazy notions or eccentric beliefs: in 1713 William Derham declared that ‘our Inability to live in too rare and light an Air may discourage those vain Attempts of Flying, and Whimsies of passing to the Moon.’ It's a short step from that to the word meaning crazy fashions or eccentric behaviours. Macaulay’s 1848 History notes that some Cavaliers ‘had what seemed extravagant whimsies about dress, diversions, and postures.’ Since then the term has softened further, such that it now means a light-hearted playfulness and caprice, inventive triviality.
It sounds like it ought to be derived from whim, willpower’s flightier and more distractible cousin, but the etymologists say not so: ‘whimsy’, in fact, is preceded by the word ‘whim-wham’, ‘fanciful or fantastic object; figurative a trifle; in early use chiefly, a trifling ornament of dress, a trinket’, which dates from the early 16th-century. The OED provides a mini-essay on possible origins:
Etymology: A reduplication with vowel-variation, like flim-flam, jim-jam, trim-tram, all of which are similarly applied to trivial or frivolous things. The history of the group of words of which WHIM n.1, WHIMSY n. and adj., and this word are the chief members, is not clear. The existence in Old Norse of hvima, to wander with the eyes as with the fugitive look of a frightened or silly person, and hvimsa, to be taken aback or discomfited, suggests the possibility of an ultimate Scandinavian origin; but, seeing that whim-wham is the earliest recorded of the group (contemporaneously with the similar reduplicated forms mentioned above), an indigenous symbolic origin is more likely; in which case whimsy may be related to whim-wham as flimsy to flim-flam.Whimsy is opposed to grave, to serious, to the timeless verities. If you tend to see the present age as a shonky falling-away from a prior golden age then you’ll likely see modernity as whimsical (Rowland Hill in 1832 advised us, sternly enough, to follow ‘the pure and simple gospel of Christ, but not intermixed with the whim-whams of the present day’). By the same token, if you have greater trust in modernity, and see the past as a kind of amateur hour, smaller scale, given to eccentric superstitions like putting pigs on trial for witchcraft or buying indulgences from the Pope, then whimsy will start to connote historical-ness, or at least the Laura Ashley, Sealed-Knot, Renaissance-Fair manifestation of it.
Michael Wood, reviewing Pynchon’s Against The Day for the LRB, records his worry, as he started chapter 1, that the novel would be a thousand page block of mere whimsy:
Many readers can’t bear whimsy and never make it far into books containing cute animals and characters with funny names. I’m not wild about whimsy myself, and a first glance at Thomas Pynchon’s new novel had me worried … Here on page 1 is a group of boy adventurers called the Chums of Chance, heroes of a series of jolly books with titles like The Chums of Chance and the Evil Halfwit and The Chums of Chance Search for Atlantis. The narrator addresses us as ‘my faithful readers’ or ‘my young readers’, adopts a verbose and patronising diction to match.But, he says, he needn’t have worried. As the book gets into its stride Wood finds not whimsy but something else, a little less than kitsch and more than kind:
‘Whimsy’ is not the word for any of this. Pynchon has an extraordinary, open-ended affection for whoever and whatever is not serious—that is, not wholeheartedly committed to rationality, purpose and greed. Most of his stories—and his novels are crowded with not always connected stories—are about drop-outs of some kind, or people who would drop out if they could, characters who are trying to focus their disagreements with what he calls, in his new title and throughout the text, ‘the day’. ‘He had learned,’ we are told of one character, ‘to step to the side of the day.’ Resistance to exploitation ‘must be negotiated with the day’; people who don’t know what’s about to hit them are said to be ‘pretending to carry on with the day’. Of course, ‘against the day’ also, or even chiefly, means ‘till the day comes’, and that is part of Pynchon’s point. Beyond or outside the current day is our image of its counterpart, a lure or a threat, a world far worse or far better, doomsday or deliverance or even both. A character finds himself ‘facing west into a great flow of promise, something like wind, something like light, free of the damaged hopes and pestilent smoke east of here’; and the words ‘longing’ and ‘yearning’ recur with astonishing, eloquent frequency.I have read Against The Day and think this is spot-on. I am currently reading a metric tonne of contemporary Fantasy, and it is troubling me with a certain whimsey in my head, partly on account of the sheer quantity of it, but also in terms of a certain preponderance of a fay, ornate tweeness. The stuff that isn't brutalist ultraviolence is, as often as not, elaborate congeries of whimwham. Presumably there is an appetite for such stuff.
Here, for instance, is C.S.E. Cooney's Desdemona and the Deep (Tor 2019)—not by any means a bad book, despite that bizarre cover-blurb praising it for being ‘festooned to the eyelids’ (I happen to prefer my eyelids unfestooned, thank you very much). Desdemona Mannering, wilful daughter of a mining millionaire, pauses her campaigning on behalf of girls with phossy-jaw in order to descend into an adjacent dimension and recover the men her Daddy gave to the goblin erl-Lord, Kalos Kantzaros King of Kobolds, in return for certain mining rights. ‘Take as many miners as you want in exchange,’ H H Mannering declares; ‘they are the tithe. That's the bargain’ [45], which is not what ‘tithe’ means, but never mind that. Desdemona passes from her Gilded Age North-America via met-by-moonlight fairies into the grottoes of the underworld, encountering on her way all manner of rococo kitschness and prose-style gildings, not all of them ridiculous. There are characters with names like Tattercoats Bubbleguts and Umber Farklewhit. There's a good deal of rather mannered levity (‘never trust sopranos, especially ones that exude sticky mucilage!’ [100]). Characters caper, literally: ‘with a caper of his shining hooves, he fluffed the remains of his apron’ [167]. All well and good, if manifestly out of favour with any natural thing, a confection rather of hammered gold and gold enamelling to, as the poet put it, keep a drowsy Emperor awake:
Desdemona and Chaz slipped away to walk in the orchard. Branches glittered. Gold. Silver. They flowered, bore fruit-like gems. Gem-like fruit. Desdemona snapped off the prettiest branches as she passed under them ... smiling wryly, Chaz followed in the wake of her demolition, silently collecting fallen boughs and arranging them in a bouquet of precious metals that sagged with jewels. [181]It would get tiresome if overextended, but Cooney doesn't outstay her welcome. That said, there are negatives as well as positives with the brevity strategy: ‘whimsical,’ says one Goodreads reviewer, ‘but rushed and insubstantial.’ That's right, I think. It's not the artificiality that's the issue, it's the sterility. To say that your golden trees bear fruit-like gems, and then to concede that you might as well call them gem-like fruits, is to make a tacit confession that all this ornateness is interchangeable and therefore arbitrary. When Yeats speaks of his amazing, Byzantine, gold-and-jewels robot bird:
Miracle, bird or golden handiwork,... his point is how such a contrivance fails to capture any of the ‘complexities of mire or blood’ that constitute actual living. Eternal but inert, ‘a mouth that has no moisture and no breath/I call it death-in-life and life-in-death.’ Hardly the most auspicious of Coleridgean allusions, that. Gong-tormented indeed.
More miracle than bird or handiwork,
Planted on the starlit golden bough,
In glory of changeless metal
What's missing, in other words, is Pynchonian transitoriness, the sense that the best stories balance stringency and acquiescence against the day: this day, the one that's already slipping away. Whimsy, we could say, is ornate without being complex, trivial without thereby banishing any of the profounder disaffections, a rotatory unadvancing mode of art (dizzying, perhaps, in that slightly nauseous sense). The issue isn't ‘cutesy’ cooties, or any emotionally-straitened reaction against sentimentality. The issue is the incapacity of this bejewelled idiom to express the yearning Wood so astutely identifies as the crucial part of the decaying lyricism of Pynchon's vast novel.
I don't mean to pick on Cooney, whose book I enjoyed and whose gorgeous sterility is perfectly fine, if you're in the mood for that kind of thing. Besides, as I say, there's a lot of it about at the moment. The trick, I suppose, is supplying your readers with something actually dizzying—properly disorienting, wrongfooting, head-spinning—rather than the kind of ersatz ditz so many of these books actually trade in. Students nowadays titter at that Milton line from Comus: ‘how Charming is Divine Philosophy!’ But the fault is in our usage, a contemporary discourse that has diluted charming into nothing more than a polished manner and a pleasant smile, and so removed it from its originary relationship to charm, to deep magic and the ability to hold your listener frozen to the spot with your glittering eye. All this, in other words, relates to the larger cultural logic of disenchantment. Once upon a time grimoires contained spells to harrow up our souls, freeze our blood, make our knotted and combined locks to part and each particular hair to stand an end, like quills upon the fretful porpentine. Now what we have are grammars, to regulate and moderate all our varieties of discourse. There's even a Grammar of Whimsy. It can be charming, but only in the modern, disenchanted and diluted sense of that word. And it can just be irksome.
Thursday, 19 March 2020
CILIP Carnegie Award 2020
So: the shortlist for this year's prestigious Carnegie Medal for best children's novel has been announced today:
• The Black Flamingo by Dean Atta, illustrated by Anshika KhullarThe Carnegie is always an interesting prize, and doubly so if one happens to be teaching a course on children's literature (as I have been doing this year). There are at least two ways in which it merits discussion: one, since the judges just have a really good record of choosing strong, thought-provoking, worthwhile books; and two since many school English teachers, mandated by the national curriculum to teach contemporary fiction, take their lead from the prize, bulk-order the winning title for their school libraries to teach it. That gives this medal a special place in the broader culture of ‘young people reading’.
• Nowhere on Earth by Nick Lake
• Lark by Anthony McGowan
• Patron Saints of Nothing by Randy Ribay
• Lampie written and illustrated by Annet Schaap (transl by Laura Watkinson)
• Voyages in the Underworld of Orpheus Black by Marcus and Julian Sedgwick
• On the Come Up by Angie Thomas
• Girl. Boy. Sea. by Chris Vick
I don't know who is going to win the 2020 title, nor do I propose to enter into barren speculation on that topic. Instead I'm going to meditate a little on whether there has been an identifiable trend in recent Carnegie winners—the last nine winners, say, to take us back to the beginning of this decade. In what follows I appreciate I'm running the risk of generalising and therefore flattening the specificity of what is a properly diverse set of novels, especially if considered shortlist by shortlist. But I do wonder if dystopia has become something of a culturally dominant force lately. The Hunger Games is one of the best-selling series of the century so far; Harry Potter takes its charming old-school, er, school into pretty dystopian territory when Voldemort comes back and establishes a fascist dictatorship. Other series like Noughts and Crosses, Divergent, and The Maze Runner spin variations on the same dystopic vision. Game of Thrones, popular among teens and adults both, is a dystopian Fantasy of rare grimness and horribleness. Once upon a time James Bond (the movies, I mean: Fleming's novels were always dour and self-hating) was camp and colourful and carefree escapism; now it is scowling, dark and testicle-crushing. Superman used to be bright colours and antic adventure; Batman's bashing-up bad guys would be embroidered with on-screen POW! and SMASH! pop-ups. Now we're offered fare like Batman Versus Superman (2016), which was, as we remember to our sorrow, two grown men joylessly punching one another in the rain for many hours.
I don't want to overstate things. There's still a lot of joy in a lot of popular culture, of course. But it does seem to me as if the really popular culture-texts, the ones with the most extensive global cultural penetration, all skew dystopic. And whilst the Carnegie titles haven't enjoyed quite the sheer scale of success of Potter, Hunger Games and Twilight, they are interesting and significant texts nonetheless.
So is there a trend? The prize has been running since 1936, but I'm going to concentrate on the 21st century, and our decade in particular. The 2001 winner was this installment of Pratchett's Discworld sequence; and as charming and funny and clever as any of them.
No dystopia here! Hopping forward to 2008: Reeve's Arthurian novel won, a book that creates a notionally ‘realistic’ 6th-century in order to think about the power and endurance of legends and the legendary:
Then to 2009, when Gaiman's Graveyard Book won. Now I don't want to sound like I'm sniping at Gaiman's success (and this novel has been very successful indeed). There's undeniably a lot to like about this novel, a retelling of Kipling's Jungle Book in a postmortem world of graves, ghouls, ghosts and vampires. I suppose we could say it's ‘about’ death, but although it is inventive and enjoyable I wonder if it doesn't, ultimately, pull its punches on that existentially desolating subject. I wouldn't call it cutesy. I might call it cute, but cute is OK. I do think it's a little, well, safe.
We might say: that's only right, since it's a children's novel. But my point in listing these earlier titles is to suggest that the Carnegie saw some manner of pivot in 2010 towards rewarding a much darker and more dystopic kind of text. First off, then, 2010's winner: the final volume of Patrick Ness's excellent Chaos Walking trilogy (the previous two installments of which had been shortlisted and longlisted respectively) won the prize in 2010.
There's a great deal to say about this trilogy, much more than I can manage here. It starts as the story of an all-male settlement on a distant planet, men and boys who have somehow been altered so that they cannot help but hear the cacophonic thoughts of others. Ness's cleverly-rendered ‘Noise’ (some playful typography that never becomes egregious) uses telepathy to capture the claustrophobic oppressiveness of a certain kind of toxic interpersonal environment. (Twitter used to be fun when I started using it; it's getting more and more like Ness's Noise, and increasingly I find myself wondering if I should be a Todd and run away.) We start the Chaos Walking trilogy believing that the women of Prentisstown have all died of the ‘germ’ that infected the men and made them telepathic; and also that this bug was released upon the human settlers by the alien aboriginal Spackles. The truth, we soon discover, is otherwise: the women are still alive, though elsewhere, and the Spackle are not to blame. But although Ness's storytelling is always lively and interesting, and although he is a funny as well as a moving writer, he is absolutely unsparing in his representation of the way violence harms the self as much as it harms others. The scene in the first book where Todd stabs a Spackle to death is genuinely upsetting to read; and the descent of the various populations into war in the end makes grueling reading. Prentisstown, and its Donald Trump-ish fuhrer Prentiss, are the stuff of a straightforward dystopian vision. [A movie is on its way starring Tom Holland and Daisy Ridley: 2021, we're told]
Ness won the 2011 prize as well, for the heartbreaking A Monster Calls.
The cover, there, sports two Carnegie medals, as you can see, since Jim Kay also won that year's Kate Greenaway prize for illustration (awarded by CILIP, the same people who administer the Carnegie). As well he should: his images for this book are amazing.
But then, the whole book is amazing. The monster is a sort of giant animated yew tree, and the person on whom it calls, always at 12:07, is 13-year old Conor. Conor's mother is dying of cancer; his father lives on the other side of the Atlantic, and his grandmother, who cares for him, is distant and cold. He's bullied at school and something of a loner. The monster tells him three stories, and in return Conor must tell the creature his own nightmare. But the monster's stories deliberately eschew moralising; they are tales of human suffering and loss. In his waking life, as when he finally fights back against his bullies, Conor seems to be in some sense possessed by the spirit of his troublesome monster. His mother's condition worsens, and at 12:07 she dies in the hospital. If I describe this book as ‘Not Now Bernard, but for bereavement’ I in no way mean to belittle it. Not Now Bernard is, in its small way, a masterpiece.
The original idea for A Monster Calls was Siobhan Dowd's, herself a previous Carnegie winner; she passed it over to Ness to write up because she was dying of cancer. But the premise stands or falls on how well the monster is written, and Ness does an extraordinary job with that. His monster possesses just the right touch of the sublime:
This in turn grounds the emotional directness of Conor's relationship to his dying mother, which you really would have to have a heart of stone to read without being moved.
You couldn't call A Monster Calls a dystopia. But it is very, very far from being a bag of laughs, and in this novel Ness here brings the same unflinching approach to psychological trauma that shapes the representation of actual violence in the Chaos Walking books.
The 2013 winner, Sally Gardner's Maggot Moon, certainly is dystopia, though: of a venerable, old-school, Nineteen-eighty-four-ish stripe.
That's Standish Tredwell on the cover there: a misfit, dyslexic, one-blue-eye-one-brown-eye kid in an Orwellian alt-historical 1950s (I'm guessing) Britain called the ‘Motherland’: deprivation and oppressive surveillance, disappearances and secret police, children at Standish's school beaten, sometimes to death, for noncompliance. Standish lives with his Gramps in a ramshackle house in distant ‘Zone 7’ whilst the Motherland North-Korea-ishly pushes ahead on a grand and pointless moon rocket project. It's a well-written but remarkably dispiriting read, Maggot Moon; or I thought so. But more to the point, there's something queerly old-fashioned about this dystopia. Hunger Games, or in their more schematic ways Maze Runner or Divergent, construct dystopias extrapolated from the experience of modern teens; Maggot Moon extrapolates a 21st-century teen dystopia from the experience of 21st-century teen's grandparents, all boiled cabbage and nosy neighbours, shonky totalitarianism and petty spite. It's a strange and oddly nostalgic mode of dystopia, this; though dystopia it certainly is. But perhaps that's only right; the -algia part of nostalgia means ‘pain’, after all, and one way of characterising the current shift to the right in world politics is as a call to turn back the clock, to return to some earlier version of the world. Gardner's book could be read as an unillusioned examination of that idea.
Which brings us to Kevin Brooks' The Bunker Diary; 2014's winner and easily the most controversial recipient of the Carnegie Medal.
Teenager Linus Weems is asked by a feeble-looking apparently blind man to help him load something into his van; duped and drugged, the next thing Linus knows is that he is waking up in a windowless underground bunker. The only only way in or out is an elevator, which his captor, ‘The Man Upstairs’, controls.
Over time various other people are deposited in this prison; the youngest a nine-year-old girl. Linus records it all in his diary as the Man Upstairs withholds food until the captives kill one another. Some die, or commit suicide; others kill. Eventually the elevator stops running; the inmates deduce that the Man Upstairs had passed away, or moved on, or been captured, and they resign themselves to their fate. It's a heroically grim and forbidding story with an exceptionally bleak ending: everyone else is dead, and Linus's diary entries trail off to indicate that he too has expired.
There is a kind of Saw-lite vibe to The Bunker Diaries; and a stubborn refusal to permit the readers any kind of catharsis which is either boldly admirable, or else just annoying. But the reaction to the book's win was way out of proportion to the matter at hand. It approached hysteria in the Telegraph, and the Guardian, reporting it, managed to slap a picture of the (I don't doubt, charming and personable) Brooks onto their website that made him look like a stare-eyed loon.
From that report:
Brooks was named winner of the Carnegie on Monday, joining a long roster of prestigious winners which includes Arthur Ransome – who won the first ever award in 1936 – Alan Garner, Penelope Lively and Philip Pullman. The Bunker Diary, which was turned down by publishers for years because of its bleak outlook, is told in the form of the diary of a kidnapped boy held hostage in a bunker. Awarding him with the medal, judges said he had created ‘an entirely credible world with a compelling narrative, believable characters and writing of outstanding literary merit’.There's no actual masturbation or rape specified in Brooks' novel: this is what we might call ‘projection’ on the evidently rather fevered imagination of Lorna Barbara. But it is undeniably a grim read
But writing in the Telegraph, in a piece headlined ‘why wish this book on a child?’ and describing The Bunker Diary as ‘a vile and dangerous story’, literary critic Lorna Bradbury vigorously disagreed. She called the book ‘much nastier’ than other dystopian fictions such as The Hunger Games and Divergent, writing: ‘Here we have attempted rape, suicide and death by various means, all of it presided over by our anonymous captor, the “dirty old man” upstairs who it's difficult not to imagine masturbating as he surveys the nubile young bodies (including a girl of nine).’
Saying that the novel ‘makes versions of the imprisonment narrative for adult readers, such as Emma Donoghue's Room, based on the case of Josef Fritzl, the Austrian who locked up his daughter for 24 years, look tame’, Bradbury questioned whether books like Brooks' were ‘good for our teenagers’.
Also grim is 2015's potent winner, Tanya Landman's Buffalo Soldier:
This centres on Charlotte, a slave girl in 1860s America who is freed by the Emancipation Proclamation but who finds her life is no better off, and in some respects is worse. It is a vivid and powerful piece of writing, but far from comfortable: Charlotte's parents raped and murdered and Charlotte herself raped and threatened, she decides she'd face a slightly reduced risk dressed as a boy. And it is as a boy, 'Charlie' that she joins the US Army, and becomes one of the Buffalo Soldiers, African American regiments (but with White officers) sent out to subdue Native Americans. Part of the point of the book is the way the brutalised subaltern in turn will find and brutalise any sub-subaltern power presents to them: the freed Blacks in Landman's novels are at the bottom of the social heap, until they meet the Native Americans. Charlie ends up in a relationship with one Indian, ‘Jim’, and I wouldn't say the novel is bleached of all hope. Nor can we really call it dystopian, unless ‘dystopia’ seems to us a reasonable description of the Civil War-era and postbellum USA. Which we might well think.
I was disappointed in 2016 that Francis Hardinge's extraordinary novel The Lie Tree did not win; instead we got One:
The story, here, concerns conjoined twins Grace and Tippi, one of whom falls in love with a boy. It ends (I'm avoiding spoilers, but) sadly. That the whole thing is written in a kind of formless free verse speaks, perhaps, to an ambition to achieve a lyric intensity of pathos, although I'm sorry to say I found the verse slack and clumsy, and the story without this gimmick (cruel of me to call it a gimmick, really; but there you go) is a short-story and rather underdeveloped narrative. It being impossible for anyone but a monster to withhold their sympathy for Grace and Tippi's situation, the emotional through-line is one-dimensional and more than a little manipulative. Perhaps what I am saying here reflects only my crusty old and hardened heart. At any rate, and although this is a mimetic novel, containing a good deal of practical day-to-day stuff on what life is like if you are half of a conjoined doublet—which is to say, we cannot call it a dystopia—nontheless it is a text that takes it as axiomatic that to be young today is to be burdened, simulataneously isolated and claustrophobic; to be tragic (if tragically hip). If I, an oldster, ask The Youngling what their life is like, will they really reply I fall upon the thorns of life I bleed with such sentimental focus? Is there a sentimental component to the dystopian vision?
We're getting nearer to now. 2017's winner was Salt to the Sea, by Ruta Sepetys, a story about refugees that certainly approaches dystopic intensity, although it is based on an historical circumstance: the sinking, by a Soviet submarine, in January 30, 1945, of the Wilhelm Gustloff, a German cruise liner that was carrying a great many refugees to safety away from the advancing Red Army. The ship was massively overcrowded (there were more than 10,500 passengers travelling in a ship designed to carry 1,800) and when it sank more than 9,000 people, including 5,000 children, lost their lives.
Sepetys spares her four main characters Joana, Florian, Emilia and Alfred, variously German, Polish and Lithuanian, trekking across frozen landscapes, reaching the ship they think will save them and ending ... well, no spoilers, but: check the book's title.
Also historical, although 18th-century rather than WW2, is 2018's winner: Geraldine McCaughrean's Where the World Ends.
I admire this novel very much, and it is written with tremendous verve and power. Nor, since it is based (we're told) on a true story, do I want to give the impression that I'm bracketing it as dystopia-adjacent only to fit my larger argument. Nonetheless, there's a chillier Lord of the Flies vibe here, a sense of a society pared down by circumstance and grimly configured. Each year a group of men and boys from the Scottish island of Hirta (St Kilda) are taken by boat to one of the uninhabited St Kilda stacs to harvest birds and eggs for food. After a set time boat comes to collect them and they return home. But in the time detailed by the novel, in 1727, no one returns to collect them. Why? The lads on the island come to believe that the world outside has ended, and that they have been abandoned to endure storms, starvation and terror alone. Things (once again, I am avoiding spoilers) don't pan out quite so catastrophically, and it's misleading to compare it to Lord of the Flies in several ways, not least that there are grown men as well as children on the island. But what McCaughrean does in this novel is to enact, as it were, the formal strategies of dystopia, using the island (More's original Utopia is, of course, an island, separated from the mainland for defensive reasons) as a trope for isolation, communal despair and grief. You're never in any doubt, reading this novel, how grimly unforgiving and horrible a location the St Kilda stacs would be as a site of habitation.
Last year the winner was Elizabeth Acevedo's The Poet X, concerning which I can say little since I'm ashamed to say I haven't read it yet. I know from reviews that Acevedo herself is a renowned slam poet, and that her highly-praised novel is about a young girl called Xiomara Batistain, living in a deprived community in Harlem, who finds in slam poetry a way to express herself and to fight back against a hostile world. As for this year, I've no idea. Maybe we're about to pivot back to a kinder, gentler YA/children's novel; conceivably The Poet X already marks a change in that direction. I've only read a few of the longlisted titles, but none of them have been grimdark in any sense.
So where are we? It seems that almost all the 20teens winners of the Carnegie medal have been either dystopias or else narratives of trauma, suffering and misery. And one way of getting at the point I'm trying to make is that these titles (with the possible exception of A Monster Calls, and The Poet X) are dark in an unrelieved way: tragic but without catharsis. Indeed a thumbnail definition of today's Grimdark might be: a commitment to tragedy that is by definition non-cathartic.
What does this say about youth culture today? Because whatever it does say will, again by definition, say something important about 21st-century culture more generally, determined as that latter quantity is so hugely by YA, from Potter to MCU, from pop to SF. Why the scope and persistence of this taste in dystopia? The more hopeful reading might be the Jamesonian one: that dystopia is actually our age's way of ‘doing’ utopia, an age that can no longer believe in the wide-eyed ingenuousness of the epoch that wrote all those unironic utopian books, but which doesn't want to give up the idea that things might be made better.
Jameson's thesis in his Archaeologies of the Future is that dystopia represents an ‘Anti-anti-utopianism’ which is, in a counterintuitive way, utopian:
What is crippling is the universal belief . . . that the historic alternatives to capitalism have been proven unviable and impossible, and that no other socioeconomic system is conceivable, let alone practically available. The value of the utopian form thus consists precisely in its capacity as a representational meditation on radical difference, radical otherness, and . . . the systematic nature of the social totality [28]Maybe that's right; but I find myself wondering if Jameson's approach is the best way of talking about all this. It is, in a manner of speaking, a kind of assertive mourning for the injustices of the present, aimed at working through the horror towards something better. But maybe Freud's distinction between mourning and melancholia better glosses the present-day vogue for dystopia by leaning more on the latter quantity. Young readers connect with books like The Hunger Games or The Bunker Diary because they feel, in some symbolic sense, trapped in a desperate game, a game designed by adults to control and kill them. The real tragedy of the circumstance is that their suffering, absent catharsis, is not even tragic. ‘Within depression,’ Kristeva notes in Black Sun, ‘if my existence is on the verge of collapsing, its lack of meaning is not tragic – it appears obvious to me, glaring and inescapable.’ Those last two words describe the premises of many of these Westeros-Panem YA topographies rather neatly, I feel.
[This new mode of] Utopia as a form provides the answer to the universal ideological conviction that no alternative is possible. It does so ... by forcing us to think the break itself . . . not by offering a more traditional picture of what things would be like after the break [323]
The counter-intuitive part of all this, for a middle-aged fogey like myself, is that in many ways young people today have ‘it’ better than any previous generation. Quite apart from material improvements in the quality of life, the future belongs to them, as it always has. They can hardly lose. But then again, perhaps that is the problem. ‘Perhaps,’ Kristeva also wonders ‘my depression points to my not knowing how to lose—I have perhaps been unable to find a valid compensation for my loss.’ Difficult to see from where such compensation could be sourced. Chaos Walking and Buffalo Soldier are both, in different ways, about the terrible fallout from acts of colonial intrusion, but it may be that the relevant empire is less historical in these novels than it is the Empire of Trauma itself, under whose distant and implacable authority we all now subsist.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)































