Monday, 8 December 2014
Marie Brennan, A Natural History of Dragons (2014)
There's a certain odour of How To Train Your Dragon about this, with the cod-Viking milieu replaced with a Fantasyland version of Edwardian England, and the cartoonish humour swapped over for a detailed (frankly, rather too detailed) evocation of the curiosity of the natural historian. The result is a gentle and, to some extent, beguiling yarn; although one that lacks any properly draconic fire or force. The narrator, Lady Trent, nurses a by-the-standards-of-her-sexist-time unladylike interest in dragons from an early age. She learns from the cook how to preserve a dead 'sparkling' in vinegar (a dragon so small some categorise it as an insect). She grows up the copy of the De draconum varietatibus in her father's library -- I can't say I trust the Latin here, since Lewis and Scott insist the genitive of draco is dracontis. Or perhaps Latin works differently in Brennan's imaginary locale. After all, Lady Trent grows-up in Edwardian luxury in 'Scirland' not Britain, and she travels from this large set of islands off the shoulder of the mainland continent not to Albania/Transylvania/somewherelikethat-ania but rather to 'Vystrana'. What Brennan gains by setting her tale in this arbitrarily constructed Fantasy realm isn't clear to me.
Anyway, not to get ahead of myself: Lady Trent grows to maturity and gets married the kindly Jacob, a less oppressively patriarchal husband than Isabella might have been lumbered with. Jacob risks social ostracism by permitting his wife to attend him on a scientific expedition to the valleys surrounding Drustanev in assuredly-not-Albania/Transylvania/somewherelikethat-ania in search of dragons. There are a couple of rather slackly told adventures: our heroine kidnapped by colourful bandits, who despite her fears that they might 'outrage her honour' in fact swiftly return her to the expedition. She goes on to encounter ancient tombs, statues, legends of the mythical half-human-half-dragon king Zhagrit Mat, and a variety of actual big-as-a-bus dragons, which Isbaella sketches. The illustrations, notionally hers, are one of the high-points of this otherwise rather underinflated story. Nothing very much happens; the cod-Edwardian tone is too broadly pastiche-y and Down-Abbeyesque properly to work and the whole flavour is, well, cosy. Though Isabella carries on her shoulder the scar of a childhood encounter with a Wolf-Drake (half wolf, half duck! Or, no, wait a minute: actually a kind of large dragon ...), and though she's always tumbling through into subterranean caves, being stalked by wild beasts etc etc it never generates any tension or terror. On the plus side, the dragons are treated as examples of naturally occurring wildlife, rather than as feeble McAffreyish ciphers for housecats or horses. But on the down side, the dragons are treated as examples of naturally occurring wildlife, and the minute itemisation of their anatomy and behaviour is a little ... well, dull.
Saturday, 6 December 2014
Philip Reeve and Sarah McIntyre, Cakes in Space (2014)
The previous review, here, talked a bit about charm: and this collaboration between storyman Reeve and picturewoman McIntyre has that quality in spades. In space-spades. Astra's family are part of a generation starship to 'Nova Mundi' (not good Latin, I fear: shouldn't it be 'novus mundus'? But then again, who's counting?). Her family slumber in their hibernation pods, but Astra and her robofriend Pilbeam are 'WIDE AWAKE'. They discover that the ship is off course, and come across some intruders called 'Poglites', with a thing about collecting spoons. But these are as nothing compared to the titular Cakes, very alarming aliens. There's a sweetened Vermicious Knid vibe to these latter, and lots of Douglas-Adams-rewrites-Dahl fun to be had. The worst you could say is that occasionally the charm degenerates into whimsy. But that's not so bad.
Ken MacLeod, Descent (2014)
Ryan is a regular lad growing up in a near-future Scotland struggling under yet another severe economic recession. He and his friend Calum have an encounter with a UFO. Ryan later 'remembers' an abduction experience, rather too fruitily supplied with all the clichés of that mode. Calum, though, has no such memories. After this vividly realised opening the novel in leisurely but absorbing style follows Ryan and his generation as they grow to adulthood. Nothing much comes of the UFO encounter, except that it primes Ryan to develop a series of complex, interlocking conspiracy theories: about advanced military tech disguising itself as alien saucers, about a new speciation event by which a secret homo neanderthalis bloodline is about to emerge and separate from homo sapiens; about the truth behind 'religious' epiphanies and of course (it being MacLeod) about politics, establishment agents pretending to be revolutionaries and vice versa, the complicity of the secret services and so on. This, it dawns on the reader, is the real theme of the book. Descent is, consciously or otherwise, a Jamesonian riff on the enduring appeal of 'the conspiracy theory' as such—Jameson, as I'm sure you know, thinks that our appetite for these sorts of things indexes our attempt to see our social, cultural and ideological milieu for what it is, a global interlocking system called 'Late Capitalism'. Meanwhile the economy gets sorted out via a quick nationalisation of the banking system and an acceptance of the trading dominance of China (or something); Ryan gets a job as a an online journalist. MacLeod has fun with some near-future tech: a world so saturated in surveillance its possible to assemble a real-time Google Earth rolling map just by sampling all the feeds. There are advances in fabric technology, a ramscoop jet that could cut access-to-space costs and the like. A dubiously sleekit fellow called Baxter stalks Ryan down the years in various guises: a priest, a man-in-black and so on. Baxter eventually becomes a political Big Cheese in the Scottish Parliament (I found this plot strand all rather hard to swallow, actually: not so much the conspiracy side to it, but the way he seems to have endless time for Ryan; the narrator phones him for a meeting and he immediately says 'I can give you an hour and a half, face-to-face' and so on). The book is dedicated to 'the memory of Iain M. Banks', and there's a decidedly Crow-Road-ish flavour to the storytelling. I enjoyed reading it very much.
What it lacks, despite all its excellencies, is menace. Even when the heavies turn up, late in the story, and rough-up our narrator the mood doesn't shift from its tenor of expansive, rather leisurely charm. Now this is not to be sniffed at, this latter quality: it is valuable, and very hard for a writer to do -- it is, for instance, quite beyond my technical capacity as a writer (I can do lots of things, but I don't seem to be able to do that). And it carries Descent a long way; the growing-up-in-Scotland milieu, the characters, the prose. It just doesn't quite carry through the thing that gives real conspiracy theories their tang, the curry-paste hotness that keep adherents coming back for more: the sense that it matters, the self-preening I'm taking a courageous risk by pursuing it. It's almost never true, the 'risk' thing. Actual conspiracy theorists risk only their sanity, and that sort of risk-taking is the opposite of courageous. But it's addictive nonetheless.
Thursday, 4 December 2014
Sibilant Fricaplug
It's been a while here since I've had a bookplug post for the Sibilant Fricative: Essays and Reviews book (available as an ebook for the low-low price of £3.42), and I'd hate to leave you missing that sort of naked marketing. So here is a link to The OF Blog's review of the collection. And here is that review!
Confession: I have a difficult time pronouncing "sibilant." I frequently confound it somehow with silibant, which would make for an odd pun if one were pondering the merits of (unintentionally) comic novels. Puns of course being something with which followers of Roberts' Twitter account would be familiar. That weakness being confessed, here's another: Roberts is one of the best lit critics writing today, especially for those who deign to treat topics as varied as Robert Browning, Gene Wolfe, Christopher Priest, Maurice Sendak and Robert Jordan. Yes, Roberts' essays run the gamut from breaking down complex fictions into interesting, illuminating reviews to bringing to the fore Jordan's unfortunate penchant for writing quasi-clothing and tea porn. There are times where I disagreed with his conclusions but admired the way he argued his points. Then there were the times that I wanted to laugh aloud at how adroitly he could skewer a plot that deserved to die the death of a thousand pinpricks. If this isn't a testimony to how good Roberts is as a reviewer, then perhaps I should just say go forth and buy a copy and find out for yourself.Do what the man says, why don't you.
Wednesday, 3 December 2014
Tobias S, Buckell, Hurricane Fever (2014)
This is a sort-of sequel to Buckell's previous spy-malarkey thriller Arctic
I'm going to pause for a moment, to let the odour of that dissipate.
Right.
So, there's a lot of rapid-fire action, and some rather too neatly disposed global conspiring too. It's a spy-thriller with a strong maritime component and a dusting of near-future imaginary tech. In other words it's yet another example of the Oft-Discovered Bond Spree, from whose Bourne/No trad Le Car-Returns, and Catcher in Jack Ry-/An makes Missions quite Impossible. Not to, you know. To get carried away. *clears throat* Thus Copying doth make Cowards of us all.
My problem is generic, not specific to this novel. That problem is that certain readers, and the writers who supply them, believe that fighting is more interesting than talking, that shooting is more interesting than being, that violence is more interesting manifested physically in the outside world than internally in the psyche (indeed, who believe that the former doesn't really entail the latter at all, though the latter is where all violence actually comes to rest), that explosions are fireworks rather than massively accelerated entropy, that Bond, James Bond is better than Henry James (Henry), and in sum that characters in action are more fun than action in character. Whereas I tend to believe the exact opposite. But that only means I'm probably not the idea reviewer for this title. Which is fair enough.
Gregory Benford and Larry Niven, Bowl of Heaven (2014)
Two big names in SF collaborate on a Big Dumb Object novel. The titular 'bowl' is a titanic construction built around a red star and travelling through the galaxy collecting life-forms. It is, in effect, half a Dyson sphere. Appropriate to this conceit, Benford and Niven have here written a half-arsed novel. Less BDO, more BOOO!
The thing is, I've a soft spot for these kinds of rude Rama retreads ('Re-rendezvous With Rama'?), and even Niven's hilariously cack-handed writing and plotting can't spoil the original Ringworld novel for me, where traces of grandeur still manage to cling, like wisps of morning fog, around the main idea (I say nothing of the myriad sequels, which are all terrible). BDOs are cool; scale and sublimity and the chance to let yourself wander, imaginatively speaking, around a varied and beguiling environment. Bowl of Heaven, though, is lamentably bad. There are two different levels on which it is simply not yet ready to be published. One is the level of story. We start with a sub-light interstellar spaceship SunSeeker, on its way from Earth to a planet called Glory. Key crewmembers are woken from hibernation because the ship's trajectory, in a co-incidence the scale of the cosmos licenses us to call 'bollocks', has crossed paths with the Bowl of Heaven. Since there's some question as to whether supplies will last the rest of the SunSeeker's voyage, on account of whoever supplied said supplies Earthside being obviously an idiot, the crew decide to fly their starship, complete with its sleeping cargo of thousands of human settlers, into the Bowl. This they do by nipping up the superheated plasma stream of the BDO's exhaust. You see, the 'bowl' has a big hole in its base, and mirrors in its concave inner surface focussing the starlight back on a spot on the star, which in turn shoots out the colossal plasma jet that moves the whole thing through space. The motion forward exactly counteracts the tendency of the bowl to fall into the gravitational well of the star, keeping the system in equilibrium. Except that late in the book some of the earthers see a sort of home movie of the Bowl being built, and there's no explanation of how the structure is kept in its orbit during the eons-long construction. No matter. Surely we can agree that flying up the stellar exhaust pipe is a stupid thing to do.
Of course, we know that Benford and Niven (I like to think of them as 'Nivbenford', the result of a tragic matter-transporter malfunction) need to get their human characters aboard
I mentioned two things; and the second is the worldbuilding. This is more deplorable, in a way, since the novel really only exists to display the cool BDO. But Nivbenford seem to have run out of space on the back of the envelope they used to plan this structure. It's big: 'bigger than the orbit of Mercury' [34]. To be precise 'it covered a perimeter about the size of Earth's orbit' [247]. Which is certainly bigger than the orbit of Mercury, I suppose. It rotates in nine days [247] except on p 315 where it rotates 'in about ten days'. How is the implausibly earth-like atmosphere kept inside? A barrier is stretched across the inside of the bowl, like clingfilm. Imagine the size of the roll they must have used! Ah, but how does the bowl steer itself, slow down to pick up new life forms, stop etc? We're not told, presumably because it can't. Out of what improbably rigid material is the bowl made, to prevent it breaking-up? Again we're not told, though we are vouchsafed that the construction of the Bowl entailed 'girders ... scaffolds ... crossbars ... joists and brackets the size of planets' [242]. Pull the other one. Nivbenford's imaginations have failed them, and they've reverted to an Empire State Building Sized construction rather than a solar-system sized one. This novel puts the 'ow!' in 'bowl' and the 'heave' in 'heaven'. If I were you I wouldn't touch this Bowl of Heaven with a barge-pole. Of heaven.
Monday, 1 December 2014
Susan Gray, Sum (2014)
I saw Susan Gray's excellent science fiction play Sum at the Bread and Roses, in Clapham, last Saturday night. There are still a few tickets available for the final three performances, at the end of this week (Thu Dec 4th - Sat Dec 6th, 7:30pm - 9:00pm) and I urge you to snap then up.
Sum is a play about the early days of a hivemind, set in a blasted near-future and tracing, through a sinuously threaded string of intense set-piece scenes, the tension between assimilation and individuality. The direction, by Chris Callow Jr, very effectively focuses attention where it needs to be: on the performances and the words; and the acting of the all-female cast is uniformly excellent. Where so much of the dramatic force depends on the integrated work of the whole company it would be invidious to single performances; but, that said, Lydia Kay as Carrie/Lan does extraordinarily well with the technically tricky business of acting two rather different characters at once; Melanie Crossey brings real electricity to Syne's hopes of becoming the 'head' of this new acephalic entity. Gray's play is at once an imagintive new intervention into a venerable SF trope, and a meditation upon theatre itself. Callow, who trained at the Athenian Stage in Greece, knows very well how the interaction between individuated 'characters' and a group-mind 'chorus' determined the very shape of drama in Aeschylus, Sophocles and Euripides; and Sum feels in one sense like a modern re-evaluation of the core structures of theatre itself. Highly recommended.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







.jpg)