Wednesday, 8 October 2014

Eric Brown, Jani and the Greater Game (2014)



Steampunky alt-historical India: British Raj, 1920s vintage. A mysterious energy source called 'Annapurnite' has enabled Britain to maintain a boosted global empire. Jani Chatterjee, precocious teenager and the daughter of an Indian government minister, is returning home from Cambridge University via airship when the Russians attack. She is saved from Russian violation and murder by a weird creature: 'long and thin, its skin deathly white ... its features were almost human' (alien? Frankenstein's monster? Peter Crouch?) From there-on it's a series of diverting adventures in Brown's alt-Raj: dastardly plots are afoot; life-size mechanical elephants are there for the riding; Annapurnite is not all it seems. It's enjoyable stuff, if perhaps a little underinflated, narratively speaking. Sometimes it reads like a jolly novella expanded to novel length; and few of the twists surprised me. Still, Jani is an appealing protagonist, and the pastiche Edwardian-y ripping yarn style is fun. But why take my 21st-century word for it? Why not go to the source: actual journals and newspapers from the alt-1920s. How do they describe the book? General Sir Rochford Faughles said



And? And whom? No matter. Turn instead to the celebrated sapient dog and critic, Sir Collie Wilkins, who identified the key elements of the story as comprising:



All in all: tasty.



The following image has nothing to do with Eric Brown, and is in no way intended as a caricature of him.



Sunday, 5 October 2014

Joe Abercrombie, Half A King (2014)



Half a review. Prince Yarrrvi, descended perchance from pirates, is set the task of regaining his Aberkingdom by an Abercruel fate. Though born an Abercripple (and thus considered the titular 'half' mentioned on the book's abercover) Yarrrvi must use his Abercleverness and his one Abercapable hand to regain the Abercrown he never Abercraved in the first place, overcoming abadversity, hardship, double-abercrossing and the general Abercrappiness of the Abercosmos's attitudes to mortals. Trust no-one; for even those Aberclosest to you can betray you into slabery, sorry, slavery. In a nutshell, this is a lean, chilled, typically well-abercrafted tale. The world Joe has Abercreated is Abercrisply evoked; the Abercharacters work well; the violence, though Abercranked down a notch from First Law (this being YA), is Abercrimson enough for most palates. Most of all it's immensely, rather disgracefully readable: gripping and twisty. An Abercracking yarn. If I had one Abercriticism to make, it would be that

Saturday, 4 October 2014

Michael R. Underwood, Attack the Geek: a Ree Reyes Side-quest (2014)



I disliked this book. I also misliked it, unliked it, de-liked it and anti-liked it. Maybe if I'd read the previous 'Ree Reyes' novels that latter reaction wouldn't have been so anti. But then again, do we really need the previous instalments when Underwood gives us the kind of complete summation of character of which Proust himself, were he alive, would surely be envious? 'Ree Reyes (Strength 10, Dexterity 14, Stamina 12, Will 18, IQ 16, Charisma 15—Geek 7/Barista 3/Screenwriter 3/Gamer Girl 2/Geekomancer 2)' [13]. Rees and her pals are able to access magic skills, plus Harry Potter wands and lightsabres and so on, by invoking various genre pop-culture references; and these they use to fight goblins, gnomes, minotaurs and other monsters through sewers and geek boutiques ('bout-giques'?) called things like 'Grognard's Grog and Games'. It's a sort of D&D game come to life, and the longer it went on the more tiresome and charmless I found it. It wants to be Buffy; but Buffy had dialogue to die for. This book has (to pick some examples at random) '"Thou shalt not fuck with one of thy best friend's relationships" she told herself' [19]; "You know what? Fuck you, you worthless piece of shit." [52]; '"Holy Shit!" Rees said.' [117]; '"The fuck?" Rees asked' [128]; "Motherfucking fireballs" [174]. Oscar Fucking Wilde it fucking ain't. The plot is a hectic mishmash of bewildering interactions, fighting, swearing and running through shit. But the real problem is the author's inability to bridge the 'you had to be there' divide. The point of this book is to capture some of the joy (a genuine and wondrous joy) we feel when we hang out without friends and do fun things, like playing games. You try to pass the joy along, saying 'we had a blast man! Eastwood said this really hilarious thing!' But when you repeat the hilarious thing, you find your interlocutors are only smiling politely, and not dissolving in helpless laughter the way you did. Now, a writer worth her/his salt can recreate the ambience and make the hilarity come alive again. Underwood can't do this.

But that's fine. Your dice-age may vary, and I (Pomposity 10, Fondness-for-Nabokov 9, Englishness 879) am surely not the target audience here. But, at the risk of pushing my pomposity score even higher, I found myself wondering whether this short novel figures not as a celebration of geek culture and in-crowd together, but instead as an indictment of it. When your friends swear, especially swear inventively, it is funny, because they're your friends, and you know they don't actually mean to harm you. But when somebody you don't know swears at you it is unpleasant and intimidating and scary. There are reasons why the idiom of courtesy is the right one for public interactions. But SF, in its faceless online conversations, very often loses sight of this. I'm guessing this is compounded of the fact that (a) if I swear aggressively in, say, a tweet, you may decide to take this as a sign that (though we've never met) you and I are friends, and grant me leeway. So perhaps the hyperprofane idiom is assumed by some to be a kind of bonding ritual. There may also (b) be a failure of empathy, or more complexly a failure to understand that the Other who has never met you has no grounds to empathise with you, behind this: the fabled asperger's-spectrum personality limitations of the geek. So if I tweet that (to pick an example out of the air) Paolo Bacigalupi should have acid thrown in his face for his portrayal of Thai characters, it may be that you assume everyone will know you aren't serious. Hey! Nobody who knows me would think I would actually throw acid in anyone's face! The failing here, of course, is that other people, including the textually assaulted Bacigalupi himself, don't know you, and have no reason to give you the benefit of any doubt. Verbal assault is still assault. Then again, (c) I wonder if the main problem is a broader inability of tonal nuance. If Geek A has a disagreement with another person over some matter, and addresses him/her with 'Fuck you. You can fucking bleed-out in a back alley while I sit watching you, sipping my caffè macchiato'. Perhaps Geek A thinks that the main effect of such expression is to convey just how vehemently s/he feels about the point at issue. But that's not the main effect. The main effect is to paint Geek A as callous and violent. The vehemence is in service of a deeply unattractive pointed discourtesy. There are better ways of disagreeing; and by better I mean 'more effective' for any metric of effective you prefer. And there are much, much better ways of writing insults into books. Let it be written in ten-foot-high letters in the public agora of genre, that nobody miss it: VEHEMENCE AND VIOLENCE ARE NOT THE SAME THING.

Marcus Sedgwick, The Ghosts of Heaven (2014)



[Note. There are four quarters to this review; they can be read in any order and the review will work. The four quarters assembled here are in just one of twenty-four possible combinations; this order makes one kind of snark, but the reader should feel free to choose a different opinion of the book, if desired.]

QUARTER ONE.
Not 'first quarter', but, instead, 'quarter one', like that.
Ever-so-slightly unidiomatic.
No matter. For the whole section is
written
in a diffuse kind of
verse. A stone age girl
sees a spiral carved in the rock, in a cave.
Under ground, under-
powered. Some great novels have
been able to pull-off the 'start with a long poem'
malarkey.
Not this. The problem,
the problem is the verse
just isn't
very good.

QUARTER TWO. The Witchfinder General rode into the 17th-century English village his heart full of malice. Devilry was everywhere! Oh, nobody calls him the Witchfinder General. Oh, nobody marks his physical resemblance to Vincent Price. They think he's just the new vicar. But he sees the simple villagers dancing their spiral dance in the graveyard! He smells out their unreformed pagan rituals!

Ah but the villagers have the social cohension of a Simpsons instamob, and are easily persuaded to turn. Drown the witch! Drown pretty young redheaded Anna Tunstall, whose mother has just died! And (when her brother pulls her out of the pond and saves her life) put her on trial!

'If you please sir,' said the virtuous, sobbing young Anna. 'It's all a misunderstanding! This is no Vincent Price-era schlocky Hammer melodrama! No, no, sir, it is a focussed tragedy after the manner of Arthur Millers Crucible!'

'Silence wench!' screamed Father Escrove, spittle flying from his withered lips. The whole courthouse moaned. 'Nuance and subtlety are the Devil's cruet set! We aim for a broader emotional response, here! So I order: strip this toothsome young redhead naked, here in the very courthouse, for all to see how attractive, er, I mean, how witchy-wicked she is!'

QUARTER THREE. It's the 1920s. The spacious insane asylum in upstate New York is build around a large spiral staircase. Spirals you see. You're starting to see how this works? You're grokking the Cloud-Atlasishness? Anna saw the same rock-carved spiral under the water, as they were trying to drown her, as the cavegirl saw, and there's bound to be a plethora of spirals in this section too. Shells, waves, but most of all stairs. There's a mad poet inmate who watches the sea obsessively (his famous collection of poetry is called On Drowning), and one of the asylum doctors mourning his drowned wife Caroline. Dexter is terrified of the staircase; so the bullying Asylum Director forces him to look at him at it ('Dexter's eyes were wide with terror as he looked to the very top of the building where that fine spiral staircase ascends into the cupola, and he screamed a long and empty scream, a howl from the bottom of his mind, that spoke of the unnameable horror at the world before him' [25]. Wait, how can the scream be both empty and speaking?) Of course the Asylum director is a cackling villain, and his hired goons are violent rapists. Of course our narrator is a sensitive, troubled soul.

QUARTER FOUR. Stardate 2001 plus howevermany years. Starman Keir Bowman (seriously; that's the dude's name) is on route for 'New Earth' in the constellation of Lyca. He is woken every ten years to perform 12 hours of shipboard duties. A couple thousand passengers in deep sleep, ready to be woken at the far end of the journey, and he the caretaker-astronaut. But people are dying in their Longsleep pods. What about all the stuff to do with spirals? 'Spiral rotation of galaxies ... the hurricane eye of Jupiter ... the motion of the Earth ... the DNA inside him' [371]  ME: Affirmative, Book. I read you. BOOK: Open the pod bay deeper cosmic significances, Adam. ME: I'm sorry, Book. I'm afraid I can't do that. BOOK: What's the problem? ME: I think you know what the problem is just as well as I do.

Monday, 29 September 2014

Gareth L. Powell, Hive Monkey (2014)



[Steve Wright voice-over]: so, pop-pickers, now that the Beeb has excised all the material fronted by Savile, DLT and the other Yewtree disgracees, there's hardly any usable TOTP2 footage left! But I'm still here, have no fear, to talk you through this classic hit. It's the follow up to the BSFA award-winning Ack-Ack Macaque, and as kink-y a tune as you could hope for. The original Ack-Ack Macaque, as you know very well pop-pickers, was an old fashioned SF yarn, a twisty-turny plot written in efficient storytelling prose that never got in its reader's way, full of high adventures and fun and neat spins on classic genre tropes, but all tied-together with the marvellous central creation, the titular simian, cybernetically uplifted from computer-game duties and into Powell's future world. Ack-Ack's genius was his attitude: his overall foul-mouthed, cigar chewing, spitfire-flying, trigger-happy, "monkey fucks given? None" in-your-hairless-face ness. It is a splendid creation: the Hyde to our 21st-century Jekylls. In the afterword to Hive Monkey, Powell references the old PG Tips television ads; and part of Ack-Ack's appeal I think resides in the sense we viewers had that those chimps-in-human-clothes, shifting pianos and grinning idiotically, were secretly really really pissed off at having so demeaningly to cavort for the diversion of homo sapiens. Ack-Ack is one such, but without the need to act nice for the cameras. I assume, too, that Powell at some point in the past has clocked these old Hellboy panels:



... except that Powell's monkey wears clothes. So anyway (and noting, in passing, how little I sound like Steve Wright, I know, I know) Hive Monkey picks up where the first novel stopped, offering its readers more of the same. Some of the shine is inevitably taken off the conceit, now that it's not brand-new any more; and some of this second Ack-Ack story is a little in-his-dinted-steps-he-trod. It's still great fun, though. The ape, now world-famous, is working a low-profile as a zeppelin pilot. Adventure starts when a passenger on the dirigible encounters his own double, bleeding to death, in his cabin. We get a similarly Ack-Ack Macaque front-loading of action, although perhaps a slightly less dense level of cool-ideation; this time the story involves parallel dimensions, a weird religion called the 'Gestalt', Neanderthal assassins, a second cyber-enhanced monkey, a plot to rule the world through mind-control and a high quotient of bang!-bang!-bang! It's not Proust, pop-pickers! But it has no desire to be. The main misstep, I thought, was the inclusion of a rather self-indulgent SF writer character, there in part to enable a series of not-very-amusing in-jokes and genre-mockery-mockeries. And if I, Steve Wright, the in-the-afternoon Steve Wright, not the US comedian, and certainly not the pompous prof who usually reviews here ... if (I say) I felt a touch peeved by the ending, it's perhaps because its knight's-move lurch into oddity seemed to me a naked pitch for Ack-Ack #3. Still, the fans won't mind that, pop-pickers! Wait. Wa-a-ait a minute. 'Pop-pickers' isn't my phrase, at all. That's Alan 'Fuff' Freeman, isn't it?

Shit.

Well, without further ado, pop-pickers, here's the Ack-Ackinks, and "Ape Man".



I think I'm sophisticated
Cos I'm reading my genre like a good lit-e-rary fan
But all around me actual readers are preferring
Something less airy-fairy, man.
Though you might think I'm a rip-off of the side-kick off-of Generator Rex, man
Compared to the other kinds of primate-uplift texts (man)
I am an Ack-Ack.

I'm a bit Dirty Harry and a bit Richard Scarry
And a little bit like Ape-X
But with genre pollination and inflation and apeflation
We're all living in the Matrix.
I don't feel safe in this World Of Powell;
Drinking and shooting and a-practising my scowl;
A face like prosthetics worn by Roddy McDowall --
I am an Ack-Ack.

I'm an Ack-Ack, I'm an Ack-Macaque, I'm an ape man
I'm a Throw Back man, I'm a sweary man
I'm an ape man

Cos compared to the books that aim to be nice
Compared to the stories that anthromorphise
Compared to the space-bugs and malignant AIs
I am an ape man.
I'm an Ack-Ack, I'm an Ack-Macaque, I'm an ape man
I'm a Throw Back man, I'm a sweary man
I'm an ape man.
I look out my window, but I can't see the sky
Cos my own cigar-smoke is a-fucking up my eye
I want to get out of this story alive
And swear like an ape man.
I'm an Ack-Ack, I'm an Ack-Macaque, I'm an ape man
I'm a Throw Back man, I'm a sweary man
I'm an ape man.

Saturday, 27 September 2014

Tom Harper, Zodiac Station (2014)



What we have here is a very competently handled Arctic thriller. US Coast Guard ice-breaking cutter Terra Nova is working the frozen Nansen Basin when a desperate man comes looming out of the mist, skiing across the ice, and is shot by a startled security detail. The man lives, and in the vessel's sickbay tells his story: he is called Thomas Anderson, and has come from the research base Zodiac Station hundreds of kilometres away, a place full of (as Anderson tells it) high-strung scientists and administrators, a crucible of murder of conspiracy and violence. The base has now been exploded, as if by a bomb. As it happens, I have likewise planted a major spoiler in this review too, in the second paragraph, and it may well explode your enjoyment of reading the novel (if you haven't already read it). You have been warned. Otherwise, the authorities fly to Zodiac, and recover other survivors, who tell a rather different tale to Anderson. There are schemes and counter-schemes by climate scientists and climate change deniers in the pay of big industry, CIA involvement, freaky science, many polar bears; there's loads of zipping across the ice, exploring abandoned mines, falling down crevasses. As is the way with 'classic' thrillers a good deal of Quite Interesting Facticity is kneaded into the running-around, exploring, shooting, threatening-and-being-threatened plotline. The reader learns a good deal about the far north, about methane and arctic fauna and how you have to lift a snowmobile's back-end off the ice before you fire it up, since if its treads have got frozen to the ice you'll burn out the engine. Which is all fine. I thought the book starts very well, and then dissipates itself in a too-many-plotlines, too-many-red-herrings middle section. It might be that the red herrings looked redder and more obvious than they would otherwise have done, set against the bright white background of the ice-pack. Then there's the ending.

So, yes: spoiler. The brighter-hued herrings swim away to their red sea, and we're left with the normal-coloured herring -- Zodiac Station is a reworking of Frankenstein, taking its cue from the powerful initial and final scenes of Shelley's novel, also set, of course, on the polar ice. The Terra Nova is Harper's version of Walton's ship; the creature is genetically engineered instead of being stitched together from corpseparts but is still called The Creature, still stronger and cleverer than us, still a full grown adult of only a few years mental maturity and so on. Now all this is fine by me, and a fairly clever reveal; and looking back over the narrative lots of things (names, clues, quotations from Milton) drop into place. But it's tricky too. It's the two stools problem. For a SF geek like me, there's something anticlimactic about bringing in the Novum only at the very end; it ought to have been the starting point. Whereas a fan of straight thrillers (and Harper has written several of those, with considerable commercial and fannish success) is liable to agree with this Goodreads reviewer, who says: 'Good page turning thriller. A good few twists to keep you guessing. Fairly believable plot right up to the end where it does get a bit silly.' Hmm.

Wednesday, 24 September 2014

Emmi Itäranta, Memory of Water (2011, 2014)



Amongst the many impressive things about Emmi Itäranta's debut novel Memory of Water is the fact that its author wrote the book in her native Finnish and also in English. It was published (as Teemestarin kirja) in Finland in 2011; and now, like Beckett, she has become her own autotranslator, with an English version, Memory of Water. What's doubly remarkable is that the English is as good as it is, considerably better than many a native-speaker I could mention. Like Hannu Rajaniemi, Itäranta is capable of writing not just serviceable but actively beautiful English prose. I admire, too, the way this novel is content to tell a plain story, eschewing the bang!-bang!-bang! attention grabbing hyperactivity of too much contemporary genre fiction, proceeding by inflection and rather than clunking direct statement.

It is set in a post climate-meltdown world where the freshwater rivers, lakes and springs have all dried. Water is now a precious resource, and a zealous, oppressive military guard it, permitting each family only the one official water-pipe that is plumbed into their house, and from which a trickle of ill-tasting fluid drips. The narrator, Noria Kaitio, is the 17-year-old daughter of a 'tea master'; for although being set somewhere in the after-disaster Scandianavian/Baltic/West Russian area, there's a strong Japanese cultural inflection here: raking the gravel garden, respecting the elaborate rituals of tea preparation. Mr Kaitio has access to a secret and pure spring; if the military find out it'll be curtains for the whole family. Meanwhile, Noria and a friend uncover an old recording that seems to contain information contradicting the official history.

So, to stay with the good for a moment longer: the relationship between Noria and her father, written with immense sensitivity and delicacy, is genuinely touching, especially when she graduates against the odds to tea master herself and he [spoiler] dies. And the novel's world is vividly evoked, its parched people so bothered by horrid insects they can't go outside without donning an 'insect hood', rummaging through the heaps of rotting and discoloured plastic our culture bequeathed them. But vividly, oddly enough, doesn't necessarily equate to plausibly or suspensive-of-disbelief. And to be frank I didn't really believe it. Early on, Noria's friend Sanja buys some water from a travelling salesman, and reacts furiously that she's been conned: 'bloody sham sold me salt water! I tasted the water first, like I always do, and it was fresh' [16]. Noria explains the ruse ('a double-pipe fraud ... inside the dias there's a secret container with salt water in it. The pipe has two settings ...') But by this stage I'm thinking: the world clearly has no shortage of brine, for the ice caps have melted (Noria's mournfully reflects that she will never see the glorious ice packs of history). And desalination is not hard to manage; a couple of glass bowls and a transparent plastic sheet in the sunlight will do the trick. Accordingly I did not believe that the military would be able to control water distribution so totally, or that water for personal use would be so scarce.

But I know what you're thinking. You're thinking: 'why must you read in so deadeningly literal-minded a manner?' I concede it; it is my curse, for I have a narrowly literal mind and never read poetry. And I'm certainly prepared to accept that Memory of Water figures more metaphorically and pseudo-poetically than it does by any of the restrictive codes of Hard SF plausibility. Water in this novel 'remembers' the abuse humanity inflicted upon the world, both in the sense that it carries the pollutants in its body, and in a more spiritual sense. And Itäranta is good on the intermittencies and strangeness of memory: 'memory has a shape of its own, and it's not always the shape of life' [92] is how Noria puts it. Although in places awkwardly done, there is something commendable in the way Itäranta structures her novel to try to reflect that queer shape. But, at the grave risk of alienating your sympathy altogether, dear reader: too often her poetic-prosy meditations on the nature of water seemed to my ear like unto the sounding brass and tinkling cymbal of pure Fotherington-Thomasness. Too many of these passages read like slogans from inspirations posters, ready to printed over pastel photographs of morning-misty landscapes, or purple-and-cyan mountain peaks arrayed beneath a full moon starry sky.
Water is the most versatile of all elements ... Water walks with the moon and embraces the earth, and it isn't afraid to die in fire or live in air. When you step into it, it will be as close as your own skin, but if you hit it too hard, it will shatter you. [5]
It's all the way through the book:
Water is the most versatile of all elements. It isn't afraid to burn in fire or fade into the sky, it doesn't hesitate to shatter against sharp rocks in rainfall or drown into the dark shroud of the earth. It exists beyond all beginnings and ends. [221]
You may indeed, if your soul be less crusted and derelict than mine, find this uplifting and beautiful. Your moisture, that is, mileage, may vary. Water is delicate, and evaporates and evanishes; but it is also strong as a mighty tide or tsunami, when each individual water droplet says to its fellow, 'let me add my strength to yours'.



PS: And wholly unrelated to this novel, my favourite motivational posters remain these Malcolm Tucker ones.